Last Updated on May 6, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 545
From the peculiar typography of its title to its enigmatic mix of images, the CIVIL warS: a tree is best measured when it is down reflects Robert Wilson’s freely associated and often ambiguous reflections on the human condition. Admitting that the styling of the title may seem “pretentious,” he has...
(The entire section contains 545 words.)
Unlock This Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this the CIVIL warS study guide. You'll get access to all of the the CIVIL warS content, as well as access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.
- Critical Essays
From the peculiar typography of its title to its enigmatic mix of images, the CIVIL warS: a tree is best measured when it is down reflects Robert Wilson’s freely associated and often ambiguous reflections on the human condition. Admitting that the styling of the title may seem “pretentious,” he has stated that he had a reason for spelling it as he did. The play began with Wilson’s interest in the American Civil War, particularly as depicted in the photographs of Mathew Brady. It was the first war to be documented by photography, which provided a visual record of what war was actually like. Wilson then began to discover parallels between nineteenth century American and Japanese history; he focused on presenting historical images not as they would appear in a history text, but as they would seem in “a work by an artist, poetically interpreted.”
According to Wilson, his work’s title refers to “historical confrontations, not necessarily violent, which comment on man’s long journey toward brotherhood.” Besides the Civil War, these events include conflicts between the young Frederick the Great and his father, and other, more routine, occurrences that normally do not find their way into history books. The emphasis on the word “CIVIL” reflects his desire to portray civil strife and struggle. Wilson intended to depict “any kind of conflict one can imagine throughout history, from a child learning to tie his shoes, to someone leaving his family, to the situation now in Lebanon where there is very little difference between civilians and soldiers.” The phrase “a tree is best measured when it is down” was derived from a reflection by Carl Sandburg on the death of Abraham Lincoln.
According to Wilson, the CIVIL warS presents “a panorama of man’s struggle and survival through all history showing the shared nature of human experience among all peoples” before ending “as a great affirmation of the oneness of humanity and the possibility of universal accord.” In this respect, the work shares an affinity with the Olympic Games. Marked throughout their modern history by intense competition between the participating athletes as well as the countries they represent, the games nevertheless encourage civility and foster respect and understanding among opponents.
Although his work was considered to be in the forefront of artistic innovation in the 1980’s, Wilson felt that, like the Olympics, the CIVIL warS would be a truly international event comprehensible to audience members from around the world; certainly, part of the meaning of such a complex undertaking, had it been presented as planned, would have emanated from the very fact of its accomplishment. A “sound dream” rather than a narrative work, its literal aspect was meant to be eclipsed by its supraverbal psychological impact. “It’s done in twelve languages, it’s not meant for one culture,” Wilson states.One doesn’t need a special education or a background in theater to understand it, because there’s nothing to understand. It’s something one experiences. I try to give a text that has a certain space or dimension that allows you to see, where one doesn’t think so much, but can more freely associate, dream, and see one’s own pictures in one’s own mind. It’s accessible to anyone.