Themes and Meanings

(Masterpieces of American Fiction)

The Beet Queen deals primarily with marginal people who live socially and culturally displaced lives. This marginality is a source of both strength and grief for Erdrich’s characters. Wallace Pfef, an outstanding civic leader, is marginal as a homosexual in a small, Midwestern town and in his role as substitute father to Dot Adare. Yet it is precisely his love for Karl and Dot that provides his greatest joy and pain. In addition to being socially marginal, Erdrich’s characters are culturally marginal; they live under codes of both Christianity and archetypal myths.

The families in The Beet Queen are also marginal. Although the novel might be seen as a family saga portraying three generations, the plot suggests that there are many nonbiological ties that link people. Mary grows up with her Aunt Fritzie, who prefers Mary to her own daughter, Sita. Celestine, who is Karl’s wife, spends much more time with Wallace, who often plays the role of husband. Celestine’s relationship with Mary is also ambiguous. While the two women are close friends by choice, it is not until Celestine bears Mary’s niece that confrontations arise. These complex, mixed roles produce gaps in the clear line of relationships that inform traditional family sagas and are suggestive of tribal kinship systems.

Erdrich’s method of characterization emphasizes this conflict between nuclear family and tribal codes. Mary, Karl, Celestine, and Dot are not...

(The entire section is 522 words.)

Themes and Meanings

(Comprehensive Guide to Short Stories, Critical Edition)

The function of a parable is to teach readers how, from the natural occurrences of life, one may discover moral and ethical attitudes essential to humankind. Erdrich’s work is expressive of this tradition stemming from the oral traditions of American fiction, in which the journey becomes a metaphor for life, characters are archetypal, conflicts are gradually and slowly drawn and sustained, and endings are satisfactorily resolved. Themes that rise from the tradition of the parable are often predictable, but that does not make the story less interesting or the writer less skilled. On the contrary, these kinds of stories often loosen the spirit in ways that more complex stories do not. Erdrich is a member of the Turtle Mountain Chippewa Tribe of Indians, a cultural group whose storytelling traditions clarify the journey convention as deliberately as any other. “After that train journey I was not a child,” says Mary Lavelle, her movement toward adulthood complete before she reaches her teens. “The Beet Queen” is clearly a story about a girl who has had no childhood, robbed of it by the circumstances of her grim environment.

A second theme, one of the significant recurring themes in twentieth century narrative fiction, is that of the loss of traditional values. Certainly, this story’s events and ironic tone seize on this idea. It becomes apparent to the careful reader, however, that in the closing lines there is a hunger expressed by the youthful...

(The entire section is 408 words.)

Social Concerns / Themes

(Beacham's Encyclopedia of Popular Fiction)

Anthropologists have asserted that rules governing kinship ties are the basis of a society; and it is these kinship rules that are the...

(The entire section is 282 words.)