The Color of Water

by James McBride

Start Free Trial

Analysis

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The Color of Water tells the compelling story of James McBride and his mother, Ruth, capturing their journey to reconcile complex identities across racial and cultural divides. At the heart of the narrative is the theme of dual identity, as Ruth navigates her Jewish heritage and her life within the African American community, while James seeks to understand himself through his mother’s past. The book weaves personal history with the broader tapestry of American society, exploring themes of identity, race, and family.

Ruth's Dual Identity

Central to the narrative is Ruth, born Rachel, a Jewish woman who transforms her life by separating from her past and integrating into New York City's black community. As Rachel, she carries the memories of a painful childhood, yet as Ruth, she embodies a vibrant Baptist matriarch with twelve children, who perceive her as a light-skinned black woman. Her Jewish upbringing informs her parenting style, emphasizing education and moral discipline, while her Baptist faith sustains her resilience. Despite her remarkable strength, a part of Ruth remains tethered to the sorrows of her past, creating a complex character who straddles distinct cultural worlds.

James's Quest for Identity

James McBride, Ruth's inquisitive son, embarks on a personal journey to understand his mother's concealed history. He realizes that to fully grasp his own identity, he must acknowledge the duality of his heritage. This quest involves delving into Ruth's Jewish past and her life in the African American community, enabling James to reconcile these seemingly disparate parts of himself. Ultimately, he embraces his identity as a biracial individual, discerning within himself elements of both a black man and a Jewish soul.

Intergenerational Exploration of Identity

James and Ruth's exploration of their identities is deeply intertwined with the historical context of 20th-century America, providing a backdrop that enriches their personal stories. Their journey is set against significant events such as Jewish immigration, the Great Depression, and the Civil Rights and Black Power movements of the 1960s. These events not only shape their individual identities but also contribute to their understanding of their place within the broader American narrative. Through this historical lens, both mother and son seek to reclaim aspects of themselves that were long buried, underscoring the importance of family history and memory in constructing a unified sense of self.

The Transcendence of Color

The title, The Color of Water, alludes to a transcendent ideal beyond racial boundaries, suggesting a color-blind approach to identity. This notion is intimately linked to the theme of doubleness, which pervades the lives of both mother and son. They navigate their dual identities—one tied to a Jewish, white world, and the other connected to a black, Baptist community. This journey leads them to embrace these identities as integral components of their whole selves. Ultimately, the story transcends cultural identity by celebrating Ruth’s unwavering determination and success in raising her children, despite numerous societal challenges.

A Tribute to Ruth's Legacy

Beyond the themes of identity and race, The Color of Water is a profound tribute to James McBride’s mother, Ruth. Her life story is a testament to the strength of character and the enduring power of education, family, and faith. The book honors her remarkable ability to overcome life's obstacles, ensuring her children’s successful upbringing and instilling in them the values that would guide their futures. Through Ruth's example, McBride illustrates the resilience and wisdom embedded in her beliefs, leaving readers with a lasting message of hope and perseverance.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Next

Critical Overview

Loading...