Breakfast at Tiffany's Analysis
- Holly's cat symbolizes freedom and Holly's resistance to captivity. Holly takes the stray in, but never gives it a name, refusing to accept the responsibility of ownership or the status of being an owner.
- Holly easily accepts the narrator's sexual orientation, reflecting both Capote's own homosexuality and the changing social attitude towards sexuality in general.
- The novel is narrated from the first-person perspective as a writer reminisces about his friendship with Holly Golightly. This perspective allows the reader to see Holly as the enigmatic and eccentric individual the narrator saw her as, but it also more subtly characterizes the narrator himself.
Analysis
"Breakfast at Tiffany's," Truman Capote's beloved novella, masterfully employs the frame narrative, allowing a tale of nostalgia and complexity to unfold. At its heart lies the enigmatic Holly Golightly, an eccentric socialite whose free spirit captivates the narrator, a struggling writer. This exploration not only delves into Holly's character but also uncovers broader themes of identity and perception, leaving readers pondering the fluidity of reality itself.
Unraveling the Frame Narrative
Capote's "Breakfast at Tiffany's" is structured as a frame narrative, where the main story is recounted through the reflective lens of a narrator years after the events have transpired. This narrative style casts an intriguing shadow over Holly Golightly, who remains an alluring yet inscrutable figure throughout. The narrator, a writer grappling with his own aspirations, becomes the focal point, drawing readers into his personal odyssey as he recalls his fascination with Holly.
The film adaptation of the novella, starring Audrey Hepburn, further entrenched Holly Golightly as the centerpiece of the story, solidifying her image as a glamorous free spirit. Her character challenged societal norms with her candid approach to sexuality and independence, a trait often celebrated in American literature. Yet, unlike her literary predecessors, Holly's character defied simple categorization, making her a complex symbol of liberation and contradiction.
The Paradox of Holly Golightly
Holly Golightly embodies a paradoxical blend of traits: narcissism paired with compassion, willfulness juxtaposed with vulnerability. Her interactions with people and even her pet cat, whom she refuses to name, reflect an ambivalent sense of responsibility, underscoring her resistance to conventional constraints. A poignant example of this thematic tension occurs during the Christmas gift exchange between Holly and the narrator. He presents her with a medal of St. Christopher, symbolizing protection for travelers, while she gifts him a birdcage with the stipulation to never confine anything living within it.
This theme of freedom versus captivity is woven throughout the novella, with Holly frequently associated with untamed creatures like horses and birds. Her disdain for zoos underscores her aversion to confinement, yet Capote crafts her character with nuance. Holly's attraction to the capitalist dream, her penchant for lavish living, and her comfort at Tiffany's demonstrate her internal struggle between yearning for a home and the allure of affluence.
Exploring Gender and Sexual Identity
While Holly Golightly is a captivating character, the novella's pioneering aspect lies in its exploration of gender and sexual identity. At a time when such themes were often overshadowed in literature, Capote bravely delves into the fluidity of identity. Holly herself, with her boyish appearance and ambiguous relationships, hints at a spectrum of sexuality, challenging the binary notions of gay or straight.
The narrator, whose platonic relationship with Holly raises questions about his own sexual identity, adds complexity to the narrative. His prose, delicate and evocative like Capote's early style, refrains from defining him strictly within conventional boundaries. Other characters, such as Rusty Trawler and Mag Wildwood, further blur the lines of clear sexual and gender identities, reinforcing the novella's central theme.
Capote's narrative suggests that gender and sexual identities are not merely predetermined or biologically fixed but are instead fluid constructions. Through symbols such as acting, fiction writing, and masks, the novella illustrates how individuals navigate a world of deception and self-discovery, marking its significance in the realm of gay studies.
The Fluidity of Reality
Capote's work shares a postmodern concern with the nature of reality, exploring the delicate line between truth and perception. The narrative structure itself—a tale within a tale—reflects this exploration, as Holly's story emerges from fragmented recollections and an unreliable narrator whose perspective shapes the tale. Readers are left...
(This entire section contains 748 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
to grapple with the distinction between reality and fiction, a theme Capote later revisited in his nonfiction work, "In Cold Blood."
Ultimately, "Breakfast at Tiffany's" challenges readers to question their understanding of the truth. Holly's character, described by her agent as a "real phony," epitomizes the paradox of reality. The narrative voice, seemingly straightforward and journalistic, forces readers to confront the limitations of memory and perception, as every recollection represents a subjective angle.
As the novella concludes, readers find themselves no closer to comprehending Holly's intricate emotional world or her various relationships. Much like the photo of the African carving resembling Holly, the narrative remains distant, thrice removed from its elusive subject. This deliberate ambiguity forms the crux of Capote's achievement, leaving readers with the unsettling realization that understanding does not always equate to clarity, and that proximity to the truth can often obscure it further.
Literary Techniques
In this novel, like many of Capote's works, symbols play a crucial role. The first notable symbol is the African statue in a photograph taken by I. Y. Yunioshi, Holly's former neighbor. This wooden sculpture, which merges the elongated head of a primitive style with Holly's facial features, signifies her role as the feminine ideal. This ideal appeals not only to civilized men like Joe Bell and the American photographer but also to primitive artists like the African woodcarver. Holly's ability to inspire art is further explored in this novel, which, for the narrator, is an attempt to understand her personality and her allure to nearly all types of men.
Another significant symbol is the ornate birdcage that the narrator admires and Holly purchases for him. While the narrator sees this cage as another piece of art, Holly views it as a symbol of lost freedom. Consequently, she cannot appreciate its inherent beauty. When the narrator angrily returns it to her, she dismisses both its artistic and monetary value by casually tossing it onto a trash heap. However, the narrator, whose values sharply contrast with hers, retrieves it.
The transient nature of Holly's life is evident in the way her apartment is furnished. She appears to be constantly in motion, with suitcases and unpacked crates serving as her only furniture. These crates double as tables for drinks, a lamp, a bowl of flowers, and her cat. Holly refuses to buy proper chairs and tables until she finds a place where she feels she belongs. Similarly, the cat remains unnamed because Holly is unwilling to take on even that minimal level of commitment to another living being.
Color symbolism is also prominent in Capote's novels. Holly is frequently associated with various colors, from the bowl of yellow roses in her apartment to her red cat and her white satin bed. However, she is primarily linked to the emotion she calls "the mean reds," her term for deep depression. This feeling can only be alleviated by having breakfast at Tiffany's. Her most intense bouts with "the mean reds" occur when she learns of her brother's death and again when she suffers a miscarriage. She confides in the narrator that during the latter event, she nearly died, or as she puts it, "the fat lady nearly got her."
Tiffany's itself is a significant symbol in the novel. For Holly, this store represents the stability, status, and taste she desires in her life. She spends hours outside the store, gazing in. Although she tells the narrator she has only bought calling cards there because she feels indebted to Tiffany's, these cards symbolize hope. This hope is further represented by the St. Christopher medal the narrator later buys for her from Tiffany's.
Ideas for Group Discussions
Modern readers might find Breakfast at Tiffany's somewhat outdated. The outlaws in the story resemble characters from the musical Guys and Dolls more than any present-day Mafia figures. Similarly, Holly Golightly's attitude seems to echo those of the 1950s beat writers and the 1960s flower children. The 1950s' more reserved approach to discussing sexual topics is also clearly evident. Overall, readers might consider the novel as a reflection of its cultural era.
1. One of the most ambiguous aspects of the novel is the narrator's relationship with Holly. Initially, she treats him like a surrogate brother, and in many ways, that dynamic persists throughout the story. However, Joe Bell hints that the narrator might have had sexual fantasies about her, and the narrator himself suggests that he wrote the novel to understand his feelings. How does he truly feel about Holly? How does his perspective influence the reader's view of her?
2. Capote was very dissatisfied with the film adaptation of Breakfast at Tiffany's. How does the novel differ from the movie? Why were these changes made in the film version?
3. Although much of the novel's action occurs during World War II, the war seems to have little impact on the events. How do wartime conditions influence the novel? Why did Capote choose not to emphasize the war?
4. The novel is essentially a retrospective narrative, framed by the narrator's more recent interactions with Holly and her friends. What effects does Capote achieve by using this narrative structure?
5. Breakfast at Tiffany's does not seem to be a typical Capote novel. In what ways does this novel differ from his earlier works? How can these differences be explained? In what ways is it similar to other Capote novels?
6. It has been reported that one of Capote's literary rivals accused him of borrowing elements from other writers and from the popular culture of the time. What are some elements that have parallels in other fiction? Are Holly and the narrator examples of the antiheroes, or at least unlikely heroes, that were emerging in the 1950s?
7. What does Tiffany's mean to the various characters—especially Holly and the narrator? What does Tiffany's represent in today's popular culture? How has that meaning evolved since the 1950s?
8. What is Holly's attitude toward money, possessions, and any form of permanence? Does the narrator continue to share her views? Why is it significant that near the end of the novel, the narrator reveals that the cat has finally found a home? Has the narrator also found a home? Does he believe Holly has? Is he likely to be correct?
9. While the novel often downplays and treats sexuality with some ambiguity, it is clear that Holly leaves a lasting impression on every man she encounters. Why is that the case? What does the narrator imply about the men who do not find themselves drawn to Holly? Conversely, why do most women appear to dislike her? Does their attitude reflect the stereotypes of women and their roles prevalent in the 1950s?
10. The novelist James Michener once mentioned that Holly Golightly was modeled after a young woman both he and Capote knew well. Without such a statement, would Holly still be a believable character? In what ways is her behavior realistic? Which traits seem exaggerated?
Literary Precedents
Holly Golightly seems to fit into the literary tradition of the picaro or the charming nonconformist who believes society's rules don't apply to her. Her natural innocence connects her to characters like Huckleberry Finn, who aren't exactly truthful but aren't genuinely dishonest either. Conversely, her openness about sexuality is reminiscent of Tom Jones (Henry Fielding, 1749).
The depiction of law enforcement and criminals is similar to that in the popular 1950s musical Guys and Dolls. Since Capote presents Sally Tomato and Father O'shaughnessy almost entirely through Holly's perspective, they come across as characters from Damon Runyon's stories or even the legendary tales of Robin Hood and Friar Tuck.
Adaptations
In 1961, Paramount Pictures released a popular film loosely based on Breakfast at Tiffany's. Though Capote reportedly envisioned Marilyn Monroe as Holly, Audrey Hepburn ultimately took on the role. The narrator, named Paul Varjak in the film, was portrayed by George Peppard. Other notable actors included Patricia Neal as the downstairs neighbor, Buddy Ebsen as Doc Golightly, Martin Balsam as O. J. Berman, Alan Reed as Sally Tomato, and Mickey Rooney as the Japanese photographer I. Y. Yunioshi. For more information, visit the following URL: http://us.imdb.com/.
Capote later voiced strong dissatisfaction with the casting choices, particularly Audrey Hepburn and Mickey Rooney. He was even more displeased with the director, Blake Edwards. A few years before his death, Capote mentioned he wished for a remake with Jodie Foster as Holly. Despite this, the film is perhaps best remembered for its iconic musical theme "Moon River" by Henry Mancini and Johnny Mercer, and it remains popular enough to have an entire website dedicated to it: Elizabeth's Breakfast at Tiffany's Website.