What are the themes of Behind the Beautiful Forevers: Life, Death, and Hope in a Mumbai Undercity?
The book is set in a slum called Annawadi in Mumbai, which is one of the fastest-growing cities in the world. The slum is near the airport and within sight of several luxury hotels.
One of the main themes is that of the permanent versus the ephemeral. Most of the residents of the slum dream of moving somewhere safe and warm, instead of their current habitats of cardboard walls and plastic sheeting. They want to make some kind of mark in the world, yet they are too consumed with the day-to-day tasks of simply staying alive to think about such lofty ideas.
Another theme is that of the very rich living side by side with the very poor. The very poor actually live off the very rich peoples' garbage, selling the scraps to make a few rupees. The dehumanizing effect of poverty is another underlying theme in the story, as...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
is the way in which the poor are treated in the greater community; the police falsely accuse residents of crimes and then demand bribes from them. They also frequently threaten to chase the slum-dwellers off the property and raze Annawadi. Food that is donated to the church for the sake of the poor is sold by nuns for a profit. The author does not judge these people for their actions, however— everyone is simply doing what they need to survive. The very poor are not saintly people; they are just trying to get by.
These slum-dwellers are not totally without hope, however. We meet a girl who is about to graduate from college, as well as a woman who wants to become a political bigwig within the slum system itself, and a boy thief who believes, in time, he will make enough money to move out of the slum and live "the full enjoy."
References
The first important theme of Behind the Beautiful Forevers by Katherine Boo is the contrast between wealth and poverty in India. It is set in a slum in Mumbai which is in sight of Mumbai's international airport and many luxury hotels. Thus, we get a sharp sense of how the "new India" of successful technology companies benefiting from globalization contrasts with the "old India" living in poverty without basic modern conveniences. An important and ironic element of this contrast is the way that the slum dwellers of Annawadi make their living is by sorting through the garbage thrown out by their richer neighbors.
The second theme dominating the book is "garbage." Annawadi is a garbage dump, both in terms of the objects tossed out in the literal garbage dump and the way in which its inhabitants are viewed as human refuse by wealthier and more fortunate Indians. Just as the residents of Annawadi survive and sometimes even succeed by sorting through and finding value in other people's garbage, Boo and her readers find value and interest in the lives of the people marginalized in Annawadi.
The final important theme of the book is justice. On top of the fundamental injustice of people living in filth and poverty in the sight of luxury hotels, we also see miscarriages of justice and corruption in the Indian legal system contributing to systematic oppression and inequality.
What is the summary of Behind the Beautiful Forevers: Life, Death, and Hope in a Mumbai Undercity?
Behind the Beautiful Forevers: Life, Death, and Hope in a Mumbai
Undercity is all about Boo's work in Mumbai, India. There is an airport in
Mumbai that was turned into a makeshift home for migrant workers in the 1990s.
In the most marshy (and unusable) part of the land, it became a large pack of
tents full of a diverse, poor population from many different countries and
speaking many different languages. Boo worked extensively with the people there
in what became known as the Annawadi slum.
The hardships at the camp are surreal: hunger, weather, fatigue, violence,
corruption, disease, and poverty. There didn't seem to be a single hardship
that these poor people didn't go through. Further, because most of them were
there illegally, all the people were worried that the airport authorities would
come and bulldoze the camp completely.
The entire book is Boo's story about very specific characters. One such
character is named Sunil. He is an orphan boy who is small for his age and is
trying to grow to be a man. To do this, Sunil thinks that he needs to learn to
be a better scavenger at the camp. Fatima is another character. She has only
one leg and dreams of a better life. At one point during the book, she gives a
false testimony to the police, and implicates Abdul. Fatima sets herself on
fire after an argument with another campmate, and eventually dies from those
wounds. The third character that is important is the character of Abdul. He is
a garbage-picker at the camp. He has been doing that job for two generations,
and he is the breadwinner for the family. Abdul is one of the people who Fatima
accuses as the reason for her injuries before she dies.
In this educator's opinion, however, the two most important characters in the
Annawadi slum are Asha and Manju. They are mother and daughter, complete
opposites, and foils of each other. Asha is the ruthless female slumlord (which
is rare in India). She has little compassion for the people of the slums and
uses argument to control the people. Asha often begins an altercation and then
requests payment from the other party in order to stop it. This dishonesty is
how Asha moved her way to the top. On the other hand, Manju is full of
compassion for people. Instead of aspiring to become slumlord, Manju wants to
be the first of her family to graduate from a university. Manju always wishes
to promote peace in the slum where her mom wishes to promote discord. As such,
these two characters are perfect examples of literary foils.