1. The ending of the novel leaves many readers unsettled because it does not provide a "happy ending." Others argue that it is the only logical conclusion to the story. Which perspective do you agree with?

2. As the story unfolds, Obie appears increasingly intolerant of Archie's actions. What stops him from standing up against Archie?

3. Both Carter and Obie are wary of Archie's "psychological" strategies. How does Archie maintain control over the Vigils without resorting to physical force?

4. A distinctive feature of Cormier's writing is his use of a shifting point of view, allowing us to experience the narrative through various characters' perspectives. How does this enhance our understanding of the story?

5. Goober is one of the novel's most enigmatic characters. Faced with the same circumstances, would you have acted as he did? Why or why not?

6. Despite cooperating on the candy sale, Leon and Archie seem to harbor dislike for each other. What is the underlying reason for this mutual disdain?

7. What convinces Archie and Carter that Jerry Renault poses a significant threat to the Vigils?

8. Given the importance of every dollar in the candy sale, how can you explain Leon's calm demeanor in response to Jerry's refusal to participate?

9. From Archie's perspective, sending Emile after Jerry Renault appears ineffective. Why does he believe the "boxing match-raffle" will be more successful?

10. Considering what we know about Archie's personality, why does he never end up drawing the black marble?

11. The novel's opening chapter introduces Jerry as he tries out for the football team. What does Cormier intend for the reader to learn about Jerry through this scene? Does Jerry's later behavior support this understanding?

12. Brother Leon is the only teacher depicted in the classroom within the novel. Does Cormier want the reader to see him as a typical teacher, or does he represent a negative example of a teacher?

13. Chapter 14 focuses on a minor character named "Tubs" Caspar. What is the author's purpose in telling us about this isolated, overweight student?

14. Emile evades consequences for his aggressive behavior because he has uncovered something about human nature. What is this weakness that allows him to remain unchallenged? Is his insight into people similar to or different from Archie's?

15. The "hippie" Jerry encounters in the third chapter tells him he is "missing a lot of things in the world." Later, Jerry recognizes the truth in this statement. What does he believe he is missing?