Editor's Choice
Why was building the fire under the spruce tree a mistake in "To Build a Fire"?
Quick answer:
Building the fire under the spruce tree was a mistake because the tree was covered with snow. As the protagonist gathered twigs, the tree shook, causing snow to fall and extinguish the fire. This critical error left him unable to relight the fire due to his freezing fingers, marking a turning point where his survival was jeopardized. While trees can sometimes provide shelter, in this case, the snow-laden branches were disastrous.
The protagonist makes a mistake by building a fire under a spruce tree
because it is completely covered with snow. The man has already had his hands
out of his mittens and his fingers have gone numb. He can barely pull the twigs
off of the spruce tree to strengthen his fire, but when he does, the spruce
shakes and drops piles of snow onto his fire, burying it.
This could be called the definitive turning point of the story. It is at this
point that the protagonist begins to panic upon realizing his life is in very
real and present danger. His inability to grip the matches with his freezing
fingers proves that by attempting to build his fire under the spruce tree, he
did indeed botch his last chance at survival.
Strangely, there are times where it would be a really good idea to build a fire under a tree. If you are trying to escape detection and want something to try and dissipate the smoke and prevent people from far away finding your fire, it can be a good idea. It can also act as a shelter from rain if you are lighting a fire in the rain.
The problem is that the main character in the story is lighting a fire under a spruce tree that is absolutely drenched and hanging with snow. When some of it melts, you are creating rain or even bringing down a lot of snow onto your fire, in this case leading to the man's death.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.