Analysis
Bruce Chatwin’s novels collectively examine the theme of humanity’s fall from an idyllic state of nomadic existence into the more corrupted state of settled life. Central to his work is the myth of Cain and Abel, with Abel representing nomadic innocence and Cain symbolizing the first settler. Through his novels, Chatwin explores the inherent restlessness of human nature and the consequences of abandoning a mobile lifestyle.
The Sins of Settlement
Bruce Chatwin’s literary exploration of the human condition frequently returns to the concept of humanity’s fall from grace through the act of settlement. In his novels, Chatwin employs the myth of Cain and Abel to symbolize this transformation. Abel is portrayed as the wandering shepherd, an archetype of nomadic purity, whereas Cain embodies the first settler, symbolizing the inception of human corruption through the establishment of the first city.
Chatwin extends this mythic fall into the realm of modern civilization, portraying through his works how humanity has lost its intrinsic state of restlessness. This theme is recurrent across his novels, where characters often grapple with the consequences of their departure from a nomadic existence—a transition Chatwin refers to as “the sins of settlement.” His novels probe into the psychological and societal implications of settlement, painting a picture of human restlessness and its impact on modern life.
The Viceroy of Ouidah
In "The Viceroy of Ouidah," Chatwin fictionalizes the life of Francisco Felix de Souza, a notorious Brazilian slave trader. Initially intended as a scholarly biography, the project transformed into a novel following Chatwin’s unsettling encounters with the Marxist military government of Benin, formerly Dahomey. The narrative follows Francisco Manoel da Silva, Chatwin’s fictional counterpart to de Souza, highlighting his ruthless pursuit of wealth and power through the slave trade in Dahomey.
Da Silva becomes a symbol of European exploitation, his wealth amassed through the corruption and oppression of African societies. In Chatwin’s narrative, the fall of da Silva from power and wealth into poverty and destitution mirrors the broader theme of cultural edenic destruction—where one society’s paradise is built upon the ruins of another. This novel explores the destructive impact of European Christian culture on African animist societies, further illustrating the moral decay associated with the settlement and exploitation of other cultures.
On the Black Hill
Contrasting the exotic backdrop of "The Viceroy of Ouidah," Chatwin’s "On the Black Hill" focuses on stasis rather than movement. The novel tells the story of twin brothers, Benjamin and Lewis, who spend their entire lives on their family farm, The Vision, located on the border between western England and eastern Wales. Here, Chatwin crafts a narrative that spans the twins' entire lives, exploring themes of isolation and the impact of external societal pressures on their pastoral existence.
The Vision is depicted as an edenic space, protected from external influences of capitalism and sexual corruption. The twins’ lives are marked by a profound interconnectedness, living in a world largely untouched by the chaos of the outside. Their forays into the wider world bring ridicule and abuse, reinforcing Chatwin’s theme of the inherent conflict between the innocence of rural life and the corrupting influence of urban society.
The Songlines
"The Songlines" is one of Chatwin’s most analyzed works, blending elements of travelogue and novel to explore the Aboriginal culture of Australia. Chatwin undertakes a journey through the outback, guided by his interest in understanding the Aboriginal concept of songlines—ancient paths that serve as both spiritual and geographical guides for the Indigenous peoples. These songlines represent a formative element of Aboriginal culture, where the land is brought into existence through the power of song.
In "The...
(This entire section contains 1063 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
Songlines," Chatwin delves into the philosophical implications of a nomadic lifestyle versus settled existence. The book reflects on the consequences of Aboriginal displacement and the resulting social issues, such as depression and alcoholism. Through his exploration, Chatwin theorizes about the original innocence of pastoral nomads and the broader implications of humanity’s shift into a sedentary, time-bound existence.
The narrative also features a series of philosophical musings drawn from Chatwin’s notebooks, interspersed with quotes from literary and philosophical giants, enhancing the book’s exploration of human restlessness and cultural dislocation. Despite falling ill during the writing process, Chatwin’s work in "The Songlines" remains a profound synthesis of narrative and philosophical reflection.
Utz
"Utz," Chatwin’s final novel, intertwines mystery with cultural exploration, as the story revolves around the enigmatic figure of Kaspar Utz, a collector in Communist Czechoslovakia. This novel draws from Chatwin’s research into obsessive collectors and the dynamics of art preservation under oppressive regimes. Utz’s vast collection of Meissen figurines and its mysterious disappearance under the watchful eye of Communist overseers form the central puzzle of the narrative.
The novel presents a stark contrast between Communist bureaucracy and capitalist greed, with the protagonist’s life and collection serving as metaphors for the transient nature of human endeavors. "Utz" also underscores a poignant realization that art outlasts human lives, a theme made especially resonant by Chatwin’s own declining health during the novel’s completion.
In Patagonia
"In Patagonia," Chatwin’s debut work, defies easy categorization, melding travel writing with literary narrative. The book chronicles Chatwin’s journey to Patagonia in search of a family relic, while uncovering deeper insights into the region’s cultural and historical legacy. Through anecdotes and historical accounts, Chatwin constructs a vivid portrait of Patagonia, rich in its diversity and marked by the imprints of Western influence.
Chatwin’s journey to Patagonia becomes a metaphysical exploration as much as a physical one. He reflects on the cultural erosion caused by colonial influences and the loss of Edenic innocence among the native populations. The narrative becomes a meditation on the human tendency towards settlement, contrasting the free-spirited existence of nomadic cultures with the restrictive nature of settled societies. Chatwin’s work in "In Patagonia" reflects his fascination with the interplay of human history and geography, where the landscape itself becomes a character in the unfolding story.
"In Patagonia" serves as a testament to Chatwin’s literary prowess, his ability to blend diverse methods of inquiry, from personal narrative to anthropological investigation, into a cohesive and thought-provoking exploration of the human condition. His works consistently challenge readers to reassess their understanding of cultural identity and the inherent restlessness that defines humanity.
