Discussion Topic
Miller's depiction of Reverend Hale in The Crucible and its impact on the drama
Summary:
Reverend Hale's depiction in The Crucible significantly impacts the drama by showcasing the transformation from a confident witch-hunt expert to a disillusioned critic of the trials. His journey highlights the dangers of hysteria and blind faith in authority, adding depth to the play's critique of fanaticism and injustice.
What is Miller's narrative about Reverend Hale in Act 1 of The Crucible?
In act I of The Crucible, Reverend Hale is presented as conscientious in his duty as a witch-hunter. He arrives in Salem determined to get to the bottom of the rapidly developing witch-craze. And it's clear right from the outset that Hale is very much an idealist who genuinely wants the witch-trials to uncover the truth.
Although he believes in the existence of witches as much as anyone, Hale wants to make sure that only the truly guilty are punished for their misdeeds. In this, he is completely at odds with the likes of Parris, whose motives in participating in the witch-trials are far from pure. Whereas Parris has no hesitation in making false accusations against innocent people, Hale understands the importance of correct protocol. He never forgets that the trials are a legal procedure and, as such, should always involve due process. Hale's firm grounding in the law,...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
combined with his relentlessly logical nature, allow him to remain calm amidst all the chaos and hysteria swirling around him. His presence reminds us of the overriding importance of doing justice in all cases, however serious the charges may be.
In The Crucible, how does Miller describe Reverend Hale?
According to Miller, Reverend Hale is almost forty years old and is a "tight-skinned, eager-eyed intellectual." He is very proud of his craft (career) of witch-hunting and is excited to finally put his skills and years of learning to use. He considers himself a specialist on witches, although he has never seen one first-hand. The only allegedly witch he has encountered turned out to be innocent. Despite this setback, he is certain that witches and evil exist and that they can be proved through science: "We cannot look to superstition in this. The Devil is precise."
Regardless of his initial over-zealousness, Hale proves to be a scrupulous and just man, as he demands that the innocent be let go when he realizes that the trials are a mistake.
How does Miller's portrayal of Reverend Hale impact the drama of The Crucible?
Miller portrays Reverend Hale as a man who is initially very confident, even a bit arrogant, concerning his ability to identify the “marks” of the devil and to banish him. He comes to Salem with his big books which, he says, are “weighted with authority,” and he never doubts for a moment that he could be wrong. In act II, he visits the Proctors to get a sense of them, and to ask John some questions regarding John’s position on the local minister and John’s own theology. When Hale learns that Rebecca Nurse has been charged with witchcraft, he is shocked, but he still believes in the righteousness of the court and its judges, and he claims that, if she is sent home, she will be exonerated. It is only in act III that we see Hale finally understand the corruption at the heart of the court, and he “quits” it and will no longer take part in its proceedings now that he recognizes how unjustly it operates. Finally, in act IV, Hale returns to Salem to counsel those convicted of witchcraft to lie and confess their “guilt” to save their own lives and avoid being hanged for crimes they did not commit. He now feels responsible for the executions that have already happened and those which are about to take place, crying out that there is “blood on [his] head.” If the audience is familiar at all with the real story of the Salem Witch Trials, then they know how this ends, and they have known since Reverend Hale appeared onstage, full of confidence. This creates dramatic irony, when the audience knows more than the character, as we understand what will happen long before Hale does. This builds tension for the audience as we see his naivety change to understanding, and it results in a release of that tension when he finally figures out the truth.