Conrad Ferdinand Meyer Critical Essays


(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

Conrad Ferdinand Meyer 1825–1898

Swiss novelist and poet.

As the author of some of the most intricate psychological narratives of nineteenth-century European literature, Meyer exemplifies the artistic movement known as poetic realism, which sought to objectify the inner life of characters through the use of stylized gestures, settings, and images. Meyer is perhaps best known for his sophisticated use of narrative frames in his prose, as well as for his perceptive attention to detail. Although his major novellas are set in the past, his work reflects the transitional character of his time; his relatively conventional political and religious outlook contrasts with the innovative complexity of his narratives and his modernist representation of the ambiguity of human thought and feeling.

Biographical Information

Born in Zurich, Switzerland, on October 11, 1825, to a bourgeois family, Meyer grew up in an intellectual environment. His father held a position as a history teacher at a gymnasium, or high school, and had close ties to the incipient University of Zurich. After his father's death in 1840, Meyer's mother, a pious and intelligent woman, strongly influenced both Meyer and his younger sister, Betsy, who would later become Meyer's secretary and close companion. As a young man, Meyer oscillated between listlessness and hyperactivity, and he pursued an interest in German history and literature. Between 1837 and 1843, Meyer attended the Zurich Gymnasium, but he found it difficult to concentrate on his studies. In 1843, he was sent to Lausanne for a year, where he was introduced to French literature, began composing Romantic poetry, and decided to pursue a writing career. He recognized the mediocrity of his early poetic efforts, however, and plagued by depression, isolated himself from all social contact beyond his immediate family and a few close friends.

During this period he read voraciously—primarily historical works and German Romantic novels—and became increasingly discouraged about his own artistic prospects. He began to suffer from neurotic symptoms and hinted to his family that he planned to commit suicide. His mother, concerned by his mental deterioration, took him to the Préfargier mental hospital in 1852, where he was diagnosed with an "irritation of

the nerves." In 1853 Meyer moved back to Lausanne to study French and there resumed the relationships he had abandoned in 1844, including his friendship with the translator and historian Louis Vulliemin, who supported his literary ambitions and intensified Meyer's interest in history. Because of Vulliemin's influence, Meyer secured a position teaching history and soon began translating Augustin Thierry's Récits des temps Mérovingiens (1840), which earned critical praise and provided him with an introduction into the Romantic literary scene. Unimpressed by these accomplishments, Meyer's mother convinced him to return to Zurich at the end of 1853. Meyer again found himself alienated amid bourgeois social life; he continued to translate French historical works and to write poetry, and he produced his first novella, Clara (first published in 1938). In 1856 his mother's mental health had degenerated to the point that she was institutionalized at Préfargier, where she committed suicide. At the same time, Meyer and his sister, Betsy, inherited from a longtime friend a large estate, which brought them financial independence. After spending time in Paris, the Swiss Alps, and Italy, Meyer returned to his translating work and to writing poems, 20 of which eventually were published anonymously as Zwanzig Balladen von einem Schweizer (1864). Still others were published in periodicals beginning in 1865. During this period, Betsy became the principal supporter of his literary work, and for most of his career his works were dictated to her. In 1869 Meyer published at his own expense a collection of poems, Romanzen und Bilder, and in 1871 had his first major literary success with the publication of Huttens letzte Tage [Hutten 's Last Days], a verse portrayal of the Reformation hero Ulrich von Hutten. During the next 20 years Meyer published a total of 11 novellas and 5 editions of his collected poems. He enjoyed both popular and critical adulation. In recognition of his accomplishments, he was awarded an honorary doctorate by the University of Zurich in 1880.

In 1875 Meyer had married Luise Ziegler, the daughter of a wealthy Zurich family. His marriage inaugurated a tense relationship between Betsy and Luise that would increasingly disrupt Meyer's ability to write, and may have contributed to a mental and physical breakdown that culminated in a year-long hospitalization in 1892-93. For the remaining six years of his life, Meyer wrote very little, while his sister continued to supervise new editions of his work. He died of a heart attack in November 1898.

Major Works

Meyer's work tends to focus on heroic figures of European history—including Thomas à Becket, the Swiss leader Jürg Jenatsch, the Spanish general Fernando Avalos, and the Swedish king Gustav Adolf. Many of these historical figures had not only political, and specifically nationalist, significance, but played a part in religious conflicts as well. Although Meyer researched these figures and their time, he also frequently modified historical details to introduce ambiguities of motivation, complexity of character, and dramatic tension in his writings. The historical novellas are notable for Meyer's sophisticated employment of frame narratives, particularly in Der Heilige [The Saint] (1880), Das Leiden eines Knaben [A Boy Suffers] (1883), and Die Hochzeit des Mönchs [The Monk's Wedding] (1883). The frames do not function merely as transparent vehicles for the internal story. Rather, the interaction between frame and narrative calls attention to the ambiguous nature of artistic construction: the narrators often claim to be confused by the very story they are recounting. Similarly, Meyer's work manifests a fundamental indeterminateness with regard to the central characters' intentions, thus allowing contradictory but equally plausible interpretations of the narratives. Meyer's subtle characterizations correspond to what George F. Folkers has called an "ambivalent objectivity"—his insistence on describing events, actions and gestures in the fullness of their opacity. The resulting pessimistic tone of his novellas has been read by recent scholars as an implicit critique of the bourgeois mores and self-stisfaction of Meyer's Europe.

In addition to prose works, Meyer wrote two verse narratives early in his career, Huttens letzte Tage and Engelberg (1872), and in his lifetime published five editions of his collected poems. The poems particularly show the arduous revisions of his work that Meyer undertook as a regular part of the writing process. The poems, like the novellas, employ naturalist motifs in both traditional and original symbolism, and often contain Meyer's deeply personal reflections on his own intimate relationships, his interest in the tension between piety and sensuality, and the anticipation of his own death.

Critical Reception

Although Meyer's earliest writings met with critical indifference, Huttens letzte Tage was proclaimed a literary success at its publication and has remained one of Meyer's most popular works. The stylistic precision, psychological insight, and complex structure of this and other novellas are consistently praised by both Meyer's contemporaries and more recent critics. Many consider his masterwork to be Der Heilige; as Tiiu V. Laane has written, "His tendency toward the pictorial and dramatic; his striving for symbolization, concentration, and the grand gesture; and his demand for strict objectivity reach their epitome in this novella." Meyer's own favorite work, Die Richterin [The Judge] (1885), became the subject of one of Sigmund Freud's essays. He considered the dramatic narrative dealing with incest, murder, and justice a confirmation, in nascent form, of his own psychoanalytic concepts. Although Meyer himself thought his poetry secondary to his novellas, he is viewed by critics as a precursor of the German symbolist movement for his use of imagery.

Critics of Meyer's work point to the contrived plots, the occasionally cumbersome and over-explicit use of symbolism, and to his refusal to affirm any single interpretation of events—an insistence that leaves some readers feeling the narrative has been left unresolved. Yet this last characteristic is also applauded by more recent critics as a further manifestation of Meyer's abiding interest in the enigmatic aspects of reality and the contradictory nature of inner life. Meyer's work is generally considered reflective of both the strengths and weaknesses of the transition from Romantic to modern literature: his cosmopolitanism, attention to psychological detail, and objective style contrast with his instinctive patriotism, anti-Catholicism, and apolitical stance.

Principal Works

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

Zwanzig Balladen von einem Schwezer (poetry) 1864

Romanzen und Bilder (poetry) 1869

Huttens letzte Tage [Hutten 's Last Days] (poetry) 1871

Engelberg (poetry) 1872

Das Amulett [The Amulet] (novella) 1873

Der Schuss von der Kanzel [The Shot from the Pulpit] (novella) 1878

Der Heilige [The Saint] (novella) 1880

Gedichte [Poems] (poetry) 1882

Gustav Adolfs Page [Gustav Adolf's Page] (novella) 1882

Die Hochzeit des Mönchs [The Monk's Wedding]...

(The entire section is 102 words.)

Georg Lukács (essay date 1936-37)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Conrad Ferdinand Meyer and the New Type of Historical Novel," in The Historical Novel, translated by Hannah and Stanley Mitchell, Merlin Press, 1962, pp. 221-30.

[In the following essay, first published in Russian in 1936-37, Lukács reads Meyer's historical portrayals as critical reflections on the "innermost conflicts" of modern bourgeois sensibility.]

The real representative of the historical novel in this period is Conrad Ferdinand Meyer, who along with Gottfried Keller—likewise a native of Switzerland—is one of the most important realistic narrative writers of the period following 1848. Both, however differently, have stronger ties with the classical...

(The entire section is 4435 words.)

Heinrich Henel (essay date 1954)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Bread and Wine," in The Poetry of Conrad Ferdinand Meyer, University of Wisconsin Press, 1954, pp. 194-234.

[In the following excerpt, Henel discusses the evolution of one of the central themes in Meyer's poetry of the seasonsthe "conflict between pagan and Christian imagery. "]

Conrad Ferdinand Meyer's poems on summer and fall provide an example of proliferation which is almost overwhelming in its complexity and complication. However, there would be little point in following their evolution if such a study provided merely additional proof of what has been amply demonstrated already. Interest is aroused, not so much by the fact that twelve poems in...

(The entire section is 19754 words.)

Frederick J. Beharriell (essay date 1955)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "C. F. Meyer and the Origins of Psychoanalysis," in Monatshefte für Deutschen Unterricht, Deutsche Sprache und Literatur, Vol. XLVII, No. 3, March, 1955, pp. 140-48.

[In the essay that follows, Beharriell examines Freud's interest in Meyer's writing as it anticipates major elements of psychoanalytic theory, such as wish-fulfillment, the fantasy Freud names 'the family romance, ' and the psychological significance of art.]

In "Freud and Literature," an eminently sane and balanced essay, Lionel Trilling commented on the lack of evidence concerning the literary influences on the founder of psychoanalysis.1 That there were such influences has of course...

(The entire section is 4264 words.)

Edward M. V. Plater (essay date 1972)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "The Banquet of Life: Conrad Ferdinand Meyer's Die Versuchung des Pescara," in Seminar: A Journal of Germanic Studies, Vol. VIII, No. 2, June, 1972, pp. 88-98.

[In the essay that follows, Plater argues that the allegorical complexity of Meyer's narratives allows him to represent the ambivalence and self-contradiction of human thought and emotion.]

This investigation concerns itself with the significance of the frescoes that Meyer describes at the beginning of his novella Die Versuchung des Pescara:

Links von der Tür hielt Bacchus ein Gelag mit seinem mythologischen Gesinde, und rechts war als Gegenstück die...

(The entire section is 5039 words.)

Manfred R. Jacobson (essay date 1974)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "The Narrator's Allusions to Art and Ambiguity: A Note on C. F. Meyer's Der Heilige," in Seminar: A Journal of Germanic Studies, Vol. X, No. 4, November, 1974, pp. 265-73.

[In the following essay, Jacobson contends that the narrator's attempt to understand Thomas à Becket in Die Heilige exposes a distinction, crucial for Meyer, between inherent and artificial ambiguity in art.]

The general significance of Meyer's frequent symbolic use of art and artefacts has already been ably treated by Karl S. Guthke. In his essay, 'Kunstsymbolik im Werke Meyers,' he argues convincingly that these works of art and artefacts not only serve a proleptic purpose,...

(The entire section is 3791 words.)

Martin Swales (essay date 1977)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Fagon's Defeat: Some Remarks on C. F. Meyer's Das Leiden eines Knaben," in The Germanic Review, Vol. LII, No. 1, January, 1977, pp. 29-43.

[In the following essay, Swales claims that Meyer's Das Leiden eines Knaben dramatizes the problem of artistic construction, which, through its very engagement with experience, introduces a certain mediation and detachment from the world represented in the work of art.]

Das Leiden eines Knaben is, like many of C. F. Meyer's stories, a "Rahmenerzählung," and Meyer spends much time and space on the framework situation. King Louis XIV of France goes, as is his wont, to the rooms of Madame de Maintenon in...

(The entire section is 7314 words.)

Dennis McCort (essay date 1978)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Historical Consciousness versus Action in C. F. Meyer's Das Amulett," in Symposium, Vol. XXXII, No. 2, Summer, 1978, pp. 114-32.

[In the essay that follows, McCort traces the conflict in Meyer's Das Amulett between nostalgia for an existentially comforting world order and a persistent skepticism regarding the possibility of transcending limited and subjective comprehension.]

It has been long in coming, but due recognition is finally being accorded Conrad Ferdinand Meyer's earliest novella, Das Amulett. As sometimes happens with works whose artistry is subtle, critical evaluation has come full circle. Deemed a triumph on publication...

(The entire section is 8789 words.)

Edward M. V. Plater (essay date 1978)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: '"Der schöne Leib' in the Prose of Conrad Ferdinand Meyer," in Seminar: A Journal of Germanic Studies, Vol. XIV, No. 4, November, 1978, pp. 255-67.

[In the following essay, Plater examines the significance of the complex objectification of inner life in Meyer's novellas.]

The underlying principle of Conrad Ferdinand Meyer's narrative art was expressed by his sister Betsy as follows:

'Mein Bruder sehnte sich von jeher, so zu dichten, daß durch sein Wort nicht Gedanken ausgedrückt, sondern handelnde Gestalten geschaffen würden. "Jeder Gedanke muß seinen schönen Leib haben," meinte er … "In der Poesie muß jeder Gedanke...

(The entire section is 5823 words.)

Marianne Burkhard (essay date 1978)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Flaming Signals on Dark Waters: Meyer's Poetry" in Conrad Ferdinand Meyer, Twayne Publishers, 1978, pp. 95-122.

[In the essay that follows, Burkhard discusses Meyer's careful experimentation with poetic structure, particularly in his aesthetic treatment of death.]

For all his extensive work in prose since 1872, Meyer was far from neglecting his poetry which, for long, had been his prime endeavor. And it is in poetry that, after an arduous working process, he was to reach his most innovative accomplishments. Letters and manuscripts of the 1870s reveal continuous work on poems which were published individually or in small groups in several poetry journals. For...

(The entire section is 11146 words.)

Dennis McCort (essay date 1988)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Gustav Adolfs Page as a Tragedy of the Unconscious" in States of Unconsciousness in Three Tales by C. F. Meyer, Bucknell University Press, 1988, pp. 33-76.

[In the following excerpt, McCort considers Meyer's Gustav Adolfs Page a psychological "tragic drama " of the repression of femininity that leads to a fundamental distortion of the central character's interpretation of reality.]

In the late 1870s, Meyer became drawn to the idea of writing a dramatic tragedy about the great Protestant standard-bearer of the Thirty Years War, King Gustavus Adolphus of Sweden. The king's loyal page, August Leubelfing, son of a Nürnberg patrician, was also...

(The entire section is 18821 words.)

Further Reading

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

Bridgwater, W. P. "C. F. Meyer and Nietzsche." The Modern Language Review 60, No. 4 (October 1965): 568-83.

Examines the elements of convergence between Meyer and Nietzsche's worldviews.

Burkhard, Arthur. Conrad Ferdinand Meyer: The Style and the Man. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1932, 225 p.

An early study of Meyer's literary style analyzed in connection with biographical details.

Dahme, Lena F. Women in the Life and Art of Conrad Ferdinand Meyer. New York: Columbia University Press, 1936, 420 p.


(The entire section is 445 words.)