Exploring Materialism

1. Miss Emily and Kevin stand as contrasting figures in their approach to materialism. Delve into their philosophies regarding wealth. How does Brieanna perceive their differing attitudes toward money? Does the narrative sway you towards adopting a particular lifestyle? Consider whether these approaches might harmoniously coexist.

Gender Dynamics

2. Are there underlying presumptions about gender roles within this novel? Reflect on Brieanna's feelings towards the men and women she interacts with. What underpins her sentiments? Analyze how societal positions and economic status shape her perceptions.

Identity and Religion in Literature

3. Numerous novels for young readers address the quest for identity and incorporate themes of religion. Among these are Robert Cormier's The Chocolate Wars, Katherine Paterson's Bridge to Terabithia and Jacob Have I Loved, as well as Judy Blume's Are You There God, It's Me, Margaret. Draw a comparison between one of these works and But in the Fall I'm Leaving.

Family Dynamics and Comparison

4. Promises Are for Keeping, penned by Rinaldi three years before But in the Fall I'm Leaving, also explores a young girl's estrangement from her family. In this earlier work, Nicki endures the loss of both parents. Contrast these two narratives. Consider aspects such as: 1) the role of male figures in relation to the central female character, 2) the treatment of social issues within each text (e.g., pregnancy, vandalism) or unique to one text (e.g., drug use), 3) the theme of rebellious youth challenging adult authority, and 4) moral lessons imparted through the characters.

Moral Reflections

5. What ethical principles do you discern within But in the Fall I'm Leaving? Discuss how specific scenes and the narrative voice shape your interpretations of these values.

Character Evolution

6. By the conclusion of But in the Fall I'm Leaving, how do you feel about Mr. McQuade? Have your opinions of Brieanna shifted? Examine particular scenes or descriptions that swayed your emotions and track the evolution of your sentiments as the story unfolds.