Common Ground

by J. Anthony Lukas

Start Free Trial

Summary

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Race has often been an emotionally charged topic in the United States, making candid and insightful discussions rare, especially when examining its role in the decline of modern American cities. However, J. Anthony Lukas, in his book "Common Ground," manages to navigate this complex terrain with both sophistication and grounding in human experiences. His exploration is essentially a biography of Boston, capturing a decade of upheaval starting from 1968.

Lukas's narrative centers around three individuals who embody the city’s diverse social fabric. Alice McGoff is a working-class Irish mother residing in the homogeneous neighborhood of Charlestown, living in public housing. Rachel Twymon, a middle-aged black mother, resides on the periphery of the ghetto while maintaining connections to the black middle class. Lastly, Colin Diver, a Harvard Law School graduate, forgoes a lucrative career to tackle pressing social issues in Boston. Through these figures, Lukas examines the racial tensions and urban transformations that Boston experienced, particularly highlighted by the court-ordered busing of 1974, which directly impacted the Diver, Twymon, and McGoff families.

The book expands its focus through chapters that radiate outward from these central characters, exploring their families, environments, and personal perspectives on the racial conflicts surrounding them. By detailing the intimate realities of these individuals, Lukas provides readers with a deeper understanding of the broader social dynamics they navigate daily. His method is rooted in extensive research, drawing from over five hundred interviews and a wealth of historical and social data.

"Common Ground" stands out for its ability to blend individual stories with a robust intellectual analysis, offering a narrative that is as dramatic as it is insightful. Although Lukas expresses a tempered view regarding the efficacy of social reforms and the future outlook of the city, his work sheds light on essential truths that are crucial for any meaningful progress. This synthesis of personal drama and analytical depth makes "Common Ground" a significant contribution to understanding the complex interplay of race and urban life in America.

Common Ground

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

In the evolving field of biography, a genre has emerged that immerses readers in the intricate tapestry of its subject's environment, often expanding into the lives and stories of those around them. This approach offers a comprehensive panorama, providing insights into broader societal issues. J. Anthony Lukas's "Common Ground: A Turbulent Decade in the Lives of Three American Families" not only epitomizes this style but also elevates it, using oral history to tell the multifaceted story of a city grappling with racial tensions and change.

The Setting: Boston on the Brink

Lukas’s narrative begins in April 1968, in the aftermath of Martin Luther King Jr.’s assassination, setting the stage in Boston by examining the reactions of three distinct individuals. Colin Diver, a Harvard Law School student, is moved to act against poverty and racial inequality in Boston instead of pursuing a prestigious law career. Rachel Twymon, a black mother of six, is devastated by King’s death and faces personal and financial ruin as her business succumbs to looting and bankruptcy. Meanwhile, Alice McGoff, an Irish-American waitress, mourns the loss but questions the relevance of the civil rights movement in the North, where she perceives fewer barriers to black mobility.

Three Families, Three Perspectives

The book introduces readers to the intersecting lives of Divers, Twymons, and McGoffs, each representing a facet of Boston’s complex social fabric: Yankee, black, and Irish communities, respectively. However, Lukas resists reductive stereotypes, instead illuminating the unique aspects of their identities: Diver as the son of immigrants, Twymon with black Canadian ancestry, and McGoff as a widowed public housing resident. Through their stories, Lukas paints a vivid portrait of urban...

(This entire section contains 797 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

life, marked by both collective heritage and individual circumstances.

A City’s Struggle with Change

As Lukas explores the broader socio-political environment of Boston, he captures the city’s fraught dynamics, from the political contests between Yankee and Irish power brokers to the challenges of urban renewal. He introduces various figures, from policymakers to educators, each contributing to the city’s ongoing narrative of struggle and transformation. This backdrop frames the personal journeys of Lukas’s three central families as they become enmeshed in the controversy of school desegregation.

The Busing Crisis: A Microcosm of Conflict

The federal ruling for busing in 1974 to desegregate Boston’s schools ignited intense discord, especially in tight-knit neighborhoods like Charlestown. McGoff and her community fiercely opposed the busing order, fearing for their children's safety and continuity of education. The Divers, despite their ideological support for integration, faced the disruption of their carefully chosen integrated neighborhood school. Twymon, hopeful yet apprehensive, worried about her children’s safety in predominantly white schools.

Lived Experience of Integration

Lukas dedicates significant attention to the visceral experiences during the busing crisis, capturing the hostility and resistance encountered by black students at Charlestown High School. The educational atmosphere was fraught, with daily protests and eruptions of violence undermining learning. Yet, amid the turbulence, seeds of change appeared; interracial friendships began to form, hinting at the potential for long-term integration, albeit challenged by the flight to suburban and private schools.

Complex Reactions and Broader Implications

While Lukas vividly portrays the challenges of busing, he enriches the narrative by exploring the diverse reactions within Boston’s communities. He highlights the complexities behind opposition, delving into the fears and motivations of those resisting change, while also addressing issues like urban crime. Through the lens of the Divers’ anxiety over neighborhood safety and the criminal activities of Twymon’s son, Lukas provides a nuanced understanding of urban decay and societal pressures.

Exploring Human Nature and Institutional Challenges

Lukas’s narrative methodically examines how individuals are influenced by their environments and the larger social forces at play. His portrayal is empathetic and detailed, fostering an understanding of each character's circumstances and choices. However, this comprehensive approach also underscores the difficulty of enacting meaningful change. Reform-minded leaders, like a well-intentioned mayor or an innovative bishop, find their efforts thwarted by entrenched political and institutional resistance, illustrating the arduous nature of social reform.

The Weight of Ineffectual Change

"Common Ground" serves as both a celebration of human diversity and a sobering account of societal challenges, particularly in urban settings. While Lukas does not propose solutions, his work highlights the need for new approaches to address issues like segregation and inequality. The narrative reflects on past failures and the complexity of societal change, urging a reevaluation of strategies to foster equitable progress.

Lukas’s portrayal of Boston’s tumultuous decade offers a profound exploration of the interplay between individual lives and systemic forces, providing a crucial understanding of the broader American experience. "Common Ground" stands as a testament to the enduring struggle for justice and equality, emphasizing the necessity for thoughtful, informed action in the pursuit of social harmony.

Loading...