Themes: Freedom and Imprisonment

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Early in the story a bet is struck between a banker and a young lawyer. The former bets the latter that he will not be able to survive fifteen years in solitary confinement. However, the lawyer can give up the bet anytime he chooses with no real consequence outside of forfeiting the money, meaning that he is, in effect, his own jailer. His prison is not literal in the sense that nothing is truly preventing him from leaving; instead, his prison is ideological. His own convictions and his desire for wealth trap him in the bet. His decision to leave early is not an act of submission or forfeiture, but rather a declaration that he has been freed from the constraints of things such as morality, idealism, and materialism. His recognition of life as a meaningless veneer has, for better or worse, freed him from the need for money or the need to be proven correct, allowing him to leave his self-imposed prison with no regrets.

Expert Q&A

What three details from "The Bet" best support its theme?

Three details from "The Bet" that support its theme include the initial debate over whether solitary confinement or death is worse, highlighting the value of life experiences. The lawyer's reliance on books during his confinement reflects his search for meaning without real-world experiences, leading to his ultimate rejection of life. Lastly, the banker's ambiguous remorse after the lawyer renounces the bet underscores the idea that life's transient experiences make it meaningful and bearable.

Why does the lawyer in "The Bet" rank "freedom" above "life and health"?

The lawyer ranks "freedom" above "life and health" because, after 15 years of solitary confinement, he finds that even freedom, which should be his highest wish, has become insignificant. His intense reading and acquired wisdom have led him to view worldly desires and blessings as fleeting and deceptive. This profound inner peace and contentment make him dismiss not only freedom but also life, health, and material wealth as illusory.

In "The Bet," what does the prisoner's reading suggest about his moods at different times?

The prisoner's reading choices in "The Bet" reflect his changing moods over time. Initially, he reads light fiction to pass the time, but by the second year, he shifts to classics, indicating a desire for deeper engagement. By the sixth year, he studies languages, philosophy, and history, showing a thirst for knowledge. In the tenth year, he reads mainly the Gospel, suggesting spiritual reflection. Finally, in the last two years, his reading becomes eclectic, indicating a sense of closure.

How would you explain the content of the lawyer's note in "The Bet," considering his behavior during imprisonment?

In "The Bet," the lawyer's note reflects his transformation during imprisonment. Initially focused on his legal career, he used his confinement to study philosophy, languages, and history, ordering over 600 books. This extensive reading led him to the New Testament, where he embraced spiritual wisdom over material wealth. By the end, he rejected the two million rubles prize, valuing his newfound enlightenment and inner peace over money, which he initially coveted.

Can you summarize "The Bet" and what the lawyer learned during his imprisonment?

The lawyer in "The Bet" learned the futility of wealth and luxury during his imprisonment. Over fifteen years, he immersed himself in studying languages, music, philosophy, and more, as the banker provided all requested materials. Through solitary meditation and extensive learning, he came to despise material wealth, ultimately deciding to forfeit the bet and leave his confinement early to demonstrate his newfound rejection of luxury.

Write a diary entry for the lawyer from "The Bet" during his imprisonment.

During his imprisonment, the lawyer might write optimistically about why he accepted the bet, expressing hope that winning would demonstrate the value of intellectual pursuits over material wealth. He might describe his initial feelings towards the banker, possibly viewing him as a catalyst for proving a philosophical point. The lawyer could reflect on his accommodations, plan how to fill his time productively, and express that his victory might inspire others to value knowledge and inner growth.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: Crime and Punishment

Next

Themes: Greed

Loading...