Student Question
In "Blues Ain't No Mockin Bird," what message does Granny give the filmmakers through her actions and speech?
Quick answer:
Granny communicates a strong message to the filmmakers that they are unwelcome and disrespectful by intruding on her property without permission. Her actions and speech emphasize her dignity, self-worth, and the importance of privacy, rejecting the filmmakers' patronizing behavior and focus on material possessions. Through non-verbal cues and direct responses, she asserts her authority, highlighting that people matter more than "things," and demands respect for her autonomy.
In "Blues Ain't No Mockin Bird," Granny speech directed at the filmmakers gives two clear messages. The first is that they have no permission to film her and her family and equally no permission to be on her property. The second is that she has dignity and intrinsic worth. This is expressed by her refusal to be categorized as just another impersonal "aunty" with no individual identity or integrity. Granny responds to "aunty" by saying, “Your mama and I are not related.”
Granny's actions give an equally clear, and possibly dangerous, message to the filmmakers and cameraman. First, she continues with her meal preparations, which is an action that excludes the intruding filmmakers and reduces their interests in her to insignificance. Second, her non-verbal grunts and groans accompanying the motions of her continued work communicate a boiling volcano-like quality churning inside of her that may well erupt. In fact, the...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
narrator, the other children and Granddaddy all recognize that at any moment Granny might "bust through that screen with somethin in her hand and murder on her mind” aiming in the direction of the filmmakers.
Why does Granny resent the filmmakers in "Blues Ain't No Mockin Bird"?
Granny also resents the filmmakers because they appear to be investigating the extent of her wealth (or lack thereof).
For example, the cameraman takes pictures of the pecan barrels, the sled, the printed stones along the driveway, the trees, and the toolshed. It never occurs to the filmmakers that they are infringing on Granny's privacy. It also never occurs to the men that they may be insulting the property owner by their focus on material objects.
When the filmmakers comment that Granny has "nice things," she counters with “I don’t know about the thing, the it, and the stuff . . . just people here is what I tend to consider.” Granny feels resentful because the men appear focused on gathering information to use for or against the food stamp program. The author does not tell us about the exact motives of the filmmakers.
The filmmakers also ask intrusive and patronizing questions. They appear to hint that the food stamp program may not be necessary after all.
"We’re filmin for the county, see. Part of the food stamp campaign. You know about the food stamps?” Granny said nuthin. “Maybe there’s somethin you want to say for the film. I see you grow your own vegetables,” he smiled real nice. “If more folks did that, see, there’d be no need—”
In all, the filmmakers have chosen to ignore Granny's wishes and have treated her with little respect. Thus, their actions fuel resentment on Granny's part.
In "Blues Ain't No Mockin Bird," Granny resents the filmmakers and cameraman for several reasons, and they are all good and right reasons. First, after asking if they could film her and her family as part of a documentary and being told "No," they continued to try to cajole and persuade her against her wishes. This is highly disrespectful.
Second, they continued to affront her by remaining on her property, property that she and Granddaddy owned. Third, they insisted on filming against her express wishes and after clearly have permission denied. This all gives Granny sound moral and legal reason to resent the intrusion of the filmmakers and cameraman on her property and in her family's life.
What messages does Granny convey to the men in "Blues Ain't No Mockin Bird"?
In Toni Cade Bambara's short story "Blues Ain't No Mockin Bird," the two men
with the camera approach Granny expecting her to be very obliging. Instead,
Granny uses facial expressions to let the men know they are
not welcome and says things to send them the message that they
are invading people's privacy and being
disrespectful towards people.
When one of the men first approaches Granny and explains he thought he would
film the house, the narrator informs the reader that "Granny cut him off. And
smiled that smile," which must be a very frosty, superficial smile. After
receiving such a frosty smile, the man hangs his head in shame but still
pursues his interests. This time, he approaches his conquest by complementing
Granny on her home, saying, "Nice place you got here, aunty," and, "Nice things
here."
Granny continues to use facial expressions to relay
her displeasure, this time "talkin with her eyebrows" raised as she
questions his actions. In addition, she gives a response to
his compliments, which she detects are not genuine compliments, by
expressing her opinion that they are invading her privacy and
being disrespectful:
I don't know about the thing, the it, and the stuff ... . Just people here is what I tend to consider.
Through her curt response that emphasizes people, Granny shows just how much she values the needs of people above all else and indicates that the men are not valuing people to the same degree, because they are being disrespectful by invading her home and privacy.
What message does Granny convey through her speech and actions in "Blues Ain't No Mockingbird"?
Granny makes certain from the beginning that the men know that she is in charge of her own property. When one man casually, smiling, tries to explain to her what he'd like to capture on film, she cuts him off. She doesn't care what the explanation is, and she isn't afraid to confront these men in her yard. Cutting people off in conversation shows a sense of power and importance. (That's why interrupting is so strongly discouraged in good manners from the time kids are young.)
Granny also conveys quite a bit through her facial expressions. She lifts them as she speaks, indicating both that she questions their intentions and that she is a serious force in this conversation. When the men tell her that they like her "nice things," she replies,
“I don’t know about the thing, the it, and the stuff,” said Granny, still talkin with her eyebrows. “Just people here is what I tend to consider.”
Her facial expressions here add additional strength to the message she is conveying.
When a different man tries to persuade Granny to allow him to film her property and tries to slyly convey her permission ("Mind if we shoot . . . ?" conveys a sense that permission is already granted, almost like a rhetorical question), he is met with
“I do indeed,” said Granny with no smile.
Granny has now lost her sense of pleasantries. Her smile has disappeared, and she is not being cordial. After explaining that she is not interested in their little project through both actions and speech, she expects the men to leave.
In short, Granny conveys through words and actions that she is a strong woman who won't cave to their desires for using her property.