Bette Bao Lord Criticism
Bette Bao Lord, a distinguished Chinese-American novelist and nonfiction writer, skillfully interweaves her rich background in Chinese culture and history into her literary works. Having left mainland China in 1946, her personal narratives often reflect her family’s journey and experiences. Her novel Spring Moon is a notable work that chronicles a Chinese family’s saga from the fall of the Manchu dynasty to the rise of Communist China. The novel is praised for its poignant portrayal of traditional Chinese society and cultural resilience, as noted by critics such as Ronald Nevans and Katherine Paterson. While some, like Christopher Lehmann-Haupt, critique its focus on tradition as stifling, others, such as Charlotte Curtis, commend its vivid depiction of daily life amidst historical change. The novel’s depth of cultural insight and historical narrative draws parallels to the works of Pearl Buck, as highlighted in Kirkus Reviews. Lord's ability to evoke empathy and capture the essence of a turbulent era is further acclaimed by critics like Enid Saunders Candlin and Joey Bonner.
Contents
-
Fiction: 'Spring Moon'
(summary)
In the following essay, the critic highlights how Bette Bao Lord's novel Spring Moon captivates readers with its cultural insights and historical narrative, depicting the complex dynamics of a Chinese family's journey through political upheavals from 1892 to 1972, while drawing parallels to the works of Pearl Buck.
-
Fiction Briefs: 'Spring Moon'
(summary)
In the following essay, Ronald Nevans praises Bette Bao Lord's novel Spring Moon for its poignant and restrained portrayal of traditional Chinese society while critiquing its polemical treatment of revolutionary themes.
-
From the Manchu to Mao: One Woman's Journey
(summary)
In the following essay, Katherine Paterson critiques Bette Bao Lord's Spring Moon for its narrative style, which skillfully intersperses historical context, while noting shortcomings in language translation and praising the novel's effective storytelling and its capacity to evoke empathy towards Chinese cultural resilience.
-
Brief Reviews: 'Spring Moon: A Novel of China'
(summary)
In the following essay, Joey Bonner critiques Bette Bao Lord's novel Spring Moon for its portrayal of the Chinese Revolution, arguing that while the novel lacks a nuanced political perspective, it effectively captures the cultural transformation and ideological conflicts within a traditional Chinese family, reminiscent of the May Fourth era.
-
Among the Ming Urns
(summary)
In the following essay, Charlotte Curtis praises Bette Bao Lord's novel "Spring Moon" for its detailed portrayal of a centuries-old Chinese clan, emphasizing the cultural and familial traditions against the backdrop of historical change, and commends Lord's balanced depiction of Chinese politics and her ability to vividly capture daily life.
-
Moving Saga of Chinese Family
(summary)
In the following essay, Enid Saunders Candlin praises Bette Bao Lord's novel Spring Moon for its panoramic portrayal of China's turbulent history, effectively capturing the dissolution of the Manchu Empire and subsequent sociopolitical upheavals through the lens of a privileged family's experiences, allowing events to unfold without overt explanation or interpretation.
-
Books of the Times: 'Spring Moon'
(summary)
In the following essay, Christopher Lehmann-Haupt critiques Bette Bao Lord's "Spring Moon: A Novel of China" for its historical fiction elements that, while promising, fall short due to the overwhelming historical context and a focus on tradition that stifles the narrative and character development.