Bertrand Russell: The Ghost of Madness, 1921-1970 Analysis

Ray Monk

Bertrand Russell

Ray Monk is a philosophy professor whose first book was a biography of Ludwig Wittgenstein, the Austrian-born philosopher whose brilliance unsettled even the haughty Bertrand Russell. This first volume of a planned two-volume life of Russell covers the first forty-nine of his ninety-eight years, from 1872 through 1921. Writing Russell’s life is a daunting task in that the Bibliography of Bertrand Russell contains more than three thousand entries, and the Russell Archives hold more than forty thousand letters as well as many journals, manuscripts, and other documents. In many of these materials, Russell is concerned mostly with himself, creating a record of “detailed self-absorption” that Monk judges matched only by that of Virginia Woolf.

In working with this rich trove, Monk, unlike previous biographers, provides a full account of Russell’s philosophical work and social thought. Monk organizes his story around the three powerful forces he locates at the root of Russell’s behavior: “his need for love, his yearning for certain knowledge, and his sometimes overpowering impulse to become involved in the great political issues of his day.” These three passions were often in conflict with one another, and in Monk’s analysis they issue from a terrible loneliness exacerbated by a haunting fear of madness. The events in Russell’s life that shaped this difficult emotional history began very early in Russell’s childhood.

Bertrand Arthur William Russell was born on May 18, 1872, in Monmouthshire, England, in the most privileged circumstances. He was the third child and second son of Viscount Amberley and his wife, Kate. The Russells were an old family in a proud Whig tradition. Russell’s grandfather, Lord John Russell, was a younger son of the sixth Duke of Bedford, and Lord John’s highly principled political career included promotion of the Great Reform Act of 1832 and two terms as Queen Victoria’s prime minister. Bertrand Russell was well aware all his life of the role expected of a Russell in public affairs.

Russell’s family began to abandon him early in his childhood. When he was two years old, first his mother, and then a few days later his sister, died of diphtheria. Russell’s heartbroken father died eighteen months later when Russell was three. He was taken in by his grandparents, only to have Lord Russell die when he was six and leave him to wonder when his grandmother would die too. Russell’s extremely intelligent and rational mind set him off immediately from most people, and the combination of mental brilliance and his childhood losses burdened him with the “spirit of solitude” (the phrase is from Percy Bysshe Shelley’s poem “Alastor”) and the need for love that Monk captures so well.

Assuagement from his loneliness came in 1889 when he met Alys Pearsall Smith, staying with her well-to-do Philadelphia family near the farm of Russell’s Uncle Rollo on the border between Surrey and Sussex. The following summer Russell entered Trinity College, Cambridge, and for the next few years he was preoccupied with mathematics and afflicted with sexual ache for Alys. He passed his Cambridge exams in 1893, and he married Alys in 1894 despite Lady Russell’s opposition and her warning of hereditary insanity, a specter that haunted Russell’s imagination all his life. After a flirtation with Baruch Spinoza’s pantheism and a spell of allegiance to Friedrich Hegel’s Absolute Idealism, by 1898 Russell had converted to the young analytical school of philosophy which he found compatible with an intense passion for Plato’s world of shining abstract Forms.

By 1899, Russell was writing The Principles of Mathematics, but his discovery in 1900 of the mathematical logic of Giuseppe Peano convinced him that all mathematics is built on logic and he completely rewrote his manuscript. In 1901, he discovered “Russell’s Paradox,” the puzzling case of the class of all classes that are not members of themselves (if this class is a member of itself, then it is not, and if it is not, then it is), an insight that he feared might be fatal to the notion of a “class” that was vital to his construction of a logical base for mathematics. Russell’s struggle with his paradox, not convincingly solved by his early “theory of types,” pursued him into his “long night,” Russell’s own term for the period from 1904 to 1910 during which he was laboring intensively with Alfred North Whitehead on their Principia Mathematica. One product of this period was Russell’s effort to resolve his paradox in his famous article “On Denoting” (1905), in which he argued that a concept is denoted by a description, not by a name. The paradox followed, he thought, from phrases that led to a contradiction and therefore could not refer to anything real. These phrases (synonymous in Russell’s mind with classes) have meaning in his “Theory of Descriptions” only when they are embedded in a proposition, and if a whole proposition and its converse are both false without creating a...

(The entire section is 2072 words.)

Bertrand Russell

In Bertrand Russell: The Ghost of Madness, 1921-1970, Ray Monk completes his account of the philosopher’s life begun in his acclaimed Bertrand Russell: The Spirit of Solitude, 1872-1921 (1996). Monk provides an important corrective to the usual image of Russell as a benign eminence grise, an espouser of quaint but ultimately harmless social views, and a culmination of the philosophical tradition that had produced such figures as Alfred North Whitehead (1861-1947) and Kurt Gödel (1906-1978). Monk’s image of Russell is both more controversial and more complex than this traditional view. The Ghost of Madness depicts the philosopher as struggling to find a new focus once his most important intellectual work is behind him. Monk’s Russell seeks in vain to locate a new philosophical anchor since he cannot refute challenges made by other scholars to his most fundamental principles. More ominously, Monk’s Russell is a conflicted figure whose stunted emotions and commitment to rationality at all cost prove disastrous to members of his own family when he attempts to put several ill-conceived ideas into practice.

The Ghost of Madness opens with its subject having both World War I and the sources of his international acclaim—his highly influential works Principles of Mathematics (1903) and Principia Mathematica (coauthored with Alfred North Whitehead, 1910-1913)—already behind him. In these early books, Russell had explored the principle that, when properly viewed, mathematics is reducible to formal logic. For this reason, Russell’s system viewed all mathematical truths as capable of being recast as logical truths. Monk notes that the difficulty with this approach was that, through his work with his erstwhile student Ludwig Wittgenstein leading to the publication of Wittgenstein’s Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus in 1922, Russell came to see one of his central beliefs about logic, and thus about mathematics, as fatally flawed. Rather than dealing with an external and objective world, as logic had been conceived since the time of Plato, logic according to Wittgenstein’s thought was essentially a linguistic, and thus a merely conventional, construct. With the keystone of his philosophical system removed, Russell found himself searching desperately for a way to reconcile his mathematic approach to logic with Wittgenstein’s more linguistically based system.

Compounding this situation, Russell’s intellectual energy was increasingly diffused by two other factors: the birth of his children John and Kate, and the delight he took in the visibility he received as a notorious, but still popular, public intellectual. After a childless marriage to his first wife, Alys Pearsall Smith, and dalliances with several other women, including Lady Ottoline Morrell and Constance (Colette) Malleson, Russell was fascinated by the birth of his first child, John. His interest shifted from exploring abstract theories to engaging in the daily routine of rearing a child. Having spent most of his inheritance on such causes as the London School of Economics and having lost his academic appointment at Cambridge when he spoke out against World War I, Russell was compelled to support his new family through journalism. However, while the essays and books he produced throughout the 1920’s and 1930’s served only to increase his popularity and (to his great amusement) to scandalize conservatives, many of these works were viewed by his academic colleagues as little more than hack pieces. The philosophers who had once admired his critical acumen were now concerned that he was dissipating his talent on insignificant works that were hastily written and at times self-contradictory.

Among the books for the general public that Russell wrote during this period were The ABC of Atoms (1923), The ABC of Relativity (1925), What I Believe (1925), Marriage and Morals (1929), The Scientific Outlook (1931), and Education and the Social Order (1932). Russell also undertook to prepare a new edition of Principia Mathematica that would incorporate both Wittgenstein’s linguistic approach to logic and recent developments in mathematics and set theory. To...

(The entire section is 1745 words.)