Themes: Nature versus Nurture
Capote incorporates extensive writings from Smith's sister, father, court-appointed psychiatrist, and friend Willie Jay, which detail Smith's upbringing, motorcycle accident, biases, and mental condition. These accounts collectively paint a picture of Smith as an inherently intelligent, talented, and sensitive individual, who has been distorted and damaged by neglect, abuse, humiliation, and unresolved emotional trauma. Smith's mother was an alcoholic who choked on her own vomit. His brother and sister took their own lives, while another sister disowned him. His father moved him frequently during his childhood, hindering his education. Despite this, Smith taught himself to play the guitar and harmonica, to paint, and to use precise grammar. He is an avid reader and, ‘‘being a bit of a prude,’’ avoids vulgar literature and materials. In prison, he painted a portrait of Jesus for the prison chaplain, prompting Reverend Post to believe Smith might not be "all that bad.’’ Capote's exploration of Smith's early life and family background raises the question of whether Smith's criminal actions are a result of inherent tendencies or if they are a consequence of circumstances beyond his control.
Expert Q&A
How is the nature versus nurture debate portrayed in In Cold Blood?
In "In Cold Blood," the nature versus nurture debate is explored through the backgrounds and actions of Perry Smith and Dick Hickock. Perry's abusive upbringing and troubled childhood suggest nurture influences his criminal behavior, while Dick's seemingly normal background implies an inherent nature for crime. Capote presents Perry as more sympathetic, hinting at nurture's impact, yet leaves the question open for interpretation, illustrating the complexity of their motivations and the debate itself.
How does the quote at the start of In Cold Blood relate to Capote's portrayal of Smith and Hickock?
"Men, our brothers, who live after us,
Do not harden your hearts against us,
For if you take pity on us poor wretches,
God will be more merciful toward you."
—Francois Villion
The quote at the beginning of In Cold Blood underscores Capote's aim to humanize Smith and Hickock, despite their brutal crime. Capote highlights Perry Smith's tragic past, evoking sympathy and suggesting that his violent actions stem from his own victimization. This aligns with the quote's plea for understanding and forgiveness. In contrast, Capote portrays Dick Hickock with less sympathy, emphasizing his violent tendencies. The quote suggests that compassion could break cycles of violence.
What evidence from In Cold Blood shows Perry Smith had personality disorganization?
Direct evidence of Perry’s possible personality disorganization can be found in his mixed-up feelings about gender and sexuality.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.