Last Updated on August 7, 2019, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 557
In the book Camera Lucida, author Roland Barthes attempts to deconstruct photography and analyzes it so that we are presented with an untrained photographer's thoughts on the subject. Among other things, we read about photography with respect to its constituent actions, the elusive energy of certain photographs, and the mindset of the subject of an image.
I am looking at eyes that looked at the Emperor.
The author says this in the first chapter, reminiscing about the thoughts in his mind when he saw a photograph of Emperor Napoleon's younger brother.
Get back to Photography. What you are seeing here and what makes you suffer belongs to the category 'Amateur Photographs: dealt with by a team of sociologists; nothing but the trace of a social protocol of integration, intended to reassert the Family, etc.
This is the voice of knowledge, or "Scientia," as the author calls it, admonishing him to approach photography with a more cultured and critical eye, instead of loving a photograph because of its evident appeal. For Barthes, this is yet another illustration of what he has always struggled with—reconciliation of the expressive and the critical.
Newspaper photographs can very well 'say nothing to me.' In other words, I look at them without assuming a posture of existence. Though the persons whose photograph I see are certainly present in the photograph, they are so without existential posture, like the Knight and Death present in Durer's engraving, but without my positing them. Moreover, cases occur where the photograph leaves me so indifferent that I do not even bother to see it as an image: The photograph is vaguely constituted as an object, and the persons who figure there are certainly constituted as persons, but only because of their resemblance to human beings, without any special intentionality. They drift between the shores of perception, between sign and image, without ever approaching either.
The author quotes Sartre to try and explain why he instinctively liked some photographs, such as "The Horse-Car Terminal" by Stieglitz, and detested others, such as Pierre Boucher's "Nudes." The example of...
(The entire section contains 557 words.)
Unlock This Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this Camera Lucida study guide. You'll get access to all of the Camera Lucida content, as well as access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.
- Critical Essays