Themes: Insanity and Perversion
The narrator opens the story by claiming he will merely narrate “a series of household events” and that he is not “mad,” despite the strange story he is about to tell. However, the actions and emotions of the narrator are certainly not those of a “sane” person. He claims his violent behavior stems from “the spirit of perverseness”—explaining that “one of the primitive impulses of the human heart” is to do what “he knows he should not.”
He describes his urge to kill Pluto, the first black cat, “because I knew that it had loved me, and because I felt it had given me no reason of offence … because I knew that in doing so I was committing a sin.” The reason he should not desire to act with violence against this innocent cat is exactly what compels him to do it. This mentality also governs the narrator’s irrational hatred of the replacement black cat. The cat is just that: A cat. Yet, to the narrator, it symbolizes shame, guilt, and violence; for that reason, he attempts to kill it and, instead, kills his wife. His actions—from his drinking and mutilation of the original cat to his insane assumptions about the replacement cat and murder of his wife—indicate that he has embraced perversity and acts exclusively in ways his moral self knows he should not.
Worse, his excitement as the investigators inch closer to his wife’s resting place suggests that the narrator has lost all sense of reason. His insanity is further supported by his belief that the second cat is “the Arch-Fiend” and has purposely led the narrator to his downfall. At no point in the story are the narrator’s actions motivated by logic and are instead ruled by his ever-worsening mental state.
Expert Q&A
What factors, other than alcohol, contribute to the narrator's descent into violence and insanity?
The narrator's descent into violence and insanity in Edgar Allan Poe's "The Black Cat" is influenced by more than just alcohol. His inherent mental instability is evident in his cruel actions towards his beloved cat, Pluto, and his delusional belief that the cat's revenge caused his house to burn. Furthermore, his past as a docile individual, often the target of ridicule, suggests suppressed aggression that emerges in his violent tendencies, especially towards his wife.
How might the narrator's original household, the fire, and the damp cellar in "The Black Cat" symbolize his mental state?
The narrator's original household, fire, and damp cellar in "The Black Cat" symbolize his mental state by mirroring his spiritual and moral decline. Initially, his home is harmonious, reflecting his kindness and love for animals. As he succumbs to alcoholism and violence, the fire represents his self-destruction and spiritual damnation. The final move to a damp cellar symbolizes his descent into a hellish state, paralleling his increasingly depraved actions and mental deterioration.
In "The Black Cat," how does the narrator feel about his actions towards the cat?
The narrator feels intense guilt over his actions towards the cat Pluto, recognizing these acts as part of the terrible burden of guilt he carries. Initially fond of Pluto, his descent into alcoholism leads to anger and eventual cruelty. He cuts out the cat's eye in a rage and hangs it, not to end its suffering, but to damn himself, feeling his guilt is so profound that he deserves no mercy.
Why is the narrator's act of cutting out Pluto's eye significant?
The narrator's act of cutting out Pluto's eye marks the escalation of his violent behavior, indicating a loss of moral restraint. This cruelty prompts the cat to avoid him, which incites further violence, culminating in Pluto's hanging. The act also sets off a chain of events leading to the narrator's downfall, including the murder of his wife and his eventual arrest, symbolizing retribution for his actions.
What is a strong thesis about madness in Poe's "The Black Cat"?
A strong thesis about "The Black Cat" would be that the narrator was mad before the narrative began, and that the incidents with the black cat served to reveal his underlying condition.
How does the man's personality in "The Black Cat" change from beginning to end, and why?
The man's personality in "The Black Cat" shifts from kind-hearted and gentle to irritable and violent due to his growing addiction to alcohol. Initially devoted to people and animals, he becomes increasingly impatient and abusive, ultimately leading to the murder of both his cat and wife. Despite his delusions of rationality, he fails to recognize that his alcoholism, not the cat, drives his descent into violence and madness.
What type of psychological illness does the main character in "The Black Cat" suffer from?
The main character in "The Black Cat" likely suffers from a psychological illness exacerbated by alcoholism. His actions suggest symptoms of schizophrenia or a severe personality disorder, as he exhibits impulsive, violent behavior, and lacks empathy. While he blames his behavior on alcohol, his desire to "do wrong for wrong's sake" points to deeper issues. His insistence on not being insane further suggests mental instability, possibly masked by his addiction.
Define perversity and its impact on "The Black Cat" and "The Tell-Tale Heart."
Perversity in "The Black Cat" and "The Tell-Tale Heart" is a driving force behind the narrators' heinous actions. Defined as a deviation from moral rightness, perversity manifests in "The Black Cat" through alcohol-induced violence, leading the narrator to brutally harm his pet and kill his wife. In "The Tell-Tale Heart," it arises from an obsessive compulsion, prompting the narrator to murder an old man over an imagined flaw. Both stories showcase how perversity corrupts human nature and justifies evil deeds.
Why does the narrator in "The Black Cat" come to hate his cats so much?
The narrator's hatred for his cats develops gradually, initially loving his favorite pet. This changes after he drunkenly mishandles the cat, which retaliates by biting or scratching him. Enraged, the narrator mutilates the cat, and despite initial remorse, he continues to drink excessively. The cat's subsequent fear and avoidance of him deepen his resentment, leading him to feel betrayed and ultimately hang the cat in anger.
Why does the narrator in Poe's "The Black Cat" say he is abusive?
The narrator in Poe's "The Black Cat" attributes his abusive behavior to alcohol, which he claims altered his temperament, making him irritable and violent. Initially, these changes manifest as verbal abuse towards his wife, escalating to physical violence. His cruelty extends to mutilating his cat in a calculated manner, indicating a deeper psychological transformation. This progression suggests a descent into sociopathy, culminating in the murder of his wife, with no remorse except for being caught.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
