International Theme: America vs. Europe
Daisy Miller, which was first published in England's Cornhill Magazine in 1878, remains one of Henry James's most cherished works. It incorporates elements of the novel of manners, a genre that often, but not always, uses satire to portray the behaviors, traditions, and values typical of a specific social class in a certain time and place. In this narrative, James begins his early exploration of the "international theme," highlighting the contrast between the manners and cultures of American tourists in Europe and those of Americans who have lived abroad long enough to adopt European customs. This America-Europe contrast is represented through themes such as innocence versus experience, spontaneity versus ritual, naturalness versus artificiality, and frankness versus duplicity. By examining these contrasts, James infuses his story with significant social, psychological, and moral implications.
Critique of Victorian Society and Women's Roles
Through Daisy, the narrative highlights the ways in which Victorian society restricted women's intellectual development and personal autonomy. Without adequate education, Daisy is unfamiliar with the destinations she explores and acknowledges that she couldn't tutor her brother, who is preparing for college, unlike her. While Winterbourne can engage with strangers, go wherever he wants, and express his opinions openly, Daisy's comparable behavior is considered scandalous, leading others to scrutinize her character.
Psychological Theme: Response to Societal Conventions
In addition to its social critique, James's story explores a psychological theme about how people react to societal norms. Those at the top of the social ladder strictly follow established customs and expect others to do the same. Winterbourne's aunt, Mrs. Costello, is so certain of Daisy's impropriety that she refuses even to meet her. Likewise, the ironically named Mrs. Walker sternly warns Daisy that walking alone at dusk will tarnish her reputation and becomes upset when Daisy ignores her warning. It is based on these perceptions, rather than any actual wrongdoing, that Daisy is eventually shunned by the upper-class American expatriate community in Rome.
Because we are never given insight into Daisy's thoughts, we cannot tell whether she is unaware of the stringent rules for young unmarried women or if she consciously chooses to defy them. Regardless of her motives, she effectively asserts her independence. Daisy continues to spend time with Giovanelli, a charming young Italian suspected of being a fortune-hunter. She is seen with him in relatively private settings, walks with him without a chaperone, and eventually goes with him to the Colosseum at night. However, after Winterbourne "cuts" her at the Colosseum, she seems to lose her zest, perhaps realizing that she cannot maintain her individuality while also seeking social acceptance.
Moral Judgment and Categorical Thinking
A central theme centers on the ethical dilemma of judging individuals based on preconceived notions. Winterbourne embodies this tendency as he navigates the story trying to label Daisy and figure out how to interact with her. He vacillates between viewing her as "a pretty American flirt," "an unscrupulous young person," and "an inscrutable combination of audacity and innocence." To his frustration, her actions consistently defy his attempts to categorize her. His indecision lingers until the night he observes her with Giovanelli at the Colosseum, when he decides, with relief, that "she was a young lady whom a gentleman need no longer be at pains to respect." Ultimately, Winterbourne realizes he wrongfully judged Daisy due to his inflexibility, but this realization does not prompt a change in his values. He returns to Geneva unchanged. Although no explicit judgment is made, he is implicitly depicted as a failure. His interaction with Daisy was a moral test of his ability to move beyond his dependence on categorical thinking, to connect with people as individuals rather than stereotypes, and to perceive life beyond the constraints of narrow conventions.