And of Clay Are We Created

by Isabel Allende

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

Characterization and realizations of Carle in "And of Clay Are We Created"

Summary:

In “And of Clay Are We Created,” Carle is characterized as a resilient and compassionate journalist who faces his own unresolved traumas. His realization comes as he connects deeply with Azucena, the trapped girl, understanding his own vulnerabilities and past pains, leading to a profound personal transformation and a deeper empathy for human suffering.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How is Carle described by the narrator in "And of Clay Are We Created"?

The narrator describes Ralf as a dedicated reporter, someone who seems to be imbued with courage as soon as he sets foot in front of a camera. Wherever he goes and whatever the story, he always seems unfailingly curious, unshakable in his fortitude. As a consummate professional, Ralf is also somewhat detached from his work, putting an emotional distance between himself and the people whose stories he reports.

All that changes, however, when Ralf begins to bond with Azucena, the little girl trapped by a deadly mudslide. He displays a more emotional side, a side that the narrator's never really seen before. He unburdens himself to Azucena, opening up about some of the more traumatic events of his formative years. The enormous anguish and frustration that Ralf feels, his sense of impotence, is etched all over his face. Even from a distance, the narrator can feel what Ralf must be...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

going through, as she watches events unfold on the live satellite feed.

After his long ordeal, Ralf is clearly physically exhausted and emotionally drained. He's no longer quite the same man; he's much more quiet, more contemplative. For the first time in his professional life, he became a part of the story, and for the first time too he forged an emotional connection with one of the subjects of his reports. Ralf identified with Azucena so completely that his whole identity became almost merged with hers, to the extent that the narrator must wait before his old self returns and they can walk together, hand in hand, once more.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What does Carle realize on the second night in "And of Clay Are We Created?"

During the second night Rolf Carlé spends with Azucena in Isabel Allende’s “And of Clay We Are Created,” he realizes through her suffering he cannot escape his tormented past.

As he stays with the child,who is burning in clay from the volcanic eruption, the demons of his childhood in Europe come to haunt him and he must confront them. In some ways, her plight is parallel to his. As a child, he was abused by his father and locked in an armoire for hours at a time for deeds he did not commit. This made him feel as though he was buried alive. He also sheltered his sister, who had Down’s Syndrome, from their father who found her to be a disappointment. Together, they hid under a dining room table that was draped with a large tablecloth. He witnessed evidence that his mother was abused, and he was forced to bury the dead in concentration camps.

During that second night, he realized he lived his whole adult life taking extraordinary chances to compensate for the trials he lived through during his youth. He is spent from these revelations and deteriorates into tears.

Approved by eNotes Editorial