Immigration and Assimilation
Throughout the story, Sophie and Martine travel between Haiti and the United States, encountering significant differences in culture and surroundings. Both women recognize the difficulties of adapting to life in a new country. They learn English, which Grandma Ife dismissively refers to as "that cling-clang talk," and Sophie describes it as sounding "like rocks falling in a stream." Despite this, they continue to speak their native Creole. They eat American food to avoid the painful memories linked to Haitian dishes, yet they still yearn for traditional meals made with ingredients like cassava, ginger, beans, rice, and spices. Sophie dislikes her French school, feeling it resembles being in Haiti, and she also endures teasing from American classmates for her Haitian background. Her challenges with assimilation also extend to her views on gender roles. She holds traditional beliefs about women being modest and protected but criticizes traditional Haitian men for expecting women to remain at home and prepare Haitian meals.
As time passes, Sophie becomes more accustomed to American culture. When she returns to Haiti, a cab driver is surprised by her fluent Creole. Similarly, when Martine arrives, they instinctively switch to speaking English with each other.
Generational Bonds and Conflicts
‘‘The love between a mother and daughter is deeper than the sea,’’ Martine tells Sophie. The complex relationships and conflicts between mothers and daughters are a central theme in the book. Grandma Ife, the family matriarch, adhered to the traditional Haitian custom of ensuring her daughters' chastity by "testing" them each month to confirm their hymens were intact. This practice left deep emotional scars, particularly for Martine, whose trauma was exacerbated by a violent rape at the age of sixteen. Despite her own suffering, Martine subjects her daughter Sophie to the same painful ritual, continuing a cycle of sexual fear and nightmares.
When Sophie finally confronts her mother about this, Martine admits she has no valid reason, saying she did it simply because it was done to her. Interestingly, although Grandma Ife likely endured the same practice, she appears untroubled by it, possibly due to her acceptance of a traditional lifestyle unlike her daughters and Sophie. Sophie eventually understands there is a way to break this cycle of pain. She manages to overcome the terror linked to her mother's rapist and vows never to subject her own daughter to such testing or pass on the associated nightmares and eating disorders.
Determined to forge her own path, she reflects on her family's emotional suffering, saying, ''It was up to me to avoid my turn in the fire. It was up to me to make sure that my daughter never slept with ghosts, never lived with nightmares.’’
Emotional Pain and Liberation
Throughout the book, female characters wrestle with emotional pain that impedes their ability to fully engage with life. Despite this, they strive for and sometimes achieve freedom. At the beginning of the story, Tante Atie feels trapped by illiteracy and a lack of love. However, years later, a friend, who is also likely her lover, teaches her to read. She begins carrying a notebook to jot down poems and thoughts, even penning a poem of her own. Martine also seeks freedom from her emotional distress but struggles to find a positive path forward. For a period, her life seems to improve; she is in a relationship with Marc, a kind man, and earns enough to send money back to Haiti each month. However, Sophie's arrival disturbs her because Sophie resembles her father, who was Martine's rapist. Martine is also distressed by Sophie's growing up and her relationship with a man. When Martine becomes pregnant, it brings back painful memories of...
(This entire section contains 244 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
her rape, her pregnancy with Sophie, and her mother's sexual tests. Unable to escape her emotional torment, Martine ultimately ends her own life.
Sophie inherits her mother's fears, sexual guilt, and nightmares. Nevertheless, by joining a therapy group, she overcomes these issues by the end of the book and ensures her daughter does not inherit them. Sophie also realizes that her mother, despite her suicide and the difficulties she caused Sophie, was a strong and capable woman who was simply overwhelmed by her circumstances.
Reconciliation of Past and Present
The challenge of reconciling two distinct realities is a central theme in Breath, Eyes, Memory. Each character strives to retain aspects of their past while trying to forget traumatic memories. This struggle even affects Joseph, who holds onto American slave spirituals in his music career. For him, these songs, rooted in a history of slavery, celebrate present-day freedom. For Sophie and Martine, merging the past and present is significantly more difficult and turbulent. Their world is divided into two parts—the Haitian past and the American present. Time and place are intricately linked; for instance, Martine can only spend a few days in Haiti because the location vividly brings back her past. Danticat suggests that the inseparability of the present from the past has both positive and negative outcomes. The positive aspect of Sophie's Haitian heritage lies in the strength of character, physical resilience, and cultural traditions it offers. Her childhood experiences of deprivation taught her sacrifice, made her physically strong, and introduced her to legends and foods she still enjoys in America. Conversely, the past also casts a shadow in Martine's harsh treatment of her daughter and her relentless nightmares, which make sleep nearly impossible decades after her rape. By exploring this theme, Danticat aligns herself with renowned American authors like William Faulkner and Toni Morrison, who also explore the interconnectedness of time and place. Although Danticat’s work is not as experimental as these authors, it shares thematic similarities.
Pursuit of the American Dream
One of the key themes in Breath, Eyes, Memory is the quest for the American Dream. Martine envisions Sophie achieving the classic rags-to-riches story made famous by Horatio Alger. Danticat questions the American notion of upward mobility when Sophie finds happiness as a secretary, instead of pursuing the medical career her mother had hoped for. For Sophie, love and emotional fulfillment are more important than achieving material wealth. Joseph also challenges the traditional American work ethic. Despite his extensive education, he opts to play jazz, motivated by his passion rather than the need for financial gain.
Strength of Family Ties
Through symbolic blood imagery, Danticat underscores the power of family connections. Even as Sophie tries to distance herself from her mother, the blood symbolism highlights the futility of her attempts. By the end of the novel, Sophie understands this when she identifies the source of her family's happiness and sorrow, realizing she cannot embrace one while erasing the other. She accepts that both the positive and negative aspects within her originate from her family, from her blood. Martine's tragedy is her inability to acknowledge this reality. Her desperate wish to eliminate the rapist's tainted blood blinds her to the fact that it also runs through her daughter's veins. She cannot reconcile the unresolved paradox at the core of her daughter's existence: that from her most detested memory came her most cherished gift.
Mothers and Daughters
Breath, Eyes, Memory gracefully navigates the intricate tapestry of human suffering and societal challenges, blending them into a narrative rich with lyrical beauty and profound insights into the resilience of its characters. The novel, while vividly portraying the political turmoil and deprivation of Haiti alongside the complexities of racism, prejudice, and identity in America, is deeply anchored in the lives of the four central women. This intergenerational exploration is encapsulated in the theme of mothers and daughters, a thread seamlessly woven through all four parts of the novel.
Sophie, the protagonist, encapsulates this theme as she navigates her identity, referring to herself as both "my mother’s daughter and Tante Atie’s child." Her journey to understanding her familial roots and the shared histories among the women in her life serves as a powerful narrative force. Through her experiences, readers gain insight into the delicate dynamics and enduring bonds that define these relationships. The novel's strength lies in its portrayal of how these women confront and transcend their hardships, embodying courage and fortitude in the face of adversity. The slow unraveling of Sophie's family history not only enhances the emotional depth of the story but also highlights the universal complexities of maternal ties.
Male Dominance and Repression
In the narrative landscape woven by the women in "Breath, Eyes, Memory," lives are orchestrated by the imposing presence of male authority. These women, both pivotal and peripheral, navigate a world frequently dictated and sometimes intruded upon by men. From the traumatic shadow of Martine's rapist to the looming presence of soldiers in Haiti, and even to the more personal realms of husbands, lovers, and heartbreakers, their experiences revolve around the axis of male influence. While the novel does not neglect the existence of positive male figures, it places a strong emphasis on the pervasive impact of repression, stereotypes, and entrenched traditions.
A poignant example of this male-dominated framework is the manifestation of sexual control, as seen through the culturally ingrained ritual of testing a girl’s purity. This societal fixation on female chastity compels mothers to subject their daughters to a humiliating "test," a practice perpetuated through generations. The protagonist Sophie uncovers that her mother, Martine, felt obligated to follow this tradition because her own mother, Grandma Ife, had done the same. This cycle of compliance highlights how deeply these traditions are rooted, passed down through the lineage like an inherited burden that shapes the lives of women under the guise of preserving virtue.
Strength and Endurance
While Edwidge Danticat’s novel is imbued with palpable pain, it is equally defined by its vibrant power and poetic grace. Her narrative does not shy away from portraying the negative traditions and challenges faced by her characters, yet it simultaneously celebrates their strength and resilience. This duality is personified in Sophie, who ultimately recognizes the courage and gifts embedded in her heritage. She comes to appreciate that her mother was "brave as the stars at dawn," acknowledging the multifaceted nature of their lives. Amidst the whirlwind of political, sexual, societal, and generational upheavals, a pivotal question emerges: Can Sophie transcend her struggles to embrace the complexity, sacrifice, and inherent duality of the relationships that are central to her existence?
Haitian Folklore and Legend
The novel Breath, Eyes, Memory intricately weaves Haitian folklore and legend into its tapestry, highlighting the profound themes rooted in Haiti’s cultural heritage. Through its narrative, the book pays homage to the indomitable spirit of Haitian women and critiques the violent chapters of the nation's history. A recurring motif is the name "Caco," emblematic of the valiant fighters who stood against the American occupation of Haiti, symbolizing resistance and resilience.
In the novel, women are frequently linked to a powerful Haitian creation myth. This story speaks of individuals chosen to bear the burden of the sky upon their heads, symbolizing their unique strength to endure and navigate through adversity. Such imagery is not merely mythological but serves as a metaphor for the struggles and tenacity of the women depicted in the story.
Central to this thematic exploration is the veneration of Erzulie, the goddess who embodies a complex duality. This figure is revered by Haitian women and encapsulates both Christian and pagan aspects, as well as the roles of virgin and temptress. Through Erzulie, the novel reflects on the conflicting and often destructive messages women receive, highlighting the societal pressures they navigate. Her presence in the narrative underscores the mixed cultural and religious influences that shape the identities and fates of the female characters.
The Myth of the Marassas
Within the narrative, the Haitian myth of the Marassas plays a significant role, symbolizing the deep and complex connections between individuals. The Marassas, often depicted as twins with extraordinary powers, embody themes of unity and duality. This myth is particularly poignant in the relationship between Martine and her daughter Sophie. During a moment of profound tension, as Martine tests Sophie's virginity, she recounts the tale of the Marassas, emphasizing their bond as inseparable lovers, more intimate than even their own shadows. Martine expresses a desire for an equally profound connection with Sophie.
However, the very act of testing—rooted in distrust and violation—undermines the possibility of such closeness between mother and daughter. The myth's ideal of unity is further explored in the relationship between Tante Atie and Louise, who approach the Marassas ideal in their own way, though their bond is ultimately fleeting. Through these narratives, the author suggests that the essence of the Marassas myth might transcend the search for a soulmate. Instead, it reflects the internal struggle to harmonize conflicting aspects within oneself, illustrating the duality that every individual must grapple with in their quest for self-understanding.
Imagery and Metaphor
The novel brims with cultural depth, using vivid imagery and metaphor to enliven the narrative. Prominent among these is the symbolic use of color. The initial chapters are infused with shades of yellow, a hue that resonates deeply with Sophie’s affection for yellow flowers, especially daffodils. These flowers, much like Sophie and her mother, embody resilience as they adapt to foreign surroundings. Upon relocating to a new neighborhood, Sophie and her mother opt for red, a color rich in symbolism and passion, to adorn their environment. This theme culminates in Sophie’s choice of a crimson suit for her mother’s burial, an audacious nod to her mother’s vibrant spirit. Sophie commemorates her mother as the "hot-blooded Erzulie" and the majestic scarlet bird, "Caco," preserving her legacy through these powerful symbols.