Themes: Slavery, Freedom, and Rebellion
Throughout the book, Isabel’s actions are in service of one overarching goal: liberating herself and her sister, Ruth, from enslavement. This goal is especially urgent to Isabel, who now has to live knowing just how close the two came to achieving freedom—per the will of Miss Mary Finch, they were to be freed upon Miss Finch’s death. When Mr. Robert Finch denies them this promise in order to make money on their sale to the Locktons, the inherent injustice of this enslavement is painfully multiplied.
Isabel’s struggle for freedom is mirrored by the book’s wartime setting. In the Revolutionary War, Loyalists to the crown fought in opposition to the rebel movement for American independence. Isabel, caught between these two worlds, is unsure which alignment offers her and Ruth the greatest chance at their overdue liberation.
Though her fight for freedom is a constant struggle from the moment it’s denied to her at Miss Mary Finch’s funeral, Isabel’s moment of true clarity comes in chapter 42, when she reads the copy of Thomas Paine's Common Sense covertly given to her by the rebel bookseller: “Way I saw it, Mr. Paine was saying all people were the same, that no one deserved a crown or was born to be higher than another. That’s why America could make its own freedom . . . If an entire nation could seek freedom, why not a girl?”
Expert Q&A
What is the difference between a servant and a slave in Chains by Laurie Halse Anderson?
In "Chains," the difference between a servant and a slave is highlighted by value, consent, and treatment. Servants are paid and work by choice under a contract for a set period, while slaves are unpaid and forced to work indefinitely. Slaves like Isabel are threatened with violence, whereas servants like Becky often receive better treatment. Skin color does not define servitude; however, slaves are considered property, while servants have the option to leave after their contract ends.
Describe Curzon from the book "Chains" and what he fights for.
Curzon, a young slave in "Chains," is owned by Bellingham but enjoys more freedom than Isabel. Politically aware and educated, he spies for the Patriots against the Loyalists, recruiting others like Isabel to aid his cause. A fervent supporter of the American Revolution, Curzon identifies as an American soldier. He is also a devoted friend to Isabel, showing her kindness and care, which ultimately motivates her to rescue him from jail.
How does Isabel's viewpoint differentiate between freedom and liberty in Chains, according to Mr. Lockton's explanation?
An essay that differentiates Isabel’s and Lockton’s perspectives on freedom and liberty in Chains could contrast the hypocrisy of Lockton with the generosity of Isabel. When Isabel acquires freedom, she doesn’t abandon the people she cares about. Instead, she tries to help them gain liberty as well.
What does freedom mean to Mr. Lockton in Chains?
For Mr. Lockton, freedom means being left alone by rebels to live his preferred lifestyle, reflecting his status as a Loyalist. He is indifferent to the freedom of others, including his slaves, Ruth and Isabel, and his wife, whom he controls tyrannically. Lockton views freedom as a zero-sum game, where his own freedom is dependent on the oppression of others, aligning with his belief in slavery and white supremacy.
How do Mr. Lockton, the Patriots, and Isabel each define freedom in the context of the American Revolution?
How did slave life differ on large plantations, small farms, and in cities?
Slave life varied significantly based on location. On large plantations and small farms, slaves faced harsh conditions, living in poorly constructed shacks with inadequate clothing, and punishments were severe due to isolation. In contrast, urban slaves often lived in better conditions, such as attics or basements of households, benefiting from better insulation and clothing. The differences were not due to a more humane view of slaves but rather the visibility and reputation concerns of urban slave owners.
What mental chains prevent Isabel's freedom in the novel Chains?
Her belief that political and legal powers will eventually free her and her fears of taking bold steps for herself are two mental chains that Isabel breaks in Chains.
What is the Patriots' view of freedom in Chains?
The Patriots' view of freedom is complex, as Isabel's narrative highlights. While they seek independence from England, seeing themselves as enslaved, they fail to apply these principles universally. Isabel, as a woman of color, perceives the hypocrisy in advocating freedom from British rule while maintaining slavery. Her perspective reveals the double standard and limited scope of the Patriots' freedom, illustrating their fight for liberty as flawed and not universally applied.
What does the rebels' action of taking down the king's statue in Chains by Laurie Halse Anderson signify?
The rebels' action of taking down King George III's statue in "Chains" symbolizes their public declaration of defiance against England. This event, where they dismantle the statue for bullets, signifies their commitment to the Revolutionary cause. The irony of the statue being gold-plated but made of lead highlights the deceptive nature of British authority. This act foreshadows the intense and brutal conflicts that characterize the American Revolution.
Isabel's Perspective on Freedom in Chains
In Chains, Isabel's perspective on freedom contrasts with Curzon's. Curzon views freedom as a collective struggle against Loyalists, believing loyalty to the Patriots could lead to widespread emancipation. Isabel, however, prioritizes immediate survival for herself and her sister, Ruth, over abstract freedoms. For Isabel, freedom embodies defiance and self-preservation, requiring physical action and sacrifice. She perceives freedom not as a granted right but as something to be actively fought for, enduring hardships along the way.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.