From the beginning of the story, Lois is noted to have a disconnect from nature. She "is relieved not to have to worry about the lawn, or about the ivy . . . or the squirrels." She lives in an apartment where the focus is the artwork she's collected. Interestingly, the pictures give her no sense of peace and "fil[l] her with a wordless unease."

The narrative then uses flashback to take the reader back to a young Lois. At this age, she attends camp each summer and befriends Lucy. Lucy is from Chicago and has a fair amount of family wealth; she has a full-time maid (while Lois's family can only afford help a couple of days a week) and lives in a gated lake community.

During their first summer there together, Lois shows Lucy around the camp. Lucy isn't all that impressed but is resolved to make the best of it. The girls write letters throughout the school year, signing their letters LL "with the L's entwined together like the monograms on a towel." When they meet again at camp, they have to readjust to the differences to being together in person, but they always reunite with life updates that haven't been expressed in their letters.

Over the years, Lucy's life changes quite a bit. She learns ballet and then horseback riding. Her mother and father divorce and she acquires a new stepfather. She decides that she doesn't like her stepfather, but she doesn't want to live with her father and his new wife either. She finds her mother kissing a doctor in the driveway. By contrast, Lois's life remains pretty "placid" summer after summer.

When they are fourteen, a group of campers embarks on a weeklong canoe trip. Lucy is "apathetic" about the trip, finally settling in to the idea with "a sigh of endurance." The counselors hold a ceremony the night before sending the campers on their adventure. They are told that they will be gone for "many moons," which Lois realizes is not true, because the length of the journey is only a few days. Still, these words make the water seem "immense and a little frightening."

The girls row steadily all day and camp at night. Lois and Lucy convince the leaders to allow them to sleep alone and outside the tent. Under the stars, Lucy tells Lois that, "it would be nice not to go back . . . to Chicago." The tone is ominous, as Lucy's future seems more and more certain in conjunction with the title.

The next day, the girls row over a "flat calm" lake, skimming along a glassy surface, which seems to set up a false sense of security. They stop to have lunch at Lookout Point, and Lois and Lucy ask to hike up to the lookout while lunch is being prepared. The climb is steep, and the girls are sweating when they reach the top. Lois thinks her friend is "nuts" when Lucy tells her, "It would be quite a dive off here." Lucy reasons that the water has to be deep as she stands precariously near the edge.

Lucy has to use the bathroom before hiking back down, and Lois hands her some toilet paper before stepping back down the trail a bit to give her friend some privacy. At exactly noon, she hears "the shout." In retrospect, as an adult, she recalls that it was not a shout of fear. It was more of a cry of surprise. Lois rushes back to the spot where she left Lucy, and she can't find her. She...