The Universality of Immorality
This short story conveys the idea that everyone is unethical, even sinful. Mr. Mooney waits until his father-in-law dies before revealing himself to be dishonest and irresponsible, even murderous—and so his wife leaves him. Jack Mooney is a "hard case" who cusses, fights, and bets. His sister, Polly, sings songs about being a "naughty girl" and manipulates a young man, Mr. Doran, into sleeping with and marrying her. Mrs. Mooney intends "to give her [daughter] the run of the young men" in the hopes that she will land a husband as well. Mr. Doran, a young man who sowed his oats in his youth and has been embracing celibacy of late, falls for Polly's manipulations and sleeps with her several times. No one is blameless here; all are guilty of some unethical, even sinful, behavior.
Marriage as a Business Contract
In "The Boarding House," love and marriage do not often go together; more often, it seems, marriage is a business contract predicated on money. Mrs. Mooney is a shrewd woman, and it seems unlikely that she would marry such a good-for-nothing man without some understanding of his real nature. However, he has a good job with her father, and she obviously knows how to manipulate him to gain control of their finances so that she could take any remaining money with her. Later, she knows how to orchestrate and manipulate her daughter and boarders to find a suitable match for Polly. Mr. Doran does not really feel himself to be in love with Polly; however, he marries her because he realizes that he has materially damaged her prospects.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.