Historical Context

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The years after World War II were a period of difficulty in Britain. A fuel crisis in 1947 left many people without heat, and food shortages meant that wartime rationing continued well into the late 1940s. Additionally, there was a severe housing shortage. During the war, construction had halted, resulting in two hundred thousand houses being completely destroyed and half a million more needing extensive repairs. Some Britons found hope in socialism, leading to the development of the Welfare State in the late 1940s, which made the government responsible for helping the poor. In 1946, the National Insurance Act and the National Health Service Act were enacted, offering insurance and medical care to the underprivileged. The National Assistance Act was created to provide a safety net for those in need. Many believed these new government policies would eradicate poverty.

However, these optimistic expectations were soon proven wrong. Moreover, those who viewed socialism as a solution to Britain's issues became disillusioned by the Soviet Union's 1956 invasion of Hungary, which demonstrated that a socialist system could be just as violent and corrupt as any other political system.

During this period, Britain's global standing also declined. Previous generations had claimed that the sun would never set on the British Empire, but now that empire was disintegrating, with former colonies like India gaining independence from British rule. In 1956, the Suez Crisis, where Britain was condemned by the United Nations for attempting to seize control of the Suez Canal in Egypt, resulted in international embarrassment for the former empire. British troops were forced to withdraw, and the Prime Minister resigned due to the incident.

Despite these political challenges, the late 1950s saw some economic recovery domestically, and a consumer culture emerged, centered on acquiring material goods. Between 1953 and 1960, ownership of what were once luxury items, such as refrigerators, washing machines, and automobiles, increased significantly. Additionally, the advent of television created a new perceived need. Magazines enticed consumers with photographs and descriptions of beautifully decorated homes, leading to an increase in advertising exposure for British citizens. Indeed, it is the language of house and garden magazines and advertisements that Mick uses when he describes his vision for the future of The Caretaker's dilapidated setting to Davies.

In the 1950s, mental health care was evolving with the advent of new psychiatric medications, enabling patients to leave institutions and reintegrate into their communities. Despite this progress, many individuals remained institutionalized. Although mental hospitals were more humane than in previous eras, they often served as mere holding facilities for those whose illnesses lacked effective treatments. Additionally, even with advancements in medication, the biological causes of severe mental illnesses were poorly understood. These conditions were still largely attributed to psychological factors. Psychiatrists frequently held the family unit responsible for disorders like schizophrenia and manic-depressive disorder, with mothers often being blamed for their children's upbringing.

As early as the sixteenth century, doctors attempted to treat schizophrenia by inducing convulsions with camphor. By the 1930s, modern electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) had been developed in Rome. In the 1950s, ECT was a common treatment for depression and schizophrenia. However, treatments were often administered without muscle relaxants to prevent fractures during seizures or general anesthesia. Furthermore, the mentally ill had not yet gained the protections from the patients' rights movement of the 1960s, making involuntary ECT, like the kind Aston experienced, much more prevalent than it is today.

Style and Technique

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Setting

The Caretaker is set in a single, dreary room cluttered with various items. The space is filled with paint buckets, a lawn-mower, suitcases, a rolled-up carpet, a stack of old newspapers, and a Buddha statue on top of...

(This entire section contains 825 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

a broken gas stove. A bucket hangs from the ceiling to catch water from a leaking roof. The room is so packed with junk that it resembles a storage area more than a living space. Metaphorically, the room not only houses useless objects but also represents people like Aston, who can no longer function in the outside world, and briefly Davies, who becomes another discarded item Aston has brought into the room.

With its clutter, leaky roof, and a window covered by a sack instead of curtains, the room starkly contrasts the idealized spaces featured in home and garden magazines, which are parodied in Mick's speech in Act III. In this speech, Mick details his fanciful plans for the room: "This room you could have as the kitchen ... I'd have teal-blue, copper and parchment linoleum squares ... venetian blinds on the window, cork floor, cork tiles." This exaggerated vision is both humorous and highlights the gap between the room's reality and the fantasies of Mick, Aston, and Davies. Despite the dreams discussed in the play, the room remains a stark reminder of the harsh reality.

Comedy

Historically, a comedy was a play with a "happy ending," where the protagonist's issues are resolved, the virtuous are rewarded, and the wicked are punished. Modern drama, however, has evolved to include tragicomedy, a blend of tragedy and comedy, featuring humorous elements with darker undertones. The Caretaker exemplifies this genre.

In The Caretaker, Pinter employs numerous comedic techniques. The character Davies is reminiscent of the vaudeville tramp/clown, a persona also used by Charlie Chaplin. Like a vaudeville sketch, Davies engages in a lot of physical, slapstick humor. For example, when Davies removes his trousers to go to bed, Mick takes them and teases him by flicking them in his face, echoing vaudeville scenes where a man loses his dignity when his pants fall down. Mick also takes Davies's backpack, tossing it around the room as Davies tries to retrieve it. Later, when Davies flees Mick's vacuum cleaner, his panic further aligns him with the classic tramp/clown character.

Besides the physical humor in the play, there's also a significant amount of verbal comedy. In Davies's dialogue, the gap between reality and his words often results in a comedic effect. For instance, he tells Aston, "I've had dinner with the best," and "I've eaten my dinner off the best of plates." This highly questionable claim from the tramp is amusing, as is Davies's story about his time at a monastery near Luton. In this tale, Davies says to a monk, "I heard you got a stock of shoes here," only for the monk to reply, "Piss off.... If you don't piss off... I'll kick you all the way to the gate." The humor arises from the unexpected nature of the monk's response and the contrast between his crude language, "Piss off," and his typically reserved and pious role.
Mick's questioning of Davies, with his rapid-fire inquiries and assertion that Davies posed as a professional interior decorator, is also comedic. This humor stems from the contrast between the tramp Davies and the professional image Mick describes.

While The Caretaker contains many comedic elements, it also has a darker side. The conclusion, in which Davies is left as a frightened old man with nowhere to go, evokes pity for his predicament. In the final scene, Davies is too pitiable to be funny; he almost becomes a tragic figure. The tragedy of his situation is made even more profound by the preceding comedy.

Symbolism

In literature, a symbol represents something beyond itself. Arguably, the most significant symbol in The Caretaker is the Buddha sitting atop the gas stove. This Buddha is an item Aston has picked up and brought into the already cluttered room. In this way, the Buddha mirrors Davies, who can also be seen as something useless that Aston has taken in. Therefore, the Buddha could symbolize Davies.

However, it's important to note that symbols do not always have a direct one-to-one correlation with what they represent. A complex symbol can have multiple possible meanings, which together create a greater whole. Mick's destruction of the Buddha in the third act, for instance, could be interpreted in several ways. Whether the Buddha symbolizes Davies, represents Aston's inner peace, or is just another item Aston has collected, Mick might destroy it because it represents his brother, whom he might detest. The Buddha, as another piece of junk in a house owned by Mick, could also symbolize Mick's life. In this case, Mick might destroy the Buddha out of frustration with his overall life. The Buddha could embody all these interpretations or something entirely different. Sometimes, the power of a symbol lies in its ambiguity.

Compare and Contrast

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

1960: Numerous government initiatives aimed at aiding the poor have been established, but doubts about their effectiveness start to emerge.

Today: While government programs continue to assist millions, skepticism grows regarding the government's ability to provide genuine solutions to poverty. There is an increasing focus on private sector involvement and a renewed emphasis on volunteer efforts.

1960: The domestic economy is bouncing back from its post-war slump, and the "consumer culture" is on the rise. Television becomes widespread, exposing people to more advertising than ever before.

Today: The focus on consumerism remains strong as corporate influence expands and advertising becomes even more omnipresent and convincing.

1960: New medications begin to transform the treatment of mental illness, yet psychologists and psychiatrists often attribute severe conditions like schizophrenia and manic-depression to psychological causes.

Today: Scientific research has uncovered a biological basis for major psychiatric disorders, but the mentally ill and their families still face discrimination due to the persistent social stigma surrounding mental illness.

1960: Immigrants and minority group members encounter significant challenges, widespread prejudice, and minimal legal protection.

Today: Minority groups are now legally protected, and racism is largely deemed socially unacceptable. However, the emergence of militant right-wing groups and hate organizations poses new threats to immigrants and people of color.

Setting

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The entirety of the play unfolds within a single, cramped room in a dilapidated flat on the west side of London, evoking the stark realities of urban decay in areas such as Shepherd’s Bush, Camden Town, and Finsbury Park. The setting is contemporaneous with the play’s time of writing, adding a layer of immediacy and authenticity to the narrative. The room's disrepair is not just a backdrop but a character in its own right, influencing and shaping the events that unfold. A bucket sits ominously in the room, its sole purpose to catch rainwater that routinely drips through the leaking roof. Basic amenities are absent; there is no provision for washing or cooking, and the chill of the unheated room is palpable. A grimy window, partially obscured by a sack, allows a draft and the relentless London rain to seep through.

Aston’s bed is the only one visible, while Davies’ sleeping area is obscured by an eclectic and surreal assortment of everyday items that clutter the space. This chaotic ensemble includes a kitchen sink—a nod to the "kitchen-sink" realism of British theater at the time—a stepladder, a coal bucket, a lawn mower, a shopping trolley, boxes, and drawers from a sideboard. Only when these items are cleared can Davies hope to rest. Near the bed stands a disconnected gas stove, yet its mere presence fuels Davies’ anxiety over potential fire hazards.

The disorder extends throughout the room, where a cupboard hides various belongings, including a clothes horse that serves as a makeshift hanger for Davies’ trousers at night. Piles of newspapers and boxes contribute to the clutter, while Aston, throughout the play, attempts to repair an electric toaster, adding to the sense of stagnation and futility. Beyond the confines of the room, other spaces within the brothers' domain are suggested, purportedly in even worse condition. The window offers a view of an overgrown garden, which Aston dreams of transforming by clearing it and constructing a shed, although it seems unlikely his ambitions will ever materialize.

Adaptations

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The Caretaker was turned into a film in 1964. This British production features Alan Bates as Mick, Donald Pleasance as Davies, and Robert Shaw as Aston. Michael Birkett produced the film, which was also released under the title The Guest.

In 1966, a made-for-television adaptation was created and broadcast on the BBC. Directed by Clive Donner, this version starred Ian MacShane as Mick, John Rees as Aston, and Roy Dotrice as Davies.

Bibliography

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

SOURCES

Page, Malcolm, compiler. File on Pinter, Methuen Drama, 1993, pp. 23-25.

Sakellaridou, Elizabeth. Pinter's Female Portraits: A Study of Female Characters in the Plays of Harold Pinter, Macmillan, 1988, pp. 127-29.

FURTHER READING

Billington, Michael. The Life and Work of Harold Pinter, Faber, 1996.
This is the first authorized biography of Pinter. Billington draws on insights from interviews with Pinter and his acquaintances to shed light on the playwright's life and career.

Briggs, Asa. A Social History of England: From the Ice Age to the Channel Tunnel, Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1994.
This book offers a detailed exploration of British social history, with significant focus on Postwar Britain.

Diamond, Elin. Pinter's Comic Play, Associated UP, 1985.
Diamond examines the role of comedy in Pinter's major works, including a dedicated chapter on The Caretaker.

Dukore, Bernard F. Harold Pinter, Grove Press, 1982.
This is a concise introduction to Pinter's key plays.
Scott, Michael, editor. Harold Pinter: The Birthday Party, The Caretaker, The Homecoming, Macmillan, 1986.
This compilation features a collection of reviews and essays on the mentioned works.

Previous

Critical Essays

Next

Teaching Guide

Loading...