A Clean, Well-Lighted Place

by Ernest Hemingway

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

The significance and symbolism of the title "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place" and its relation to the theme

Summary:

The title "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place" symbolizes a refuge of order and clarity amidst the darkness and chaos of life. It reflects the theme of existential loneliness, as the characters seek solace in a well-lit café to escape their inner despair and the encroaching night, representing their search for meaning and comfort in an indifferent world.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What do darkness and light symbolize in "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place"?

Darkness in this short story symbolizes despair while light, especially when accompanied by cleanliness and order, symbolizes a refuge from the chaos and nothingness ("nada") of the universe.

In this story, an old man sits in "the shadow the leaves of the tree made against the electric light" of a cafe. This is a pleasant setting, though the shadows reflect the sadness that hovers over the old man's life. We learn that the old man recently tried to hang himself because of despair.

The light of the cafe provides the old man with a bulwark against his despair. This light represents safety. The younger waiter is angry that the old man is lingering late in the cafe. The younger waiter wants to get home to his wife. However, the older waiter understands why the old man stays, even though it is very late at night. He feels a sense of compassion for the old man, with whom he identifies.

The light of the cafe stands for the light of compassion. In a meaningless post-World War I world, islands of compassion and light like the cafe are important to keeping despair at bay. A clean, well-lit cafe may seem like very little in the larger scheme of things, but it is these little refuges that make life bearable.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What do darkness and light symbolize in "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place"?

In "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place," light symbolizes a safe refuge from the chaos of the world.

In this story, an old deaf man sits in the shadows in a café. The shadows represent his feelings of hopelessness. In fact, this old man has recently attempted to take his own life. Despite sitting in "the shadow of the leaves of the tree," the rest of the café is well lit and orderly. This setting provides the old man with a degree of safety and respite from his feelings of despair.

Although the old man lingers long enough in the café to upset the younger waiter, the older waiter understands that the old man needs this place of light for a refuge. In this sense, light also symbolizes compassion and empathy. When all else in the world seems to be lost in darkness, small places of light, safety, and understanding can make a world of difference to forlorn people like the old man.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the symbolic meaning of darkness in "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place"?

Darkness in this short story symbolizes despair. It is first associated with the deaf old man who stays late at the well-lit cafe drinking. He sits

in the shadow the leaves of the tree made against the electric light.

We learn that he recently tried to commit suicide by hanging himself but that his niece cut him down.

The darkness outside the clean, bright cafe is associated with the chaos and meaninglessness that the light and order of the cafe keeps at bay. The older waiter associates the darkness with "nada." In Spanish, nada means nothing. The older waiter uses the word to signify inner emptiness or meaninglessness, a sense of despair.

The older waiter therefore praises the orderliness, light, and cleanliness of his cafe, as well as the fact it offers seating, something the brightly lit bars don't. All of these features, taken together, represent a humane way of living, a contrast to the nada and darkness without.

While the younger waiter is impatient with the deaf old man for lingering when he wants to get home to his wife, the older waiter, who has experienced nada, understands why he stays. He feels compassion towards him and understands that the little things in life, such as the safe haven a comfortable, well-lit cafe offers, are not trivial in a dark, uncertain world.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place," what does the clean, well-lighted place represent?

Everybody needs a home, a haven, a place of refuge. In this story the bar run by the old man (and a young waiter) is such a place for all passing there:

In this story, Hemingway creates a classic opposition between light and darkness: the light in the café offers a temporary respite from the darkness outside. Both symbolically and physically, the old man takes refuge in drinking brandy in this pleasant atmosphere.

The younger waiter has no real conception of the psychological or spiritual dimension of the customer’s activity; hence, all he does is complain about not getting to go home on time. But the older waiter can relate. He has more patience because he, like the old man, has stared into the Great Nada, the “nothing he knew all too well.”

          -from enotes "A Clean, Well-lighted Place,' Brief Analysis'

Check out the references below concerning this novel by Hemingway and how it relates to his own philosophy concerning the human condition.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the significance and symbolism of the title "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place"?

The famous short story "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place" by Ernest Hemingway tells of an old man who sits late at a cafe drinking brandy and the two waiters who serve him. One of the waiters is young and impatient to get home to his wife. The other waiter is older and sympathizes with the old man in his loneliness. The story is told in Hemingway's minimalist style, in which much is implied but not directly stated. We don't know the names of the characters, for instance, or their backgrounds.

Some clues throughout the story help us understand the significance of the title. In the beginning, when the waiters are talking together, we learn that the old man tried to kill himself in despair. When one waiter asks why, the other says it was over nothing. Later, after the old man has left, the older waiter parodies the "Our Father" prayer by substituting "nothing" for most of the words.

The old man once had a wife but doesn't have one anymore. Apart from his loneliness, he probably feels useless, and he is coming close to the great darkness of death. He comes to the cafe to feel less lonely and to keep the darkness away, at least temporarily. It is important for the place to be clean and well-lit because this gives him a feeling of security, safety, and dignity. The cleanliness and light defend him from the nothingness, darkness, and despair of life. The old waiter shares the problem that the old man faces. He doesn't like the bar that he stops at because it is not clean, and he is unable to sleep because he fears the darkness. He is only able to fall asleep when the light of dawn comes.

In conclusion, the clean, well-lighted place symbolizes the security, safety, and dignity that the old man needs to keep away the darkness, despair, and nothingness that he would otherwise feel.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the significance and symbolism of the title "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place"?

The importance of the title lies in the way that it is used to describe the cafe that forms the setting of this short story. The story is set against a backdrop of suicide, meaningless life and the struggle for significance in a universe that seems to be defined in this short story by one word alone: the Spanish word "nada," meaning nothing. This bleak despair is something that even the bartender himself experiences as he contemplates his life and the "nothing" that his life represents. What is important about the cafe then is the way that it acts as something of an antidote to the nothingness of life and the bleak chaos it represents. This is why, the short story suggests, the cafe provides something of a shelter to those who suffer from their awareness of the oppressive nothingness of life, a place where nothingness can be forgotten. Note what the waiter thinks as he contemplates the cafe:

It was only that and light was all it needed and a certain cleanness and order... He disliked bars and bodegas. A clean, well-lighted cafe was a very different thing.

Cleanliness, light and order are shown in this story therefore to be important through the way in which they can act as a defence, albeit temporary, to the horror of nothingness and the bleak despair that can ensue and dominate a person's life, and indeed which threatens to dominate the life of the older waiter as he contemplates going back home and the fear that he suffers from. The cafe seems to give the older waiter hope, or at least it is an anchor that allows him to not let his life become unhinged by despair. The importance of the title therefore is based on its description of the cafe and the symbolism of this setting set against the theme of nihilism and nothingness that is explored in this short story.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does the title "A Clean, Well-lighted Place" relate to its theme?

In Hemingway's "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place," that is what one can hope for:  a clean, well-lighted place like the little cafe.

The story presents a realistic--some might say bleak--picture of reality and existence.  In this world, the story suggests, one finds meaning in small ways.  Bits of kindness or courtesy, peace, contentment, and comfortable surroundings are what one can hope for.  The place where the old man drinks his brandy is all he has. 

The world, as the speaker sees it, is bleak.  The old man "Last week...tried to commit suicide."  Why, or what about?  "Nothing."  Yet, though he is cut off and told he is "finished" by the inconsiderate of the two waiters, he leaves a tip and, when he leaves, walks "unsteadily but with dignity."

Meaning in the story is clutched from nothingness, and found in places like the little cafe. 

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does the title "A Clean, Well-lighted Place" relate to its theme?

The title "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place" reveals not only irony but the major themes of solidarity and dignity in the face of the unknowable.

Irony: the title is an ironic description of the physical setting of the bar.  It shows the public world of the old man and the two waiters.  All three no doubt act one way in public: with dignity.  One wonders how each act when they are in private.  We must assume that all are lonely, whether young or old.

Themes: the title juxtaposes the "nada" at the end.  So, we have a well-lit exterior world of things, but an empty dark world of character.  The theme is implicit: old men can show real dignity in public even though they may privately feel empty.  So says Enotes:

Hemingway is a writer obsessed by ethical conduct. The bulk of his writing is concerned with questions of good versus bad actions. In this fiction, it’s not about winning or losing, it’s about how you play the game. This is true, perhaps, because in Hemingway’'s fictional universe one rarely wins. The title of the collection from which “A Clean, Well-Lighted Place’’ comes suggests this complicated stance. It is called Winner Take Nothing. If one has won nothing as a winner, then all one has done is played the game.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How is the setting of "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place" related to its theme?

This story is set in a cafe late at night—or, more specifically, at a little after two o'clock in the morning. An old man sits at a table in the otherwise empty terrace of the cafe "in the shadow the leaves of the tree [make] against the electric light." For the old man who is alone and suicidal, the cafe terrace represents (as the title of the story suggests) a clean, well-lighted, and pleasant place to sit and drink.

The predominant themes of the story are loneliness and despair, as well as the absence of meaning and purpose which often goes hand-in-hand with them. The old man who sits at the table is lonely and—as indicated by his reported suicide attempts—despairing: without hope. The older of the two waiters is likewise lonely and (although not to the same degree) also seemingly without much hope.

The setting of the cafe reflects the loneliness of these characters in part because, except for the old man and the waiters, it is empty. This impression of emptiness and loneliness is also compounded by the time of day. Two o'clock in the morning is a very quiet, lonely time. Everybody else has gone home, and nobody else (except for the passing soldier and the girl) is awake yet.

The light in the cafe is also an important aspect of the setting and is described often throughout the story. The light symbolizes a source of solace. Indeed, the older of the two waiters says that he likes to stay late at the cafe to be with "all those who need a light for the night." The light is a the solace that the lonely characters rely on to subdue their despair.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How is the setting of "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place" related to its theme?

Like the old man who craves a well-lighted bar at which to drink, the older waiter of "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place" by Ernest Hemingway, desires to keep the care open, providing a light.  In fact, after the cafe closes, seeks another lighted place, for anywhere that is lighted is preferable to the darkness of aloneness and "nada."

Thus, the setting of Hemingway's story is essential to the theme of the nothingness (nada) of life where the lack of spiritual faith leaves an empty promise, something to be endured while it lasts (the lighted place) because nothing more awaits before it ends.  Indeed, this story's setting is most relevant to Hemingway's motif of nihilism, the "nada."

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does the title "A Clean, Well-lighted Place" relate to its theme?

Ernest Hemingway explores several themes in his short story "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place."

LOYALTY AND SOLIDARITY.  The two old men--the waiter and his customer--share this common bond. The waiter is completely loyal to his patron, in part because of their age, and also because they are both affected by the despair of the night. The old man is perfectly happy drinking by himself in the quiet cafe, away from the noise and crowds of bodegas. The waiter, too, suffers from what he hopes is only insomnia, and he reveals at the end of the story that he also prefers a clean, well-lighted place to while away his time.

ETHICAL CONDUCT.  The old waiter lives by a set of standards that is often not found in the younger generation, especially that of the young waiter. He cuts no corners, gladly staying deep into the night to wait on the single, old man who wishes to drink in peace. The young waiter, meanwhile, treats the old man poorly, purposely spilling his drink and rudely commenting--knowing that the old man is deaf--that he should have succeeded at his recent attempted suicide before demanding that he leave.

NOTHINGNESS.  "Nada," and "nothing," are repeated throughout the story. The word seems to have at least two possible meanings: One is of a material aspect, particularly financial, concerning a man's money or possessions. Another is the spiritual outlook of life, and the consideration that a person is a mere nothing in the vast, unexplainable expanse of life. 

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on