Discussion Topic
James Madison's distinction between democracy and a republic
Summary:
James Madison distinguished between democracy and a republic by stating that in a democracy, the people directly govern themselves, while in a republic, they elect representatives to govern on their behalf. This representative system in a republic helps to mitigate the dangers of factionalism and ensures a more stable and just government.
What distinction between democracy and a republic does James Madison make in The Federalist #10?
The Federalist No. 10 believed to have been written by James Madison is his commentary regarding his opinions on what he called 'the mischiefs of faction'. In the essay, Madison concludes that there is a 'diversity in the faculties of men' suggesting that a 'pure democracy' made up of the diverse faculties of men might not be in the best interest of the new nation because 'pure demcracy' held too many opinions. Moreover, Madison argued the differences between a democracy and a republic are rooted in the scope of their intended power. His rationale based between the individual citizens with their factional attitudes and local prejudices possibilty corrupting the people (pure democracy) or that of a smaller number of citizens elected by the individual citizens (republic) who have the potential to express a more public view rather than a factional perspective. Madison's perspective rests on the side of...
Unlock This Answer Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
a representative government for the new nation, he thought it a more sustainable form of government. However, it must be noted thatThe Federalist Papers were written with a specific agenda attached to them. Hamilton, Madison, and Jay under the name 'Publius' published the essays in Hamilton's New York newspaper to sway public opinion on the ratification of the U.S. Constitution.
The distinction that Madison makes between the two is that he sees democracy as a danger but sees a republic as the way to prevent that danger from occurring.
When Madison wrote about democracy, he meant a more direct democracy where the people have a large say in the government. He thought that was a bad idea because he didn't think the people were informed enough to make good decisions.
Instead, Madison wanted a republic where there are legislators who represent the people, but who can be kind of independent of them. He thought those legislators would be better informed and would not do stupid things.
So Madison thought that too much democracy was dangerous and he thought a republic would be better because the only people with power would be the people who really knew enough to make good decisions.
What, according to James Madison, is the difference between a democracy and a republic?
James Madison discusses the difference between pure democracy and representative democracy in Federalist Paper 10. He discusses how the impact of political factions is different in the two government types. Madison warns that people with common interests or agendas could form a coalition and if that coalition can form a majority, they can suppress the interests of the minority. As an example, imagine if the lower classes would form an alliance in which they demanded their economic interests be heard. In a direct democracy, they could control most decisions because of the sheer volume of votes. This would potentially harm commercial and economic development. Madison felt that the impact of factions or political parties could be offset by establishing a form of representative government. In a republic where the population would be larger, Madison believed that factions would remain local and would not spread to all parts of the nation. Madison believed it was impossible to stop the formation of parties, but their influence on liberty could be stymied in a republic.
References