Student Question

In "Chains", why did the men stop talking when Isabel and Becky entered, but resumed after Becky left?

Quick answer:

The men stop talking when Becky is present because they consider her, a white servant, capable of understanding and potentially repeating their conversation. However, they resume once Becky leaves and Isabel remains, as they view Isabel, a black slave, as insignificant and incapable of understanding or relaying their discussions. This reflects the pervasive racism and dehumanization of slaves, allowing Isabel to overhear critical information about their conspiracies, as she is not perceived as a threat.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The men do not consider Isabel a person capable of listening and understanding their conversation.  They believe this about Isabel because she is a black slave. 

Isabel has always known that white slave owners think less of her, but in chapter six Curzon flat out tells Isabel that the Locktons do not consider Isabel a human being.  Curzon asks Isabel to spy on the Locktons, but Isabel thinks that she won't hear anything worthwhile.  

"They won't say anything in front of me."  

"You are a small black girl, Country," he said bitterly.  "You are a slave, not a person.  They'll say things in front of you they won't say in front of the white servants.  'Cause you don't count to them.  It happens all the time to me." 

There was truth in his words, hard truth, a hammer striking stone. 

It turns out that Curzon is correct because Isabel overhears many important pieces of information while she is the same room as Lockton and his conspirators.  She overhears the plot to bribe members of the Patriot army, and she overhears the plot to assassinate General George Washington.  The entire assassination plot was discussed while Isabel was in the same room as the men!  They don't consider her a person at all.  They act like she is the house dog or something like that.  Isabel is present, but ultimately doesn't matter. 

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial