Historical Context
Post-World War II
Although World War II had ended several years prior, its impact still lingered
in the minds of people worldwide by 1948. Nations directly affected by the war
were still in the process of economic recovery. To aid in the reconstruction of
Europe, the United States Congress approved the 1947 Marshall Plan.
Concurrently, tensions between the Soviet Union and the United States were
escalating into what Bernard Baruch, an advisor to President Truman, termed the
"Cold War." This conflict's initial act occurred where World War II had
concluded, with Soviet forces initiating a blockade of Berlin on June 24, 1948.
In response, the United States and Britain launched a massive airlift,
delivering 4,500 tons of food and supplies daily until the Soviets lifted the
blockade on September 30, 1949. Domestically, the "Cold War" spurred political
paranoia, leading to the establishment of the "Un-American Activities
Committee." This committee was tasked with investigating individuals suspected
of Communist ties. The most notable case in 1948 involved Alger Hiss, a case
that remains contentious despite Hiss's death and Moscow's assertion that he
was never a spy.
As the two superpowers embarked on an arms race, many British colonies began to fight for their independence. India achieved independence with the guidance of Mahatma Gandhi, who had once lived and been imprisoned in South Africa. In 1948, Gandhi was assassinated by individuals opposed to his acceptance of the partition with Pakistan. Other nations that gained independence during this period included Burma and Israel.
Apartheid in South Africa
South Africa was established in 1910 when the former British colonies of Natal
and Cape merged with the republics of Transvaal and the Orange Free State.
Around this time, the descendants of early Dutch-speaking settlers began
identifying as Afrikaners, referring to their language as Afrikaans, and
aligning with the Afrikaner Nationalist Party. Another significant demographic
in 1910 was the African population, which outnumbered the white settlers. This
group was predominantly tribal in their political organization and lived in
rural areas. However, a demographic shift was underway, reflecting global
trends of migration from rural communities to urban centers. In South Africa,
this shift was largely driven by the rapid expansion of mining and industry,
particularly towards Johannesburg, a burgeoning city built upon gold fields
discovered in 1886.
The Afrikaner Nationalists governed South Africa from 1924 until 1939. In that year, the liberal policies advocated by figures like Jan H. Hofmeyr gained prominence, instilling hope that South Africa might become a more fair and just society. When World War II broke out, South Africa allied with the Allies against Germany. Post-war, there was a significant migration of Africans into urban areas, particularly Johannesburg. Alan Paton's novel Cry, the Beloved Country is set during this post-World War II period. The novel highlights the dual realities of South Africa in 1945. On one side, Africans were striving to survive in shantytowns or in rural areas with depleted soil. Meanwhile, white individuals like Arthur Jarvis were beginning to recognize the issues caused by inequality and were joining forces with other whites to improve conditions for the native population. On the other side, the influx of people and rising crime rates in the cities led to a sense of paranoia among the enfranchised citizens. Consequently, in the 1948 election, following Hofmeyr's death, the Afrikaner Nationalists regained power with promises to restore order.
In 1948, the Afrikaner Nationalists established a government system known as apartheid. This system was akin to Jim Crow laws in the United States, which discriminated against African Americans. However, a critical difference was that apartheid was a national policy that legally enforced racial discrimination. Under this regime, native Africans were confined to designated areas and required to carry "passes" and identity documents at all times. Failure to produce these documents to an official could result in imprisonment or fines. These passes dictated where individuals could travel. The overarching goal of apartheid was to maintain a controlled workforce of nonwhite people under South African rule. Consequently, they suppressed any form of dissent or organization into labor unions or political parties, imprisoning leaders like Nelson Mandela and Steven Biko for state crimes. Recently, Nelson Mandela was released from prison, resumed his role as the head of the African National Congress, and was elected President of South Africa. In 1996, he signed a new constitution for the Republic of South Africa.
Literary Style
Point of View
Paton narrates his story as if it were a dream. The opening phrase, "There is,"
suggests the events are unfolding in the present, although they are not. Using
the present tense gives the story a sense of remoteness while making it feel
possible. The narrative is in the third person, but the narrator is not
omniscient—providing only the necessary information or what would realistically
be known in the context. Consequently, readers never gain deep insights into
the characters, only observing their actions within the storyline. The language
used is reminiscent of Biblical text, with simple prose interspersed with
religious undertones and references. This stylistic choice is influenced by the
main characters being Anglican clergymen and because South Africa, as a
Christian nation, might best understand itself through a parable-like
narrative. This perspective adds significance to Arthur Jarvis's comments and
contributes to the novel's complex self-reflection. The novel is conscious of
its nature as a story told from afar about African affairs. This physical and
narrative distance is crucial to the point of view; while it is a third-person
narrative, it is written from a location far removed from the events described.
Cry, the Beloved Country gained popularity internationally
before it became well-known in its home country.
Dialect
The novel's diction is influenced by the Zulu and Xhosa languages, unsurprising
given its setting among peoples colonized by English speakers. Unique phrases
from these languages are translated into English, creating a beautiful yet
archaic sound. For instance, mature women are addressed as "mother," and
farewells include phrases like "go well, stay well," or simply "stay well."
Today, this prose style may seem outdated. Critics in the 1940s also found
Paton's style somewhat old-fashioned and sentimental. Another example of
native-influenced syntax is the repetition of simple words: "This thing, he
said. This thing. Here in my heart there is nothing but fear. Fear, fear,
fear." This use of local dialect reflects the author's effort to capture
emotion. Effectively conveying emotion in words requires simplicity,
repetition, and concise dialogue between characters. Thus, rather than
appearing patronizing, Paton achieves emotional depth by maintaining simplicity
and incorporating local expressions.
Apostrophe, Aphorism, and Parallelism
Paton's writing bears a strong resemblance to the style often found in Hebrew
poetry. Because of this, Cry, the Beloved Country is frequently
described as quasi-Biblical. Three rhetorical devices shared by both the Bible
and Paton's novel are apostrophe, aphorism, and parallelism. An example of
apostrophe can be found in the title, which is derived from a passage within
the text. This technique involves directly addressing an inanimate object for
sympathy or assistance. The passage begins, "Cry, the Beloved Country for the
unborn child," suggesting that the country is being implored to show mercy
toward the future.
The second device is aphorism, which involves the use of a concise, wise saying. This technique is often utilized in the speech of Msimangu. For instance, "It suited the white man to break the tribe ... but it has not suited him to build something in the place of what is broken." Another example is, "It is fear that rules this land." Through these statements, Msimangu shares wisdom he has gained from careful reflection.
The third technique is parallelism, which appears when Msimangu delivers a sermon in chapter thirteen and the narrator attempts to describe his extraordinary voice. The narrator conveys this through parallelism, relating Msimangu's voice to various objects instead of defining it directly: "For the voice was of gold, and the voice had love for the words it was reading. The voice shook and beat and trembled, not as the voice of an old man shakes and beats and trembles, but as a deep hollow bell when struck...." Parallelism connects descriptive phrases in a series to enhance and amplify the impression of the object being described. Through these serial phrases, the narrator enriches the power of the voice by suggesting what else the voice does or resembles. The voice is compared to valuable things like "gold" and "love," leading the reader to independently appreciate the voice's magnificence, in parallel with Kumalo.
Dramatic Irony
Dramatic irony is a moment of heightened drama that occurs when at least one
character lacks information that the reader possesses. Paton skillfully employs
this technique in chapter twenty-five when Kumalo and Jarvis meet by chance.
Jarvis is unaware of the black clergyman's identity. The two fathers encounter
each other at Barbara Smith's on a day when the court is not in session. Kumalo
is searching for Sibeko's daughter, who was rumored to have worked there.
During this errand, Stephen encounters the father of his son's victim. However,
Jarvis sees only a poor, old, black clergyman. This encounter is highly charged
for the reader and Stephen precisely because one participant is unaware of the
other's identity.
Expert Q&A
The mood and tone in Cry, the Beloved Country
The mood and tone in Cry, the Beloved Country are predominantly somber and reflective. The novel addresses serious issues such as racial injustice and social disparity in South Africa, creating a sense of sorrow and contemplation throughout the narrative. Despite the heavy themes, there is also an underlying tone of hope and resilience.
Setting
Cry, the Beloved Country unfolds in two main settings: the rural village of Ndotsheni and the bustling city of Johannesburg. The dichotomy between these locales highlights the stark contrasts between traditional rural life and the complexities of urban existence. Set in the mid-twentieth century, the narrative captures a pivotal era in South African history, just before apartheid became entrenched as official policy.
Ndotsheni: A Portrait of Rural Life
Ndotsheni, the home of protagonist Stephen Kumalo, is emblematic of the serene yet struggling rural communities of South Africa during this period. Life here is simple and deeply rooted in tradition, offering a sense of unity and continuity among its residents. However, the village faces numerous hardships, such as drought and poverty, which threaten its very survival and drive many young people to seek opportunities elsewhere.
Despite these challenges, Ndotsheni is portrayed as a place of spiritual strength and cultural heritage. It embodies the warmth of familial ties and the richness of community life, sustaining its people through adversity. Kumalo's journey from this village to Johannesburg and back underscores the powerful pull of home and the enduring importance of one's roots.
Johannesburg: The Urban Experience
In stark contrast to Ndotsheni, Johannesburg is depicted as a sprawling metropolis rife with both opportunities and perils. It represents the modern world with its vibrant hustle and bustle, but also its moral and social decay. The city is a magnet for those seeking employment and a better life, yet it is also where many find themselves lost amidst its chaos.
Stephen Kumalo's experience in Johannesburg serves as a narrative vehicle to explore the alienation and fragmentation that can accompany urban life. Here, family bonds are tested, and individuals are often engulfed by the city's overwhelming scale and impersonal nature. The city serves as a microcosm of the broader societal changes occurring in South Africa, a place where traditional values are frequently at odds with the demands of modern urban living.
The Socio-Political Backdrop
The time period in which the novel is set is crucial to understanding its themes and characters. Written between 1945 and 1948, Cry, the Beloved Country captures South Africa on the cusp of institutionalized apartheid. The novel's settings reflect the simmering tensions and disparities that apartheid would later crystallize into law.
During this era, racial segregation was already deeply embedded in South African society, though not yet formalized as apartheid. The novel poignantly illustrates how these divisions impact both rural and urban contexts, revealing the pervasive inequalities and injustices faced by black South Africans. By contrasting the idyllic yet precarious life in Ndotsheni with the harsh realities of Johannesburg, the author offers a powerful commentary on the socio-political landscape that would soon define the nation.
Interconnection of Settings
The interplay between Ndotsheni and Johannesburg is central to the novel's narrative arc. Kumalo's journey from his village to the city mirrors the migration of countless South Africans during this period, driven by necessity rather than choice. This movement underscores the tension between maintaining one's cultural identity and adapting to new environments.
Through this duality of settings, the novel explores themes of displacement, resilience, and hope. It invites readers to consider the impact of setting on individual destinies and to reflect on the broader societal currents that shape our lives. The contrasting worlds of Ndotsheni and Johannesburg serve not only as backdrops but as dynamic characters in their own right, each influencing the story's progression in meaningful ways.
Expert Q&A
How is Ndotsheni described in Cry, the Beloved Country?
Ndotsheni is depicted as a beautiful, remote South African village with lush green landscapes and a strong community spirit. Despite its natural beauty, it faces significant economic challenges, including limited job opportunities and frequent crop failures. Many educated villagers leave for cities like Johannesburg. The future seems bleak due to poor education and weak agriculture, but with Jarvis's assistance in farming techniques, there is hope for improvement.
In Cry, the Beloved Country, how do the conditions of Natal's hills contrast with the valley below?
The conditions of Natal's hills and the valley below highlight stark socio-economic and racial contrasts. The hills, where Jarvis lives, are lush and fertile, symbolizing wealth and power. In contrast, the valley where Stephen resides is dry and barren, unable to sustain its people, forcing them to migrate to Johannesburg. This disparity symbolizes the broader divisions in South Africa, reflecting economic, cultural, and racial inequalities.
In Cry, the Beloved Country, which setting is more moral, Johannesburg or Ndotsheni?
Johannesburg and Ndotsheni represent contrasting moral landscapes in Cry, the Beloved Country. Johannesburg is depicted as morally depraved, with individuals pursuing material wealth at the expense of traditional values and community bonds. In contrast, Ndotsheni embodies greater morality, yet it is a declining world as many leave for urban opportunities. While Ndotsheni may seem more moral, both settings ultimately lack hope and redemption, highlighting the complex moral challenges faced by Black Africans.
Literary Techniques
The style of "Cry, the Beloved Country" is both distinctive and unique. Its diction, symbolism, and imagery seamlessly blend with the Biblical language in which the novel is crafted. The language is straightforward, featuring uncomplicated sentences, and is heavily influenced by Biblical themes, reflecting the protagonist, Stephen Kumalo, a humble village parson. Kumalo, who is not a deeply philosophical character, received his education at a missionary school where the focus was on the Bible and the basics of reading, writing, and arithmetic. Paton also incorporates Zulu and Afrikaans words to emphasize the South African setting. The author thoughtfully includes a glossary for the non-English terms used in the novel. The dialogue in "Cry, the Beloved Country" is highly realistic, typographically distinct, and captures the linguistic and social nuances of the various ethnic groups within the story. Whenever characters, particularly Kumalo, grapple with profound questions or issues requiring divine intervention, the author frequently employs rhetorical questions.
The symbolic elements in the novel are immensely important. The titihoya bird symbolizes the rigid, artificial political divisions in the country. It sings in High Place, the estate of James Jarvis where the land is prosperous, and resources are plentiful. Conversely, the bird is silent in the valley of Ndotsheni, where the black population is deprived of even their basic dignity. Critics have noted that the titihoya cannot sing in this area plagued by exploitation, decay, indifference, ignorance, fear, hatred, and brutality, where agricultural practices are outdated.
The drought at the novel's conclusion, along with the desperate need for rain and water, echoes T. S. Eliot's "The Wasteland" (1922), where water and rain symbolize birth, purification, and love. Here, the absence of rain is both a physical and spiritual death sentence for the valley's inhabitants. The use of Biblical names such as Absalom, Stephen, Peter, and John further enhances the novel's symbolic depth. The name Absalom evokes the disobedience of King David's son, who met a tragic end for betraying his father. Similarly, Absalom causes immense suffering and heartbreak for his elderly father, Stephen Kumalo, mirroring the anguish experienced by St. Stephen, the first Christian martyr.
Absalom Kumalo wishes to name his son Peter, in honor of St. Peter, the rock and founder of the Christian Church. Thus, Peter Kumalo symbolizes the foundation of a new lineage, representing redemption, hope, and restoration. John Kumalo, akin to John the Baptist, seeks a new order of economic justice for the black community. In this regard, he parallels John the Baptist, who heralded the coming of Jesus Christ.
The novel's structure, divided into three parts—Book 1: The Search, Book 2: Trial and Reconciliation, and Book 3: Restoration—mirrors the social divisions and barriers in South Africa.
Paton employs a series of coincidences as a narrative technique, although these sometimes feel forced or artificial. For instance, Arthur Jarvis's son attends a Johannesburg school called St. Marks, the same name as Kumalo's parish. Stephen Kumalo and James Jarvis coincidentally meet in Springs, an East Rand town, at Barbara Smith's house while Kumalo is searching for Sibeko's missing daughter. In Book Three, just as the Bishop considers transferring Stephen Kumalo to Pietermaritzburg to work with Father Ntombela (due to the scandal caused by Absalom and the proximity of the Jarvis family), Jarvis's letter of reconciliation and support arrives. Additionally, James Jarvis pledges to construct a new church in the valley. The Bishop then changes his mind, telling Stephen Kumalo, "I see it is not God's will that you should leave Ndotsheni." Irony and sarcasm are prevalent throughout the novel, particularly in chapter 23. A notable example is Stephen Kumalo's son killing Arthur Jarvis, a champion of native causes, thereby making Arthur a victim of the very issues he fought for.
Arthur Trevelyan Jarvis is never physically present in the novel. His life philosophy, contributions to native causes, and practical efforts to aid the underprivileged are revealed through his manuscripts, letters, artifacts, and library. The inclusion of diaries and manuscripts as part of the narrative is characteristic of Alan Paton's style and is notably used again in Too Late the Phalarope (1952).
The point of view in Cry, the Beloved Country warrants further examination to fully grasp the author's themes. The omniscient narrator reveals the thoughts and actions of the protagonist, as well as those of other characters. However, a parallel narrative emerges through the manuscripts and letters of the late Arthur Jarvis, brought to life by his father's reading. Interior monologues, especially during Stephen Kumalo's prayers, appear frequently. An intriguing aspect of this technique is "authorial intrusion," where the author inserts his own thoughts or opinions into the text. The most prominent example in Cry, the Beloved Country occurs during the prison scene, where Stephen Kumalo questions Absalom about his relationship with Johannes Pafuri and Matthew Kumalo. A voice suddenly interrupts, advising Stephen Kumalo, "Old man, leave him alone. You lead him and then we spring upon him. He looks at you sullenly, soon he will not answer at all."
Literary Qualities
Cry, the Beloved Country's unique style features diction and symbolism that enhance the religious simplicity of the protagonist, Stephen Kumalo. Kumalo, a humble village parson, is not a deeply philosophical character. His education at a missionary school focused almost exclusively on the Bible.
There is a beautiful road that stretches from Ixopo into the hills. These
hills are covered in grass and roll gently, beyond any description.
The text includes a sprinkling of Zulu and Afrikaans words that highlight the
South African setting, and Paton provides a glossary for non-English terms. The
realistic dialogue captures the speech patterns of the various ethnic groups
depicted in the novel.
The novel's symbolic elements illuminate its themes and characters. The behavior of the titihoya bird symbolizes the rigid, artificial political divisions in the country. The titihoya sings in High Place, James Jarvis's homestead where the land is fertile and resources are plentiful. In stark contrast, the bird cannot sing in the valley of Ndotsheni, where the black population lives in dire poverty and faces exploitation and brutality.
The use of biblical names such as Absalom, Stephen, and Peter also carries symbolic weight. The name Absalom evokes the disobedience of the biblical Absalom, who meets a tragic end for rebelling against his father. Stephen Kumalo's name recalls St. Stephen, the first Christian martyr. Absalom Kumalo wishes to name his son Peter, in the tradition of St. Peter, the rock and founder of the Christian church. This suggests that Peter Kumalo is to be seen as the foundation of a new dynasty, with the potential for redemption and renewal.
Paton uses irony and sarcasm throughout the novel to highlight the evils and hypocrisies of a society tainted by apartheid. For example, the Bishop decides to transfer Stephen Kumalo from Ndotsheni because of his son's crime; only a letter from the influential white man, Mr. Jarvis, prevents this injustice. When the Bishop quickly changes his mind, stating "I see it is not God's will that you should leave Ndotsheni," Paton ironically demonstrates that in South Africa, God's will and the white man's will are often indistinguishable. Another instance of irony is that Arthur Jarvis, a champion of native causes, becomes a victim of the very people he advocates for.
Compare and Contrast
1948: After winning the national election, the National Party implements apartheid, formally segregating the black majority from the white minority.
Today: After spending twenty-seven years in prison, Nelson Mandela is inaugurated as the President of South Africa in 1994. In 1996, he signs the new Constitution, which ensures equal legal treatment for all citizens, regardless of race.
1948: Opponents of Apartheid policies find hope for a better future by singing Nkosi Sikelel' iAfrika.
Today: The song of hope, Nkosi Sikelel' iAfrika, is now the national anthem of South Africa.
1948: The British Empire is disintegrating as former colonies gain independence.
Today: The Soviet Union has dissolved, and its republics have proclaimed independence.
Literary Precedents
As a protest novel, Cry, the Beloved Country was heavily influenced by John Steinbeck's The Grapes of Wrath (1939), and the two novels share several similarities. The genre of the protest novel dates back to the eighteenth century when Samuel Richardson wrote Pamela (1740), using the novel to critique many societal issues of his time. Other potential influences include Richard Henry Dana's Two Years Before the Mast (1869), Upton Sinclair's The Jungle (1906), and even Charles Dickens, who was Paton's favorite author during his teenage years.
In the South African context, Cry, the Beloved Country established a tradition as a protest novel. While William Plomer's Turbott Wolfe, published in 1925 by Hogarth Press, is also a protest novel, it does not quite fit into the category of modern South African literature. Paton's work paved the way for a significant body of South African protest literature written by authors of all races, focusing on apartheid as a political system. The novel's influence has left a lasting legacy in South Africa, inspiring writers to use fiction, drama, poetry, and the novel to challenge the political system. In this regard, Paton can be seen as the father of the modern South African protest novel. Writers such as Nadine Gordimer, Athol Fugard, Peter Abrahams, Alex La Guma, J. M. Coetzee, Andre Brink, Dennis Brutus, and Adam Small have all followed in Paton's footsteps.
Media Adaptations
In 1951, Alan Paton and Zoltan Korda collaborated with London Films to produce a movie adaptation of Cry, the Beloved Country. Featuring Sidney Poitier, this film was recently made available on video by Monterey Home Video.
In 1994, Blackstone Audio Books released an audiobook version of Cry, the Beloved Country on cassette.
In 1995, Miramax created a new film adaptation of Cry, the Beloved Country, starring James Earl Jones and Richard Harris. This version was directed by Darrell James Roodt and produced by Anant Singh.
For Further Reference
Biko, Steve. Black Consciousness in South Africa. Edited by Millard Arnold. New York: Random House, 1979. This book explores the racial dynamics in South Africa, written by a black South African leader of the anti-apartheid movement who ultimately died while in police custody.
Callan, Edward. Alan Paton. New York: Twayne, 1982. A fundamental biographical and critical analysis.
La Guma, Alex, ed. Apartheid: A Collection of Writings on South African Racism. New York: Lippincott, 1965. An accessible and concise compilation of essays by authors, primarily South Africans, who have directly experienced apartheid. This collection includes Brian Bunting's article "The Origins of Apartheid."
Bibliography and Further Reading
Sources
Sheridan Baker, "Paton's Beloved Country and the Morality of Geography," in
College English, Vol. 19, November 1957, pp. 56-61.
Edwin Bruell, "Keen Scalpel on Racial Ills," in English Journal, Vol. 53, December 1964, pp. 658-61.
Edward Callan, Cry, the Beloved Country: A Novel of South Africa, Twayne, 1991.
Edmund Fuller, Man in Modern Fiction: Some Minority Opinions on Contemporary American Writing, Random House, 1958, p. 40.
Harry A. Gailey, "Sheridan Baker's 'Paton's Beloved Country,'" in College English, Vol. 20, December 1958, pp. 143-44.
Harold C. Gardiner, In All Conscience: Reflections on Books and Culture, Hanover House, 1959, pp. 108-12.
Myron Matlaw, review of Cry, the Beloved Country in Arcadia, Vol. 10, No. 3, 1975.
Martin Tucker, Africa in Modern Literature: A Survey of Contemporary Writing in English, Ungar, 1967.
For Further Study
Graham Hough, "Doomed," in London Review of Books, December 3-16,
1981, pp. 16-17.
Instead of commending the novel for its political significance, this critic
reaffirms the reason why it is considered a classic. It tells the tale of an
individual struggling to comprehend the complexities of life in a blatantly
unjust, racist society.
Tom McGurk, "Paton's Nightmare Came True," in New Statesman, Vol.
115, No. 2977, April 15, 1988, pp. 7-8.
Written at a time when conditions in South Africa were dire, McGurk believes
that Paton's novel predicted the intensifying racial oppression under
Apartheid. He also discusses the novel's inclusion in school curricula, though
he does not regard this as the hopeful sign it would later become.
William Minter, "Moderate to a Fault?" in New York Times Book
Review, November 20, 1988, p. 36.
In this piece, Minter explores the theme of justice in Paton's novels and his
personal life.
Herbert Mitgang, "Alan Paton, Author and Apartheid Foe, Dies of Cancer at
85," in New York Times, April 12, 1988, pp. A1, D35.
This obituary by Mitgang details the milestones of Paton's life as an author,
educator, and political activist.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.