Chronicle of a Death Foretold
One of the foremost writers of El Boom Latinoamericano of the 1960’s, Gabriel García Márquez has steadily produced a series of works that have won for him both popular international acclaim and the official recognition that attaches to the Nobel Prize for Literature (1982). While his reputation rests securely upon such epic works as Cien años de soledad (1967; One Hundred Years of Solitude, 1970), and El otoño del patriarca (1975; The Autumn of the Patriarch, 1976), and such short fiction as Lo hojarasca (1955; Leaf Storm and Other Stories, 1972) and El coronel no tiene quien la escriba (1962; No One Writes to the Colonel and Other Stories, 1968); his Chronicle of a Death Foretold (published in Colombia in 1981 as Crónica de una muerte anunciada) clearly contributed to his official recognition as a master storyteller and continues to bring him popular acclaim despite its mixed critical reception. Measured against his longer and more ambitious works, García Márquez’s latest novel falls short of the virtuosity of One Hundred Years of Solitude and The Autumn of the Patriarch, but it is nevertheless a richly complex work, a monument to García Márquez’s artistry.
A virtually undisguised García Márquez shuttles back and forth between August, 1950, and his present moment of writing to narrate a series of events based on historical fact, his own research into the facts of the case and their fictionalized outcome, and his quest that leads him, at various historical points, to return to his “forgotten village, trying to put the broken mirror of memory back together from so many scattered shards.” One must approach these authorial and narrational shuttlings warily, particularly in those instances in which fact and fiction intersect: The narrator remains a fictional character of limited perspective and at times appears to be the victim of some authorial irony. One must also tread warily in the footsteps of the narrator, who leads the reader, familiarly and openly, to a place abutting that celebrated region of a mind’s geography García Márquez calls the Macondo, the Caribbean coastal area of northern Colombia that has its North American counterpart in the famous Yoknapatawpha county of his avowed master, William Faulkner. The mind’s geography also intersects that of cartographers: The unnamed village may not be unlike the author’s native Aracataca; both Riohacha, where the Vicario brothers serve out their brief sentence, and Manaure, where the rest of the Vicarios live after Santiago Nasar’s death, are surely on the map. These places also belong to a magical region filled with the incongruities, oddities, small insanities, and omnipresent hostilities that characterize its genuinely human, sometimes warm, and truly unforgettable populace. So, too, the facts upon which García Márquez weaves his fiction are verifiable: In 1951, two brothers murdered a man in Sucre, Colombia, for being the supposed lover of their sister, another man’s bride. García Márquez, then a journalist, was acquainted with the victim. The fictional treatment of these bare facts is pure García Márquez and partakes of what has been termed his “magical realism”, 6 a technique that superadds fantasy to the shards of history in surprising ways.
The chronicle García Márquez presents is a tale of slaughter that affects the village’s entire population. Twin brothers, Pablo and Pedro Vicario, avenge the honor of their sister, Angela, a bride of five hours, returned home by her groom, Bayardo San Román, upon his discovery that she was not a virgin. Santiago Nasar, the man whom Angela names when asked who deflowered her, is an unlikely suspect; indeed, no one really believes that he is responsible. It is Nasar’s death that...
(This entire section contains 1965 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
is foretold in the novel’s first sentence, variously heralded before the fact, and explicated, discussed, and rationalized once it has occurred. The chronicle is itself, however, incomplete, despite the fact that García Márquez has said it was thirty years in the making: The one shard of memory not found and replaced is the secret Angela Vicario never reveals—the name of her actual lover.
As author and narrator, García Márquez uses the improbabilities of life and the techniques of fiction to comment upon the nature of reality in a work that treats life in the spirit of art and art in the spirit of life. Early in the chronicle, the narrator refers to the door before which Nasar was murdered as having been “cited several times with a dime-novel title: ’The Fatal Door.’” Later, twenty-three years after the tragedy, the narrator, unlike his creator, finds himself in an uncertain period of his life selling encyclopedias and medical books in the towns of Guajira. There, he glimpses Angela Vicario, a figure with steel-rimmed glasses and yellowish gray hair, seated at her embroidery machine. “I refused to believe,” he writes, “that the woman there was who I thought it was, because I couldn’t bring myself to admit that life might end up resembling bad literature so much.” The same motif appears in García Márquez’s account of the investigating magistrate who visits the village twelve days after the crime: “he never thought it legitimate that life should make use of so many coincidences forbidden literature, so that there should be the untrammeled fulfillment of a death so clearly foretold.” Here, fiction-as-fact is commenting on fiction-as-fiction in a multi-mirrored regression. The preoccupation with literature and its relation to life—and the creation of the chronicle is one example of such a preoccupation—extends to a preoccupation with the act of writing, ordering the perception and memory of experience and reordering experience itself.
Most of what the narrator learns comes from direct observation and conversation, but significant portions of knowledge come from written sources. He first learns of Bayardo San Román’s entry to the village from his mother’s letters to him, and his reconstruction of the judicial inquiry into Nasar’s death is drawn from his five-year effort at rummaging around the sometimes flooded record offices of the Palace of Justice at Riohacha, where he secured only 322 pages of a much longer brief. The reordering of experience, the chronicling of a death foretold, represents a significant, long-term effort on the narrator’s part, an effort that spans three decades and is, finally, an effort directed at fixing in words, at writing, the history of a calamity that befell Santiago Nasar, Angela Vicario, Bayardo San Román and, indeed, the whole town. This act of writing, arguably the unifying theme of the work, is mirrored and surpassed by the prodigious writing of Angela Vicario herself, writing that is entirely obsessive and that chronicles her own existence over approximately twenty-seven years. Angela, seized by the memory of San Román, who “had been in her life forever from the moment he’d brought her back home,” writes him long letters with no future, letters he never answers until finally a fat, bespectacled and balding Bayardo San Román pays his visit and returns to her the nearly two thousand letters she has written him. A quintessential García Márquez touch closes the chapter: The two thousand letters are arranged chronologically in bundles tied with colored ribbons, “and they were all unopened.”
At the heart of the novel is the double standard of sexual morality and, with it, the strange, dark power of sex and sexuality that pervades the culture García Márquez depicts. This double standard in its Latin-American form is part of a larger cultural phenomenon embraced by the term machismo, a phenomenon noted in many sociological and psychological works and summarized pithily in Manuel de Jesus Guerrero’s El machismo Latinoamericano (1977). There is, for example, no thought that Angela Vicario could come legitimately to the marriage bed having had another lover, just as there is no thought that the amorous exploits of Santiago Nasar with Maria Alejandrina Cervantes and the girls of her bordello should interfere with his right to marry—and expect virginity from—his fiancée, Flora Miguel.
The lot of women, in fact, receives considerable attention in the novel. In Hispanic cultures, boys are brought up to be men while girls are “reared to get married.” The Vicario girls, for example, are exemplary in their devotion to the cult of death and should make any man happy “because they’ve been raised to suffer.” When Angela hints obliquely that, despite the fact that her parents arranged that she marry Bayardo San Román and obliged her to do so, she had an inconvenient lack of love for him, the matter is settled by her mother’s phrase, “Love can be learned too.” The one voice that undercuts the stereotypical view of Hispanic women is that of the narrator’s mother, a voice that is not without humor. That Angela dons the wedding veil and orange blossoms is, after her return, interpreted as a profanation of the symbols of purity. Recognizing the courage it took for Angela to do so, she comments, “In those days God understood such things.”
In a work that deals with the more somber elements of existence, with frustration, betrayal, and the imposition of a one-sided code of conduct, there are also many wryly humorous passages. One, for example, seems to parody Gustave Flaubert’s famous operating-room scenes: The grisly, botched autopsy on Nasar leads to the conclusion that, based upon the weight of the encephalic mass, he had not only a superior intelligence but also a brilliant future. So outrageous is the autopsy and so poorly is it executed that Colonel Aponte, the mayor, whose personal logic is elsewhere presented for the illogic it is and whose responsibility for numerous massacres is clearly established, becomes a vegetarian as well as a spiritualist. Another instance illustrates both García Márquez’s mastery of form and his pervasive sense of the incongruities of which humor is born. One of the dozens of minor characters who weave through the novel, Magdalena Oliver, is present on the boat when San Román arrives at the village and also witnesses his inglorious departure. On both occasions, she draws an incorrect conclusion based on his appearance, first thinking him a homosexual and then, as he leaves, concluding that he is dead and making a remark about waste which Gregory Rabassa wisely leaves untranslated. Magdalena thus frames San Román’s entry and exit with complete understanding.
Elsewhere García Márquez has said that the historical personage he most detests is Cristóbal Colón (Christopher Columbus). It is not without significance that Bayardo San Román first meets his future bride “on the national holiday in October.” This holiday, celebrated throughout the Americas as Columbus Day, is also known in Colombia as Fiesta de la Raza, a nomenclature devised early in this century to downplay the commemoration of colonialism and its oppressive legacy. October, one recalls from García Márquez’s story “No One Writes to the Colonel,” is an unpropitious time in general; in Chronicle of a Death Foretold, October 12 is doubly unpropitious: It is the day when Bayardo (whose name is too close to the word boyardo, which Rabassa translates as “seigneur,” to ignore) buys up all the raffle tickets from, and presents the prize (a music box) to, his intended conquest, Angela Vicario; it is also the unfortunate Angela’s birthday.
These small touches, matter-of-factly stated, and scores of other similarly deft strokes combine to form a highly wrought vision of a tragic event. It is a deliberately fragmented vision, one more tentative addition to the one book of solitude that García Márquez claims, in El olor de la Guayaba (1982; The Smell of Guava, 1984), to be his life’s work.
Historical Context
The Birth of Latin American Culture
The term "Latin America" encompasses the Caribbean islands and the mainland
regions stretching from Mexico to the southern tip of South America. Latin
America's history is extensive, beginning with Columbus' arrival in 1492.
Primarily settled by Spanish and Portuguese immigrants, Latin American culture
is a blend of European influences and indigenous traditions. Marquez
masterfully weaves these cultural elements in his work, Chronicle of a Death
Foretold.
Upon their arrival, the Spanish and Portuguese quickly subdued the native populations. They dismantled indigenous architecture, replaced native religions with Catholicism, and reinforced the existing class system. As diseases brought by Europeans decimated the native peoples, a new generation emerged from the unions between male colonists and female natives. This mixed population, known as mestizos, now forms the majority of Latin American society. Alongside mestizos, the remaining natives and African slaves constituted the lower class, working as slaves or in mines. The upper class was composed of whites from Spain and Portugal, referred to as peninsulares, who were the only ones allowed to hold public office or professional roles. Between these classes were the Creoles, European whites born in the colonies, who, despite being equal to peninsulares, were barred from government positions and professional work. The tension between peninsulares and Creoles played a significant role in the wars for independence.
Colombian Civil Wars
In Chronicle of a Death Foretold, Ibrahim Nasar arrives in the village
after the civil wars. García Márquez is referring to the Colombian wars for
independence. In the 1700s, Colombia, then known as New Granada, faced a
separatist movement due to taxation and political and commercial restrictions
on the Creoles. Independence was secured with Simon Bolivar's victory at the
Battle of Boyaca, but conflicts between Conservatives and Liberals ensued over
the separation of church and state. Conservatives advocated for a strong
centralized government and the preservation of traditional class and clerical
privileges. In contrast, Liberals supported universal suffrage and complete
church-state separation. These ideological battles have persisted over the
years.
Post-Colonial Latin America
By 1830, most Latin American colonies had secured independence from their
colonial powers. Although they continued trading with Spain, Portugal, and
Great Britain, they began to establish themselves as major exporters of raw
materials worldwide. Besides experiencing economic growth, Latin America also
saw a significant population increase. Immigrants flocked to Latin America from
less prosperous or politically unstable European nations. This surge in
population and economic development persisted throughout the twentieth century.
By the late 1990s, the Latin American economy had grown to match the sizes of
the economies of France, Italy, or the United Kingdom.
Latin American Literature
Latin American literature is closely intertwined with the region's history.
Literary scholars typically categorize it into four distinct periods: the
colonial period, the independence period, the national consolidation period,
and the contemporary period. During the colonial era, literature mirrored its
Spanish and Portuguese influences, mainly consisting of didactic prose and
event chronicles. The early 1800s independence movement ushered in patriotic
themes, predominantly in poetic form. The subsequent consolidation period saw
the rise of Romanticism—and later, modernism—with essays becoming the preferred
mode of expression. Eventually, Latin American literature transitioned into
short stories and drama, which matured in the early twentieth century. The
mid-twentieth century witnessed the emergence of magical realism, epitomized by
García Márquez, a key figure in the "boom" trend of novel writing in the 1960s
and 1970s. During this period, male voices and themes were predominant.
Recently, however, female writers have gained recognition for both their early
contributions and their contemporary accomplishments.
Literary Style
Point of View
One of the most remarkable aspects of Chronicle of a Death Foretold is
the perspective García Márquez employs to narrate the tale. The story is told
from the first-person viewpoint of an unnamed character, who is the son of
Luisa Santiaga and the brother of Margot, Luis, Jaime, and a nun. Having
returned to the river village after a twenty-seven-year absence, the narrator
attempts to piece together the events leading to Santiago Nasar's murder.
Typically, a first-person narrator provides their own perspective but lacks
insight into other characters' thoughts, a trait usually associated with the
third-person omniscient perspective. However, in this novel, García Márquez
breaks convention: the narrator recounts the story in the first person while
also revealing the thoughts of all characters.
SettingChronicle of a Death Foretold is set in a small Latin American river village along the Caribbean coast, sometime after the civil wars. Once a bustling hub for shipping and ocean-going vessels, the town's commerce has dwindled due to changing river currents.
The storyline unfolds over a two-day period. A wedding has recently taken place between a prominent local young woman and a wealthy stranger who has lived in the town for only six months. On the day of the murder, most townspeople are nursing hangovers from the wedding festivities. Despite this, a festive atmosphere persists due to the anticipated visit from the bishop.
Foreshadowing
Foreshadowing usually involves an author's subtle hints about an upcoming
event. García Márquez adds a unique twist by explicitly stating what will
happen but not why it will occur. The entire narrative builds upon the
premonition of Santiago's murder. The twins openly declare their intentions,
informing everyone they encounter. Each villager who hears of the plot passes
it on to the next person. Santiago himself dreams of birds and trees the night
before his death, a vision his mother later interprets as a warning of his
demise. Ultimately, even Santiago becomes aware of his impending death.
Dream Vision
In Chronicle of a Death Foretold, characters frequently mention dreams
and visions connected to Santiago's imminent death. Santiago's mother, known
for her skill in interpreting dreams, fails to grasp the significance of
Santiago's dream about his own demise. He describes a dream in which he walks
through a grove of trees and wakes up feeling as if he is covered in bird
droppings. She later recalls focusing only on the part about the birds, which
usually symbolize good health. Clotilde Armenta, reflecting years after the
murder, says she thought Santiago "already looked like a ghost" when she saw
him at dawn that morning. Margot Santiaga, hearing Santiago boast that his
wedding would surpass Angela Vicario's, "felt the angel pass by." The author's
frequent references to dreams and visions enhance the surrealistic tone typical
of magical realism.
Magical Realism
Magical realism originated within Latin American culture. Although critics
often credit Cuban novelist and short story writer Alejo Carpentier with its
inception, they acknowledge that García Márquez has upheld the tradition. This
genre blends reality with the fantastic, grounding its stories in historical
facts while weaving in imaginative elements. García Márquez highlighted this in
an interview with Peter H. Stone in The Paris Review, stating, "It
always amuses me that the biggest praise for my work comes for the imagination
while the truth is that there's not a single line in all my work that does not
have a basis in reality."
Techniques / Literary Precedents
In a style reminiscent of writers like John Dos Passos and Ernest Hemingway, Garcia Marquez blends journalism with fiction in Chronicle of a Death Foretold. This novel, composed of five chapters, condenses the vivid reenactment and subsequent fallout of Santiago Nasar's ritualistic death into a brief timeline. On the morning of his murder, Santiago wakes up to drink a ritualistic cup of coffee, dresses in a white linen suit, and then walks ceremoniously through the town's streets before his destined encounter with the Vicario brothers. Rejected by the townspeople, Santiago is symbolically disowned by his family, and the locked door of his house becomes the altar for his demise.
Though considered a minor work in Garcia Marquez's literary collection, Chronicle of a Death Foretold is a fascinating tour de force, merging cinematic presentation with artistic creativity. Purposefully crafted, the novel intertwines suspenseful action with imaginative imagery to create a highly readable piece of fiction. Most notably, it succeeds as a mystery even though the reader is already aware of the crime's nature and its consequences.
Media Adaptations
- Graciela Daniele transformed Chronicle of a Death Foretold into a Broadway musical, which was showcased at the Plymouth Theater in New York City in July 1995. Although the production garnered mixed reviews, it was nominated for a Tony award in the Best Musical category.
Bibliography and Further Reading
Sources
Alonso, Carlos. "Writing and Ritual in Chronicle of a Death Foretold."
In Gabriel García Márquez' New Readings, edited by Bernard McGuirk and
Richard Cardwell. Cambridge University Press, 1987, pp. 151-68.
Berg, Mary G. "Repetitions and Reflections in Chronicle of a Death Foretold." In Critical Perspectives on Gabriel García Márquez, edited by Bradley A. Shaw and Nora Vera-Godwin. Society of Spanish and Spanish-American Studies, 1986, pp. 139-56.
Burgess, Anthony. Review in The New Republic, Vol. 188, No. 1, May 2, 1983, p. 36.
Christie, John S. "Fathers and Virgins: García Márquez's Faulknerian Chronicle of a Death Foretold." In Latin American Review, Vol. 21, No. 41, June, 1993, pp. 21-29.
De Feo, Ronald. Review in Nation, December 2, 1968.
Elnadi, Bahgat, Adel Rifaat, and Miguel Labarca. "Gabriel García Márquez: The Writer's Craft." Interview in UNESCO Courier, February, 1996, p. 4.
García Márquez, Gabriel. Interview with Claudia Dreifus in Playboy, February, 1983.
Gass, William H. "More Deaths Than One: Chronicle of a Death Foretold." In New York Magazine, Vol. 16, No. 15, April 11, 1983, pp. 83-4.
Grossman, Edith. Review in Review, September/December, 1981.
Mano, Keith. Review in National Review, Vol. 35, No. 2, June 10, 1983, p. 699.
Millington, Mark. "The Unsung Heroine: Power and Marginality in Chronicle of a Death Foretold." In Bulletin of Hispanic Studies, Vol. 66, 1989, pp. 73-85.
Petrakis, Harry Mark. Review in Tribune Books, April 17, 1988.
Sheppard, R. Z. Review in Time, March 16, 1970.
Stone, Peter H. Interview in Paris Review, Winter, 1981.
Streitfeld, David. Review in Washington Post, October 22, 1982.
Sturrock, John. Review in New York Times Book Review, September 29, 1968.
Yardley, Jonathan. Review in Washington Post Book World, November 25, 1979.
For Further Study
Bell-Villada, Gene H. García Márquez: The Man and His Work. University
of North Carolina Press, 1990. This book, complemented by an extensive
bibliography, places Márquez among authors known for blending the ordinary with
innovative philanthropic political themes.
Donoso, Jose. The Boom in Spanish American Literature, translated by Gregory Kolovakos. Columbia University Press, 1977. Donoso argues that the label "the Boom Generation" is somewhat misleading but acknowledges the significance of the period's novels and writers. He also provides an explanation of the term's origin.
Gonzalez Echevarria, Roberto. Myth and Archive: A Theory of Latin American Narrative. Cambridge University Press, 1990. Echevarria offers an extensive bibliography that supports his theory on the genesis and evolution of the Latin American narrative in relation to the modern novel.
Gabriel García Márquez and the Powers of Fiction, edited by Julio Ortega. University of Texas Press, 1988. This compilation of critical essays on Gabriel García Márquez's works provides insights into his style through the perspectives of various scholars.
Landmarks in Modern Latin American Fiction, edited by Philip Swanson. Routledge [and] Kegan Paul, 1990. This collection of essays focuses on key texts from the "Boom" period in Latin American literature, providing a backdrop for understanding the era's influential works.
Martin, Gerald. Journeys Through the Labyrinth: Latin American Fiction in the Twentieth Century. Verso, 1989. Covering the period from the 1920s to the 1980s, the author explores Latin American literature through thematic and historical lenses. He introduces new works and authors, alongside a list of primary texts and a critical bibliography.
Wolin, Merle Linda. "Hollywood Goes Havana: Fidel, Gabriel, and the Sundance Kid." In The New Republic, Vol. 202, No. 16, April 16, 1990, p. 17. This article highlights the globally renowned Foundation for New Latin American Cinema and its film school in Cuba, led by García Márquez. The school, supported by notable figures like Robert Redford, offers comprehensive courses in the art and craft of filmmaking.