Themes: Individuality

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Individuality is a rarity in the universe of Brave New World. It is highly discouraged by the government and even by the citizens themselves. Anyone who is seen as “different” from the norm—like Bernard—is viewed with suspicion. Many of the citizens are spawned from the lower-class Bokanovsky Groups, which are sets of identical twins all from the same egg and lacking individuality due to their status as clones. What little remains of individuality is reserved for the upper-class Betas and Alphas, who are not cloned.

According to Mustapha Mond, this genetic homogeneity is essential for society to function peacefully. Mustapha claims in chapter 16 there would be chaos if there were too many independent people like Alphas in the world. This is because individuality breeds unique thoughts and behaviors, which can lead to the questioning of authority and of one’s place in the social and economic hierarchy.

In the novel, freedom and individuality go hand in hand. John, the only character who has truly experienced freedom and recognized it as such, is the most individual of all the characters. He is still shaped by his environment and upbringing but not as strongly as Bernard, Lenina, Linda, and other World State citizens. After being taken to the World State, John repeatedly fights against society to maintain his individuality. While doing so ensures his freedom and stops him from becoming complacent like the other characters, it is instrumental to his own undoing. His suicide is the result of his inability to reconcile his independence with the deeply controlled life of the World State citizens: he cannot fully be himself and refuses to become like everyone else, so he instead chooses to be neither and takes his own life.

Expert Q&A

How is Helmholtz Watson different from other Alphas in Brave New World?

Helmholtz Watson differs from other Alphas due to his exceptional intelligence and individuality. While physically an ideal Alpha, he is "a little too able," which leads him to question societal norms. Unlike Bernard Marx, whose difference stems from physical traits, Helmholtz's mental excess makes him dissatisfied with superficial pleasures and prompts him to seek deeper meaning. This intellectual curiosity ultimately results in his banishment to the Falklands, highlighting his divergence from a conformist society.

In Brave New World, how does John and Lenina's confrontation highlight their differences?

The confrontation between John and Lenina in Brave New World underscores their differing values and highlights key themes. John holds traditional views on love and courtship, valuing emotional connections and moral integrity, while Lenina embodies the New World's shallow, hedonistic approach to relationships. This clash reveals Lenina's inability to understand true emotions, while John's idealism is challenged by the superficiality around him. Their encounter emphasizes the novel's themes of dehumanization and the conflict between individuality and societal conformity.

In Huxley's Brave New World, how does the Cyprus Experiment highlight the importance of difference?

The Cyprus Experiment in Aldous Huxley's Brave New World demonstrates the importance of societal differences by showing the failure of a society composed entirely of Alphas. Without diverse roles, conflict arose as everyone sought high-status jobs, leading to civil war. Mustapha Mond argues that a stable society requires people content with their limited roles, even at the cost of personal fulfillment. In contrast, John the Savage values individual freedom and creativity over imposed stability.

Why doesn't the Principal publish Helmholtz's poem in Brave New World?

The Principal refuses to publish Helmholtz's poem because it contains ideas that contradict the values of the society in Brave New World, specifically the notion of solitude, which is considered dangerous. The society promotes constant social interaction to prevent individual thinking, which could threaten its stability. Helmholtz's poem, which he shares with his students, expresses a desire for solitude, leading to his reprimand by the Principal, who views such ideas as subversive.

In Brave New World, how do Bernard's dating habits differ from society's?

Bernard Marx's dating habits differ significantly from society's norms in Brave New World. In a culture where casual, non-committal relationships are the norm, Bernard desires deeper emotional connections and meaningful conversations. He is less popular due to his unattractive and anti-social nature, and he often feels ostracized. Unlike others, Bernard seeks solitude with women and values individual interactions, reflecting his struggle to fit into the society's superficial expectations.

In Brave New World, why is Bernard excited by the Savage's responses?

Bernard is excited by the Savage's responses because he sees an opportunity to protect himself from his boss, the Director, who wants to exile him. Bernard learns that John, the Savage, is the Director's biological son, a fact that could discredit the Director in the World State, where parenthood is considered disgraceful. By bringing John back to England, Bernard hopes to use this revelation to ensure his own safety and advance his status.

What is John the Savage's role in the novel and why might Huxley have educated him and brought him from the reservation to the New World?

John is the outsider who represents our moral views and actions. He is an innocent, but he is also a Christ-like figure. John was educated in an isolated reservation where he grew up with all of the memories of the old world. Thus, he is able to see through the superficiality and insanity of this nightmarish society that has been created. He is by far the most intelligent character in the novel, and he knows it. Even so, John retains his humility despite his great intelligence; he never thinks himself better than anyone else just because of his ability to reason and think logically.

How does John the Savage's knowledge of Shakespeare characterize him in Brave New World?

John the Savage's quotations from Shakespeare help situate him as a representative of an older world order that has been lost in the "brave new world" of the World State. From his quotations we learn that what he values and cherishes is a vision of society that directly clashes with the realities of the World State, especially with how its sexual mores have been conditioned.

Analysis of Bernard's and Lenina's personalities, desires, self-perceptions, and their relationship in Brave New World

In Brave New World, Bernard is insecure, critical of society, and desires individuality, while Lenina is conformist, pleasure-seeking, and conditioned by societal norms. Bernard struggles with self-esteem and craves recognition, whereas Lenina perceives herself through societal approval. Their relationship is strained, as Bernard's desire for deeper connections conflicts with Lenina's superficial attitudes towards relationships.

The relationship and contrasts between John the Savage and Bernard Marx in Brave New World

The relationship between John the Savage and Bernard Marx in Brave New World is complex and marked by contrasts. While John represents natural humanity and emotional depth, Bernard embodies the conditioned, conformist society. Initially, Bernard seeks validation through John, but their differing values and perspectives create tension and highlight the incompatibility between natural human instincts and a controlled, artificial society.

Show another question (5 questions hidden)

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: Consumption

Next

Themes: Technology and Control

Loading...