Student Question
Why is defining postmodernism challenging for critics, and how does the merging of national boundaries contribute to this?
Quick answer:
Defining postmodernism is challenging because it lacks a unified set of principles, unlike ideologies such as Fascism or Communism. Postmodernism emerges as a reaction to the failure of coherent systems, exemplified by events like World War II and the Atomic Age. The merging of national boundaries, as part of globalization, complicates its definition further. This phenomenon weakens nationalist identities, as seen in the European Union's border policies and Brexit, highlighting the complexity of postmodern trends.
One of the challenges in defining postmodernism lies in an inherent assumption in such a project. There are countless writers and thinkers whose work can be classified as postmodernist in that they reject some or all of the basic tenets of modernism. However, a common analytical error is to treat postmodernist trends as if they represent an “ism” such as Fascism or Communism that is based on a coherent set of principles or tenets. Instead, postmodernist thinking is a response to the destruction or failure of such coherence, as evidenced by the global destabilization that began in, or contributed to causing, World War Two. For some, postmodernism is most potently symbolized by the Atomic Age, especially its birth through the immoral acts of dropping atomic bombs. Such literal destruction may be conceptually linked to the fragmentation of holistic models of culture and identity.
The relationship of postmodern trends to weakened national boundaries is generally observed as a facet of globalization. Consumer culture is portrayed as an ever-stronger component of both economy and politics in nations that exhibit otherwise diverse characteristics. In this scenario, nationalist impulses decrease as identification with inter- or supranational entities increases. In the 2000s, the logic of this approach has increasingly been called into question. The tightening of borders throughout the European Union, as increasing numbers of African migrants arrived in Europe, is one such contradictory situation. Another ongoing case is the relationship between Britain and the European Union, in the “Brexit” phenomenon.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
References