I cannot live with You—

by Emily Dickinson

Start Free Trial

Summary

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Emily Dickinson's poem captures the essence of impossible love through the intricate weave of life's inescapable tensions. The speaker grapples with the futility of a life shared with the beloved, for such a union would be overwhelming, akin to experiencing life in its fullest, yet most unattainable form. However, this concept of life is eternal, likened to the sanctity guarded by the church sexton, who holds the key to the divine abode.

The Impossibility of Union

Living with her beloved seems unachievable because it represents the entirety of life itself—rich, complex, and beyond reach. Life's essence, in this context, aligns with religious symbolism, where the church sexton tends to the sacred space of the Lord. Yet, human life, depicted through mundane objects like cups, lacks true spiritual substance; they are mere vessels discarded when flawed and replaced without ceremony.

Death’s Unyielding Barrier

Death offers no respite for the speaker either, as the presence of "the Other"—a divine observer—takes precedence. This metaphysical presence claims authority over life and death, leaving no room for personal pacts. The notion of witnessing the beloved's death is equally unbearable, as it would render the speaker's devotion futile, the beloved becoming a solitary martyr in death's cold embrace.

Resurrection and Divine Judgment

Even the hope of resurrection together is fraught with divine disapproval. Such an event would provoke the anger of Jesus, obscuring the vision of salvation that the faithful strive to see. Dickinson intelligently integrates the phases of Christian life—life, death, judgment, and resurrection—into this contemplation, where the longing for divine grace clashes with earthly love.

Judgment and Separation

In the face of judgment, the beloved’s gaze upon the "homesick Eye" would promise a grace that the speaker can only perceive as alien, as it seeks a higher spiritual plane. Religious judgment would deem the speaker's devotion inadequate, highlighting a divide between earthly love and heavenly aspirations. Even if the beloved finds forgiveness, the speaker remains tethered to earthly despair, unable to look toward paradise without condemnation.

Despair: The Sole Connection

Their only remaining bond is "Despair," a bittersweet communion that unites them through shared suffering. This despair becomes their dialogue, bridging the gap between the mundane and the divine, echoing through their mutual longing and unfulfilled promises. In their unspoken prayer, they find a connection that transcends earthly and heavenly boundaries, offering a meager solace in their divided existence.

Thus, Dickinson's poem masterfully navigates the complex interplay between love, life, and the divine, illustrating the poignant struggle of a soul torn between earthly affection and spiritual aspiration. Each stanza delves deeper into this existential quandary, revealing the profound layers of yearning and resignation that define human experience.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Next

Themes

Loading...