Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Last Updated June 21, 2023.


Billy Budd, written by Herman Melville and published posthumously in 1924, is a novella that delves into themes of innocence, moral ambiguity, and the clash between individual morality and institutional authority. 

Melville, best-known for his masterpiece Moby-Dick, crafted Billy Budd as his final completed work. The story takes place aboard a British naval ship during the late 18th century and explores the fateful encounter between Billy Budd, an innocent and charismatic sailor, and John Claggart, a malevolent master-at-arms. This summary will provide an overview of the novella's major events, examining its historical and literary significance.

What Happens:

Chapter 1: The novella introduces the setting, the HMS Bellipotent, a British naval ship. The reader is introduced to the protagonist, Billy Budd, a young and handsome sailor who impresses everyone with his good nature and physical beauty.

Chapter 2: Billy Budd's innocence and charm quickly make him popular among the crew. However, the master-at-arms, John Claggart, develops an irrational hatred towards Billy, which he disguises beneath a fa├žade of respect.

Chapter 3: Captain Vere, the ship's commander, recognizes Billy's extraordinary qualities and promotes him to a higher rank. Billy's rise in status further intensifies Claggart's jealousy and animosity.

Chapter 4: Claggart falsely accuses Billy of mutiny, presenting his allegations to Captain Vere. Despite Billy's innocence, he is unable to articulate a coherent defense, and his speech impediment, a stutter, contributes to his inability to express himself clearly.

Chapter 5: Captain Vere, facing a difficult decision, must choose between adhering to strict military discipline and recognizing the injustice of condemning an innocent young man. Ultimately, he succumbs to his duty and condemns Billy to death by hanging.

Chapter 6: The night before his execution, Billy remains stoic and serene, inspiring compassion and sympathy from his fellow sailors. Some crew members contemplate mutiny in response to Billy's unjust sentence, but their plans are thwarted.

Chapter 7: Billy Budd's execution takes place, and the entire crew witnesses the tragic event. Captain Vere wrestles with guilt and the realization that he sacrificed justice for the sake of military authority.

Why it Matters:

Billy Budd holds significant literary importance for several reasons. It explores complex themes such as the inherent goodness of innocence, the corrupting influence of power, and the conflict between individual morality and institutional law. Melville's exploration of these themes reflects his own contemplation of the moral dilemmas present in society.

The novella's historical context is crucial to understanding its significance. Set during the Napoleonic Wars, Billy Budd sheds light on the harsh and often arbitrary nature of naval discipline in that era. Melville uses the naval setting to critique the rigidity and flaws of all hierarchical systems, questioning the balance between justice and obedience to authority.

Billy Budd's posthumous publication and its subsequent recognition as a significant work of literature attest to its enduring impact. The novella showcases Melville's mastery of prose, his ability to create multidimensional characters, and his exploration of moral complexities. It remains a powerful examination of human nature, conscience, and the tragic consequences of flawed judgment.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

Chapter Summaries