Critical Overview
Christine de Pizan, an Italian by birth who became known as the first professional female writer in France, faced adversity and triumph in equal measure. Her journey from a young widow to a celebrated author underscores her resilience and intellectual prowess. Her seminal work, The Book of the City of Ladies, serves not only as an allegory but also as a powerful defense of women against the pervasive misogyny of medieval literature.
Early Life and Motivation
Christine de Pizan was born in Italy and relocated to Paris when her father took a position as the court astrologer for King Charles V of France. Her marriage to Estienne de Castel, a French notary, ended prematurely with his untimely death, leaving Christine a widow at twenty-five with the responsibility of caring for her three children and her mother. Despite societal pressures and her mother's objections, Christine's father supported her educational pursuits, which became a lifeline in her quest for financial independence and intellectual fulfillment.
Left without a male provider, Christine turned to writing to sustain her family. Her early works, mostly poetry, garnered attention and favor among the French nobility, helping her establish a network of patrons. Her ability to navigate the male-dominated literary world of her time highlights her tenacity and strategic acumen.
Challenging Misogyny and Building a Literary City
Christine's literary journey took a critical turn around 1400 when she began to address the rampant misogyny permeating literary works. Her participation in the well-documented epistolary debate on the Roman de la rose marked her as a vocal critic of misogynistic language and themes. Christine's most renowned works, The Book of the City of Ladies and its sequel The Book of Three Virtues, serve as her response to the male-dominated narratives that often disparaged women.
In The Book of the City of Ladies, Christine constructs an allegorical city inhabited by women of virtue. The structure of this city mirrors her literary task of creating space for women's stories within the broader cultural narrative. Guided by allegorical figures—Reason, Rectitude, and Justice—Christine embarks on a narrative journey to "take the trowel of your pen" and "mix the mortar in your ink bottle" to construct this symbolic city.
Allegory and Structure
The book is divided into three sections, each representing a stage in the city's construction. In the first section, Christine, guided by Reason, lays the metaphorical and literal foundations by recounting the lives of women who contributed positively to society. As the city walls rise in the second section, Rectitude guides her, drawing from examples of women who demonstrated strength and virtue. Finally, under Justice's guidance, the city stands complete in the third section, with high towers housing revered figures such as the Virgin Mary and various female saints.
Through this allegory, Christine ingeniously weaves together a series of biographical sketches that elevate the narratives of women from antiquity and contemporary French history. The framework of the city allows her to explore various themes such as women's strength, intellectual contributions, and marital faithfulness, each illustrated through the lives of exceptional women.
Sources and Originality
Christine's narrative draws on a rich tapestry of both classical and medieval sources. Influences such as Boethius’s The Consolation of Philosophy, Dante's The Divine Comedy, and St. Augustine’s The City of God resonate within her work. Particularly notable is her use of Giovanni Boccaccio's Concerning Famous Women, from which she derives inspiration for her biographical sketches.
While Christine's reliance on established works might appear derivative from a modern perspective, it aligns with medieval literary practices that emphasized adaptation and reinterpretation over originality. Her...
(This entire section contains 821 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
reworking of these sources illuminates the positive attributes of women, challenging the negative portrayals often disseminated by male authors.
Recasting Women's Narratives
Christine adeptly reimagines stories to highlight women's virtues and strengths. For instance, in recounting the story of Queen Semiramis of Assyria, she emphasizes the queen’s military prowess and governance rather than focusing on scandalous tales of incest. This strategic retelling allows Christine to engage with pressing issues, such as gender-based violence and women's autonomy, through a lens that celebrates female agency.
Impact and Criticism
Despite its groundbreaking nature, The Book of the City of Ladies has faced criticism for Christine's seemingly conservative stance on contemporary political issues and her acceptance of social hierarchies, including female submissiveness. However, these critiques often overlook the historical and social constraints under which Christine operated. Her reliance on patronage from the nobility necessitated a careful balance between advocacy and deference to the prevailing social order.
Christine de Pizan’s work stands as a testament to the power of a singular female voice in an era dominated by male perspectives. Her pioneering efforts in The Book of the City of Ladies provide a nuanced and enduring challenge to the misogynistic narratives of her time. Through her sophisticated allegory and skillful reinterpretation of sources, Christine de Pizan carved out a lasting place for women's voices in literary history.