Canto 5 Summary
As Dante moves down from the First Circle, he soon discovers that the Second Circle is more tormenting. As he continues to go deeper into Hell, he encounters sinners who are guilty of the sin of lust. At the entrance to the Second Circle, the mythical figure King Minos serves as the guard; each soul must admit their sins to Minos, who determines their punishment. The atmosphere is gloomy, and the cries of the damned are audible to Dante, even from the gates.
Dante and Virgil pass through the Second Circle of Hell and observe a bevy of familiar figures, condemned to an afterlife of torment for their lustful ways. Among them, he sees the mistress of Babel, as well as historical figures, such as Cleopatra and Helen, who succumbed to their desires and embraced licentiousness. Dante also observes many men who succumbed to lust and are now suffering in this circle, including famous mythological characters such as Achilles, Paris, and Tristram, whom Dante is able to identify due to his expansive knowledge of history and mythology.
Dante converses with Francesca, who was married to Gianciotto da Verucchio but was intimately involved with his brother, Paolo. She explains how she and Paulo would read about the love affair of Sir Lancelot and Guinevere and of the story of Gallehault, adoring the shared aspects of their adulterous but loving relationships. Francesca adds that her story ends poorly, as her husband killed her after discovering her infidelity. Dante expresses his empathy towards Francesca and Paolo and is overwhelmed with pity.
Expert Q&A
What is the purpose of Dante's allusions to Minos and lustful mythological figures in Inferno's canto 5?
Dante's allusions to Minos and lustful mythological figures in Canto 5 serve to emphasize the theme of judgment and punishment for sins of lust. Minos, a familiar figure to Dante's audience, acts as a judge in Hell, reflecting his mythological role. Figures like Helen of Troy and Achilles illustrate that even the powerful are not exempt from punishment for lust, reinforcing Dante's humanist engagement with classical literature.
How does Dante address the sin of lust using contrapasso in canto 5 of Inferno?
In Canto 5 of Inferno, Dante uses contrapasso to address the sin of lust by mirroring the sinners' lack of self-control in life with their punishment in death. The lustful are eternally swept in a dark, relentless storm, symbolizing their betrayal of reason for passion. This punishment reflects their earthly surrender to carnal desires, with darkness representing the absence of reason and holiness they forsook.
How does the story of Paolo and Francesca in Dante's Inferno canto V relate and not relate to romantic or courtly love?
Francesca and Paolo's story in Dante's "Inferno" reflects both romantic and courtly love, as their affair was sparked by reading about Lancelot and Guinevere. However, their sin transcends romance, symbolizing the prioritization of desire over reason. Their punishment of being eternally buffeted by winds mirrors their lack of control. Dante's initial sympathy for them, influenced by Francesca's storytelling, highlights the tension between carnal lust and spiritual love, a theme central to his journey.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.