Themes: Morals and Morality

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The Crucible delves into moral dilemmas that resonate universally, while also capturing the unique context of America during its creation. As Dennis Welland notes in his book on Arthur Miller, the play's moral themes are similar to those found in George Bernard Shaw's works, such as Pygmalion and Major Barbara. Shaw often suggests that misguided actions, like the witch trials, arise from a failure to take personal responsibility rather than sheer cruelty or malice. Essentially, instead of challenging the unjust trials, the residents of Salem choose to comply. Welland observed: "That is why Elizabeth quietly dismisses Hale's fervent plea to help Proctor save himself as 'the Devil's argument'... Elizabeth, much like [George Bernard] Shaw's St Joan [in his play of the same name], has learned through suffering that 'God's most precious gift is not life at any price, but the life of spiritual freedom and moral integrity.' In Proctor's ultimate rejection of his confession and his refusal to compromise his principles to save his life, we see the victory of personal integrity in a morally complex world."

Expert Q&A

In The Crucible, what message is Arthur Miller conveying to the reader?

Perhaps the most important message that Arthur Miller is trying to get across to the reader in The Crucible has to do with the need for good people to challenge corrupt authority and stand against injustice, even if it costs those people their lives or reputations. John Proctor and Reverend Hale fail to do this until it is too late, and many innocent lives are lost, including Proctor's own, as a result of their delay in speaking out.

What is the meaning of Proctor's quote in which he recognizes his own goodness?

"I can. And here is your first marvel that I can. You have made your magic now, for now i do think i do see some shred of goodness in John Proctor."

Proctor's quote signifies his recognition of his own goodness and redemption. Throughout the play, Proctor is burdened by guilt for his past sins. By refusing to falsely confess and choosing to die with honor, he believes he redeems himself and upholds the truth, challenging the corrupt court. This act allows him to finally see a "shred of goodness" in himself.

What does this quote reveal about Hale's character and its significance?

"Let you not mistake your own duty as I mistook my own. I came into this village like a bridegroom to his beloved, bearing gifts of high religion the very crowns of holy law I bought, and what I touched with my bright confidence, it died, where I turned the eye of my great faith, blood followed up."

The quote reveals Reverend Hale's transformation from a confident intellectual to a guilt-ridden figure recognizing his role in the tragedy of Salem. Initially, Hale arrives with pride in his religious expertise, eager to root out witchcraft. However, witnessing the hysteria and injustice, he begins questioning his beliefs and methods. The significance lies in Hale's realization of the destructive power of blind faith and his complicity, ultimately leading him to value truth and moral integrity over ritualistic duty.

Why is Proctor's "name" so important in The Crucible?

In The Crucible, Proctor speaks of ringing a bell of "doom of [his] good name." After Elizabeth lies, Proctor says, "She only thought to save my name." Hale even calls Elizabeth's lie a "natural lie to tell."

In The Crucible, one reason why Proctor's name is so important is because he doesn't want his descendants to have a bad reputation. He doesn't want them to have to live with the shame of having a self-confessed witch for an ancestor, even if the confession in question was a false one.

What does Miller's quote "there were moments when an individual conscience was all that could keep the world from falling apart" mean?

Miller's quote highlights the crucial role of individual conscience in preventing societal collapse during mass hysteria, as depicted in The Crucible. In the play, and during the McCarthy era it allegorizes, most people avoided speaking out against injustice, leading to widespread persecution. Those few who did, like John Proctor and Reverend Hale, acted too late. Miller suggests that moral courage is essential to counteract the destructive power of fear and prejudice in such situations.

What does Reverend Hale's quote in The Crucible mean: "I dare not take a life without there be proof so immaculate no slightest qualm of conscience may doubt it."?

Reverend Hale's quote reflects his belief in executing his duties only when the evidence is "immaculate," meaning beyond any doubt. This underscores his conviction that such proof justifies taking a life, revealing a fundamental flaw in his character. As the events in Salem unfold, Hale realizes that the "proof" accepted by the court may not meet his standard. This quote marks the beginning of his doubt about the legitimacy of the trials and the evidence presented.

Discuss the significance of this statement about Proctor's goodness in The Crucible.

The statement about Proctor's "goodness" signifies his embrace of his true identity and rejection of deception in The Crucible. By refusing to sign a false confession, Proctor asserts his moral integrity, seeking redemption and defending his dignity against hypocrisy in Salem. His admiration for Corey's honorable death inspires him to protect his own name, representing a triumph over internal and external "dogs" that threaten his integrity.

Did the sacrifices in The Crucible achieve anything? Are principles always worth dying for?

The sacrifices of characters like John Proctor, Rebecca Nurse, and Martha Corey in "The Crucible" contributed to ending the Salem witch trials by turning public sentiment against them. Their integrity and refusal to confess highlighted the hysteria and injustice, eventually leading to societal reflection and apologies. While dying for principles is subjective, their actions underscored the importance of integrity and the dangers of mass hysteria, showing that their deaths were not in vain.

In The Crucible, how does Proctor's perception of morality affect his decision to tear up the confession?

John Proctor’s perception of a morally righteous person affects his decision to tear up the confession because it is Elizabeth who points out to him that he has not confessed yet and that it does not matter if she forgives his sins against her if he will not forgive himself.

The meaning and significance of the quote "Do that which is good, and no harm shall come to thee" in The Crucible

The quote "Do that which is good, and no harm shall come to thee" in The Crucible signifies the belief that moral integrity and righteous behavior will protect individuals. However, the play's events ironically contradict this, as characters who act morally often face dire consequences, highlighting the flawed justice and the hysteria of the Salem witch trials.

Show another question (4 questions hidden)

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: All Themes

Next

Themes: Society

Loading...