What does Isabel mean by "I was chained between two nations" in Chains?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

This quote appears in chapter 29 of the book. It's a great quote because of its brevity. By this point in the novel, Isabel has deeply considered which side of the conflict to take; however, her thinking isn't based on which country she thinks is right or wrong. Isabel debates which cause she should support based on which side she believes will grant her freedom soonest. What Isabel discovers is that neither side really truly wants to grant her and the rest of the slaves freedom. Each side simply wants to use the slaves as pieces on a chess board, and they dangle freedom in front of the slaves as a motivational tool. Regardless of who Isabel supports, she is likely to remain a slave "chained" to that cause. Each side wants her, and each side pulls that metaphorical chain in order to keep her from going to the other side. In the end, Isabel chooses her own freedom. She escapes from the Lockton house, forges her freedom papers, and leaves New York. She breaks her chains by choosing her own side.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I think that there can be a couple of ways to interpret this.  The first would be that on the most literal level, Isabel is chained to the Loyalist home of the Locktons.  Being Loyalists, this is one nation to which Isabel is physically chained because she is a slave in their home.  Yet, she might also be seen as chained to the hopes of the Patriot side.  It is evident throughout the narrative that Isabel empathizes with the Patriotic cause because she views freedom for her own sense of being in the same light that the Patriots view it in their relationship with England.  The "chained between two nations" could come to represent the physical bondage in which she is immersed in the Loyalist nation, but also can come to represent how she so strongly identifies with the Patriotic cause.  These become the two nations to which she is physically and emotionally chained.  

Another reading of this could be more introspective.  On one hand, Isabel finds herself chained to the Patriotic cause and the cause of the newly conceived American nation.  Yet, she also understands in the course of the narrative that the Patriotic cause is one that might not include the liberation of slavery.  Isabel is perceptive enough to understand that the fight for the Patriotic conception of freedom does not apply to the slaves within the nation.  The chaining that Isabel could speak of here reflects her desire to want freedom for the Patriots, as she identifies with their cause.  Yet, she is equally chained to the idea that as a woman of color, slavery is not going to be abolished in the new nation.  Hence, her chaining here consists of wanting freedom for the nation and for her own sense of self.  Isabel can be seen as being chained between these two nations.  In such an exploration, Anderson's development of Isabel's characterization is complex and intricate with regards to the issue of freedom and being "chained between two nations."

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial