Colonial Living Critical Context - Essay

Edwin Tunis

Critical Context

(Survey of Young Adult Fiction)

Colonial Living, Tunis’ fourth book, received the Thomas A. Edison Foundation Award. It was favorably reviewed at the time of publication by The New York Times Book Review, as well as by the standard children’s book review journals such as Booklist and Horn Book. Tunis’ Frontier Living was published as a companion volume to Colonial Living in 1961.

Although still held by many libraries and cited in the sixteenth edition of Children’s Catalog (1991), the core list of books for children from preschool through sixth grade, Colonial Living is not mentioned in major textbooks on children’s literature. This omission is probably attributable to the fact that most of these textbooks are limited to children’s literature at the elementary level. Tunis’ prose may be difficult for the average elementary school reader in an era in which the trend in nonfiction for children is the photo essay.

Another notable trend in children’s nonfiction is the emphasis on careful documentation and provision of reference aids such as a glossary, a list of sources, and an index. Colonial Living includes none of the above. Although the depth of research suggested by the author’s remarks in the preface and acknowledgments is impressive, most teachers and librarians would prefer to see a bibliography of the sources used.

Also important in quality nonfiction are the illustrations. A more recent book on the same topic would be more likely to include a variety of media, particularly photographs or contemporary illustrations, but Tunis’ drawings should not be underestimated. In many cases, a good drawing is far superior to a photograph, and Tunis’ skill with pen and ink, as well as his fascination with the technology of an earlier era, is strongly reminiscent of David Macaulay’s works, such as the Caldecott Honor Book Cathedral (1974).