Summary and Analysis: Part 1—The First Hearing—Chapters 10-12

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 990

New Characters
Hare-lip (also known as "Kieffer"): Rubashov's fellow prisoner, who is later revealed to have implicated him in an effort to kill No. 1

Writing an essay?
Get a custom outline

Our Essay Lab can help you tackle any essay assignment within seconds, whether you’re studying Macbeth or the American Revolution. Try it today!

Start an Essay

Little Loewy: a leader of the Party in a Belgian port town

Summary
The scene returns to Rubashov in his cell, looking out the window to realize he has spent almost four hours walking in the cell. Two men, one of whom has a hare-lip, are walking on the prison yard's path. "Hare-lip" looks up at Rubashov's window, directly above the path. Rubashov asks No. 402 who he is. No. 402 says that Hare-lip, No. 400, is also imprisoned for "POLITICAL DIVERGENCIES" and was tortured yesterday. As he begins smoking his last cigarette, Rubashov thinks, "I will pay my fare." He visualizes Richard and the cab driver pursuing him and threatening him because of supposed betrayal and cheating.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

Rubashov's request for more cigarettes is rejected by the warder, and he responds by cursing the warden. He is told that this will be reported. No. 402 offers to give Rubashov some tobacco. The warden replies that this is not allowed, and Rubashov ponders whether or not he must pay for his past deeds even if they "'were right and necessary.'" No. 402 tells him that Hare-lip sends his greetings to Rubashov but that Hare-lip does not tell Rubashov his name.

It is the afternoon of the day of his arrest. Rubashov's thoughts linger on memories of his life in the Party and the situation both he and the Party are in. He recalls himself in an old Belgian port on Party business, two years after expelling Richard from the Party. In the interval, he had returned to the homeland to see many of his old Party colleagues dead and expelled from Party memory. Dismayed and afraid of this, he requested an assignment abroad and went to Belgium, where he met Little Loewy. Little Loewy had helped make the dock workers' section of the port town a model that the Party encouraged others to emulate. Little Loewy showed him around the port and its pubs. Little Loewy told Rubashov about his past exploits, including his days as a man without a country, shuffling between France and Belgium and killing cats to stay alive. Although complaining about the Party's treatment of him during this hard time, Little Loewy eventually made his way into the traditional hierarchy and recognition of the Party.

Homework Help

Latest answer posted May 10, 2007, 12:14 am (UTC)

3 educator answers

Rubashov met with the local Party cell in the port to discuss the Party's shipments of minerals and petrol to a "dictatorship in the heart of Europe" and "another hungry dictatorship in the south of Europe," both of whom the Party had called upon the workers of the world to boycott. Many of the dockworkers who were Party members left the Party over the minerals shipment, not understanding how such a contradiction as supplying an ideologically opposed country could possibly be resolved. As the petrol shipment neared the port, Rubashov met with the leading Party members to explain that the shipments were necessary to aid the industrial development of the Party homeland. Little Loewy and the other Party members expressed their skepticism about this rationale and opposed the shipment. Rubashov communicated with Party officials, who expelled the leaders of the dockworkers' section and denounced Little Loewy. In response, Little Loewy hanged himself three days later.

Analysis
The introduction of Hare-lip, the reason for his punishment, and his staring at Rubashov's cell, combined with Rubashov's thought that "I will pay my fare," prompts the readers to wonder how Hare-lip is linked to Rubashov and what the consequences of this link will be. Since Hare-lip has undergone torture, another uncertain element is added to the ominous atmosphere of Rubashov's imprisonment.

The theme of Rubashov's bluntly physical circumstances continues with his desire for food and cigarettes, and his insult to the warder. And yet much of the novel so far is taken up with Rubashov's inner life. This inner life keeps him from being absolutely trapped by his cell's walls, as he is still free to recollect and consider his Party's past and its consequences. His memory also ranges across intellectual and philosophical disagreements with the Party and Party actions, revealing that even someone high up in the Party can have significant bones of contention. Yet by revealing that Rubashov turned Little Loewy in to the Party members as a dissident, Koestler illustrates that Rubashov's current plight is one that Rubashov has created for others. Still, Koestler does not seem to imply that Rubashov's imprisonment is just or right, merely that it fits with the philosophy Rubashov has been acting upon and with.

The Party's brutality has helped produce the extermination of many high ranking, former leaders of the Party, including those who helped found the Party and put Stalin in power. Koestler then exemplifies these contradictions by explaining Rubashov's visit to the Belgian port to meet Little Loewy and other Party denizens. Rubashov flees the Soviet homeland because of No. 1's extermination of many powerful leaders. This extermination and its accompanying changes to attitudes toward Party founders show that for the Party, history is malleable. So, when it becomes necessary for goods to be shipped to the Fascist dictatorships in Germany and Italy, prior vows of resistance against those nations is replaced by practical expediency. The Party workers do not buy this line of reasoning, but Rubashov conveys it and their reaction, and thus is the vehicle for their betrayal. The philosophy of exporting Communism fails in the face of practical need for goods and money, but the workers refuse to accept this compromise.

Since the end justifies the means, these shipments are defended as a way to strengthen the Soviet homeland. Rubashov was sent to Belgium to convey this message to the port, but its individual consequence was that Little Loewy killed himself. Now, in prison, Rubashov is joining Little Loewy and Richard as individual casualties of No. 1 and the Party's ever-changing morality.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Summary and Analysis: Part 1—The First Hearing—Chapters 8-9

Next

Summary and Analysis: Part 1—The First Hearing—Chapters 13-14