Critical Evaluation

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The Conjure Woman is Charles Waddell Chesnutt’s first collection of short fiction. It includes seven short stories that are loosely connected but unified by parallel format, characters, and thematic similarities. Each story is presented against the unifying background of postbellum Southern life. The apparent model is the Joel Chandler Harris collection of Uncle Remus tales. Chesnutt’s method differs from that of Harris by presenting an outside story providing the framework for the inside narrative, which is an original tale. Harris, on the other hand, based his inside material on existing folktales. An African American, Chesnutt places a distinctive black perspective on his folk material, which is liberally sprinkled with dialect. The Conjure Woman preserves a relatively inaccessible and easily overlooked portion of American social and literary history.

The outside narrative usually consists of some type of journey that offers an opportunity to relate the inside narrative in dialect by Uncle Julius. Each inside narrative, which usually involves a major change in a newly introduced character, can stand alone. Chesnutt uses the frame-within-a-frame technique to mute the racial implications of the inside narrative.

Chesnutt also contrasts The Conjure Woman’s outside and inside narratives. The outside narrative is solidly based in the real world, one that treats the weak harshly and rewards the wealthy and powerful. The inside narrative is more imaginative and entertaining than didactic. This complex method masks much of the intent to educate the reader about the plight of the African American without becoming offensive or maudlin.

Uncle Julius relates to his white employers in a manner that parallels that with which the artist relates to his audience. Using this paradigm, Chesnutt educates his white audience by correcting the flawed vision of the outside narrative. In a very real sense, Chesnutt conjures his readers by employing this complex methodology.

Some of these stories, in the author’s words, “are quaintly humorous; others wildly extravagant, revealing the Oriental cast of the negro’s imagination; while others . . . disclose many a tragic incident of the darker side of slavery.” These tales are less amusing and more complex than the Uncle Remus stories: Both sets of tales recall the treasury of African American folklore, replete with birds and animals, witches and spells, spirits and haunts, horrors, wonders, protests, and fright.

The Conjure Woman presents several unique problems, one of which is the question of unity in the diversity of these seven stories. That unity is derived from Uncle Julius and consistently similar personas, plot development, and narrative thread, which concerns the trickster overcoming the deceptions of a hostile environment.

The exterior story is narrated in standard English by whites, and the interior story is narrated in dialect by Uncle Julius. The interior stories begin to develop after a catalyst such as an interrupted journey or task. The supernatural elements thereupon take over, with a full-blown story-within-a-story. The entire tale ends when the strands of all the outside plots are gathered up and brought to a satisfactory conclusion.

At the core of each of these seven stories is a desire to promote a better understanding of race relations in the antebellum South with which Chesnutt was so familiar. It also appears that Chesnutt was writing for the white audience a series of stories that appeal for more humane treatment of minorities in the United States.

All of the stories in The Conjure Woman are deftly and competently developed, but three are outstanding: “The Conjurer’s Revenge,” “The Goophered Grapevine,” and “The Gray Wolf’s Ha’nt.” “The Goophered Grapevine” is the first story in the collection, deliberately placed to entice the reader to read the...

(This entire section contains 821 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

entire volume. It remains the most widely known and frequently anthologized of Chesnutt’s short stories. At a seminal level, “The Goophered Grapevine” is about the economics of slavery; although Chesnutt masks his message, the story remains a powerful indictment.

“The Conjurer’s Revenge” is properly placed as the fourth story in the collection. It is the centerpiece for unifying character and plot line and is the most complex of the seven stories. It concerns appearance versus reality, illustrated in many ways like Zora Neale Hurston’s “The Gilded Six Bits.”

“The Gray Wolf’s Ha’nt,” the sixth story in the collection, is a genuine sojourn in the world of the supernatural. Dan is evil personified; although he starts out with apparently good intentions, he develops a dangerous jealous streak and is transformed into a wolf and a multiple killer. It is a dark, brooding tale of act and revenge.

When The Conjure Woman was published in March, 1899, reviews were almost universally favorable. Chesnutt was given credit as the equal of Paul Laurence Dunbar, a new African American literary talent, and a master of the short story. All of these tributes inspired Chesnutt to continue writing short stories, many of which were collected in The Wife of His Youth, and Other Stories of the Color Line (1899).

Previous

Critical Context

Loading...