The Ballad of the Sad Café

by Carson McCullers

Start Free Trial

Themes and Meanings

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The love theme is unquestionably the most important of several themes interwoven in this richly symbolic story. The author not only demonstrates through her characters her distinctive view of love relationships but also, at one point in the novel, digresses into a brief essay on the nature of love and how it affects people who love and are loved. She distinguishes the lover, who is free to love and to demonstrate this love and is thus in control of the relationship, from the beloved, who is in danger of being possessed by the lover. The lover is the happier one in the relationship always, and the beloved fears and even hates the lover.

There is no place for reciprocal relationships in this concept of love. Marvin Macy loves Amelia and she rejects him. Amelia loves Lymon and he uses and finally attacks her. Lymon loves Marvin, but Marvin despises and abuses Lymon. Love is a pleasure for the lover as long as the beloved will tolerate the lover. For the beloved, the relationship is no pleasure at all, and the only reason to tolerate it is for some perceived material gain.

A very insistent theme is that of isolation. The town is isolated, Amelia is isolated in many ways from the other people of the town, Marvin Macy was isolated in prison, the members of the chain gang are isolated from other people in society, Lymon is isolated by his handicap and ill health. All attempt to overcome the isolation by love, social intercourse with other people, and singing in harmony, as the case may be. However, the story ends with Amelia in ever more profound isolation, with the townspeople seeking to relieve their loneliness by leaving the town to go listen to the chain gang singing. Love, the author suggests, can overcome this sense of isolation, and being together, even in a chain gang, is preferable to the intolerable loneliness of isolation. Amelia’s isolation is destroying the life of the town as it has destroyed the social center of the town.

Another important theme is that of the grotesque. Each of the major characters is manifestly grotesque in certain ways. The little hunchback who is less than four feet tall is certainly grotesque. To add to his oddity, he dresses in grotesque clothing not at all appropriate to the time, place, or climate. Amelia is grotesque also. She is not built like an ordinary woman, being too tall, too strong, too brawny, and she dresses and acts like a man. Amelia’s talents for commerce, healing, moonshining, fighting, and self-sufficiency all set her apart from the ordinary. Marvin Macy is also grotesque, in his outlaw behavior, his defiance of social mores, and his cruelty to people who care about him. Indeed, the town and the climate itself seem grotesque in that they depart manifestly from the usual. The author seems to suggest that isolation stems from differences and that love does provide a bond to enable people to share and be together, but as the love is not reciprocated, the chain is weak and will be broken, incurring even more profound isolation, and even more grotesque behavior.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access