Confessions

by Aurelius Augustinus

Start Free Trial

Student Question

What are the differences in moral and societal obligation between Augustine's Confessions and Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales?

Quick answer:

In "Confessions," Augustine's moral and societal obligations are centered on his Christian faith, with an emphasis on living a life aligned with eternal goals and rejecting worldly desires. In contrast, "The Canterbury Tales" presents a variety of moral perspectives, with characters displaying a mix of piety and selfishness. While Augustine's work is a didactic religious text, Chaucer's poem explores the interplay between the worldly and the religious in everyday life, reflecting diverse personal interpretations of faith.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In St. Augustine's Confessions, Augustine explores his own journey to faith and in particular his own growing understanding of God and how he should respond as a result of who God is and what he has already done for him. As a result, the moral and societal expectations are placed firmly within this religious context, as Augustine experiences and understands more and more that God's call on his life results in expectations on how he should act morally and in society that could not be ignored. Note how he comments on this in the following quote:

I look forward, not to what lies ahead of me in this life and will surely pass away, but to my eternal goal. I am intent upon this one purpose, not distracted by other aims, and with this goal in view I press on, eager for the prize, God's heavenly summons. Then I shall listen to the sound of Your praises and gaze at Your beauty ever present, never future, never past.

For Augustine, obligations are all based around his Christian faith which calls Christians to live their lives now in the light of an eternity with God in heaven after death. All actions in the present are therefore based on this future, and moral and societal obligations are about doing what is right in order to move closer towards this future.

Moral and societal obligations, however, are presented very differently in Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales. Whilst there are characters who try to live respectable and upstanding lives, such as the Knight and the Prioress, at the same time the vast majority of characters clearly have their own agenda and are not burdened by the same moral and societal obligations that Augustine was. Just think of the content of some of the tales, for example, and the way that characters such as the Pardoner present themselves. The narrator is very open in pointing towards this different understanding of characters, as well:

The miller is a lout, as you're aware;
So was the reeve, and so were many more.
They both told bawdy stories. Then beware,
And do not lay upon me all the blame,
Or take in earnest what is meant in fun.

This text, in contrast with St. Augustine, presents the reader with a wide range of different understandings of moral and societal obligations, ranging from quite pious and principled approaches to characters who clearly live their lives very selfishly, doing what they think alone is important.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Compare spirituality and religion in Augustine's Confessions and Chaucer's Canterbury Tales.

The most obvious similarity between the two works is that both describe a pilgrimage, but a closer investigation reveals significant differences. Confessions describes a spiritual pilgrimage toward Christianity, and Canterbury Tales takes place in the context of a pilgrimage to Canterbury. The emphasis in Confessions is on a Christianity that rejects the worldly, including sexual appetites and material greed. Canterbury Tales engages with this dichotomy in many ways, most explicitly in its treatment of avaricious and lustful clergymen such as the Friar, the Summoner, and the Pardoner. On the other hand, the distinction between "right" and wrong" Christianities in The Canterbury Tales is never very distinct. The pilgrims all seem to inject their personalities into their versions of the faith, which nevertheless (appropriately, since they are, after all, on a pilgrimage) suffuses many of their accounts. So while Confessions is a rejection of the worldly, The Canterbury Tales seems more ambiguous, almost a study of how the worldly mingles with the religious in the lives of actual people. This is, of course, entirely approriate. Confessions is intended to be a didactic religious tract, where The Canterbury Tales is a secular poem that addresses religious themes that occupied the minds of Chaucer's readers.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial