Initiation into Womanhood
The themes of Daddy Was a Number Runner fall conveniently into three ever-enlarging circles of meaning: from self to family to community. The central meaning of the novel is Francie’s initiation into womanhood, and it is no easy journey. “Finally it was summer and I was thirteen,” she declares toward the end of her story—but she also realizes she is “stuck here in my black valley” where “nothing was too much fun anymore.”
Sexual Roles and Behavior
On one level, the whole novel is about sexual roles and behavior, for sex pervades this novel more than most about adolescence. It is a violent sexual world that Francie inhabits: She is fondled by Mr. Morristein the butcher, by Max the baker, by men on the roof of her building and by men in the park, and other men expose themselves to her or offer to pay to touch her. Everywhere Francie goes, she encounters this sexual abuse. (Her own sexual awakening actually occurs when she is being molested in a darkened theater.) By the end of the novel, though, she has overcome the abuse: She knees Max the baker, and thus symbolically ends the sexual exploitation.
Family and Identity
This character or identity she gains in part from her family, from her mother and father and her two brothers. Daddy Was a Number Runner is a historically accurate portrait of the Depression-era black family, in all its strengths and weaknesses. The author shows all the pressures that bear on this institution, and by the book’s end, Francie recognizes how many black males are gone: dead, in prison, or (like her father) escaped. It is the women, such as Francie’s mother, who must carry on.
Racial Identity and Community
This family theme is inextricably connected to the larger question of what it means to be black in Harlem. In a revealing episode, a white teacher tries to get Francie to think of becoming a seamstress, but Francie holds out her dream of one day working as a secretary. “I don’t know why they teach courses like that to frustrate you people,” the teacher sighs. Throughout the novel, Francie hears the answer: the words of Adam Clayton Powell, Jr. (a famous Harlem minister) and other African Americans who give Francie a political analysis of what is wrong with this racist society—and the tools to change it. By the end of the novel, Francie finds herself rooting for the Indians in the Western films she attends, and she has come to love Harlem:I wanted to hug them all. We belonged to each other somehow. I’m getting sick, I thought, as I shifted my elbows on the windowsill. I must of caught some rare disease. But that sweet feeling hung on and I loved all of Harlem gently and didn’t want to be Puerto Rican or anything else but my own rusty self.
Community and Ethnic Identity
In the novel’s closing page, Francie qualifies this somewhat: “We was all poor and black and apt to stay that way, and that was that.” But she has learned the values of her black community. For Harlem is a community in Daddy Was a Number Runner , and Meriwether portrays it with all of its warts: an area of crime, of white exploitation, of Jewish-black tensions, of numbers and prostitution and sexual violence—but at the same time a place where ethnic identity acts as a positive force. The Coffins have to borrow money to defend James Junior—but they take in a southern black family that is starving to death on the Harlem streets. Earlier in the novel, James Coffin tells his children of their...
(This entire section contains 165 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
slave heritage, and of Yoruba, their royal African great-great-grandmother, stating that “we got a past to be proud of.” The novel’s pivotal part 2, in which Francie gains a balance of self and community, is called “Yoruba’s Children.”
Psychological Themes
More significant than the social meaning of the story is the psychological, and this is far more subtle, for the eleven-year-old narrator does not always understand the significance of her own life. Like her slightly older fictional cousin, Huck Finn—likewise a first-person narrator of his own adventures—Francie relates incidents that readers must interpret. She wonders what makes her friend Sukie so mean, for example—but Meriwether gives readers all the evidence they need to make the analysis of Sukie’s behavior themselves. Francie cannot articulate the pressures of her own life, let alone recognize them in her friends. She is suspended in that limbo between childhood and adulthood that is not yet adolescence. She still reads fairy tales from the library on her fire escape, and her dreams, such as the fish dream that gives her the winning numbers, aid the family. On the other hand, she witnesses the violence of Depression Harlem, as shown in a reference to mugging any white man caught alone there after sunset, and its poverty, highlighted by her mother searching half an hour for a dime she thought she had lost but that Francie had stolen. She loves her father, who is trying to get her to grow up to be a lady, and still trusts him, wondering why her mother could not. She has not yet learned all the lessons life has taught her mother.
Coming of Age
The story provides clues that Francie will successfully navigate her way out of childhood to adulthood, in spite of the numerous dangers in her world. She is, in fact, halfway there. She is already resourceful and responsible for her family, and at the end of the story, after beating up Sukie, turns her face away from home and wanders aimlessly down Fifth Avenue. Her future will be away from this world. When a mob crowds around her and Sukie, she says, “I was suffocating. I pushed against the black, shoving mass until I was free of them. There was something evil in their sweating black faces, and that something was in me also.” She must flee this world in order to attain her own healthy identity, even if it means wandering aimlessly at first. Readers can only hope for Francie’s future.
Background and Publication
The story was written in the Watts Writers Workshop, which screenwriter and novelist Budd Shulberg started after the Los Angeles riots of 1965. Three years later, Louise Meriwether published a novel based on the story. Although the novel brings in many more significant details, sexual and violent, it does not change the basic thrust of the original short story. In both, readers witness a young girl coming of age against the myriad difficulties of urban Depression life.