Rational vs. Instinctual
In the 5th century B.C., the Greeks placed a high value on balance and harmony in their everyday lives. This appreciation is evident in their art, architecture, laws, political systems, and societal structures, all of which reflect a culture striving for equilibrium in every facet, including human behavior. Their gods personified different aspects of human nature. Apollo, the deity of prophecy, music, and wisdom, represented the rational and intellectual capabilities of the human mind, symbolizing the ability to create order from chaos. Conversely, Dionysus, the god of wine and revelry, embodied the emotional, creative, and uninhibited sides of human instinct, providing a counterbalance to the rational, structured, and lawful aspects of daily life. The central conflict in The Bacchae centers around these two opposing behavioral tendencies, commonly known as the Apollonian and the Dionysian.
The advantages of worshiping Dionysus are celebrated by Cadmus, the former king of Thebes; Tiresias, the wise blind prophet of the city; and the Chorus of Bacchae, the god's followers. Always eager to learn, Tiresias and Cadmus have embraced the joys of Dionysian rituals, finding a renewed sense of youth. ‘‘I shall never tire, night or day, of beating the earth with the thyrsus,’’ Cadmus proclaims, ‘‘In my joy, I have forgotten how old I am.’’
The Chorus, who recount the god's history and explain how to worship him, also warn of his dual nature and the risks of defying him. ‘‘The deity, son of Zeus, delights in festivals,’’ they sing. ‘‘He loves the goddess Peace, who brings prosperity and cherishes youth. He grants both rich and poor the equal blessing of wine's joy. But he despises those who reject such pleasures—living a life of joyful days and sweet, happy nights, wisely keeping their mind and heart away from overly busy affairs.’’
Pentheus's error in the play is his disdain for the simple pleasures that Dionysus offers. Fully devoted to reason, he dismisses the necessity for himself and his citizens to occasionally release their inhibitions—to dance, sing, eat, drink, and enjoy life. As a strict moralist, he warns Tiresias, ‘‘When the sparkle of wine joins women’s feasts, there is something corrupt about such celebrations, I assure you.’’ His flaw is excessive pride, or hubris, in Greek terms. He denies the existence of Dionysus, the god of wine and festivity, and his relentless pursuit of order leads to his downfall, despite all the warnings he receives.
Individual vs. God
The struggle between individuals and their gods, whether literal or metaphorical, has been a frequent theme in literature. From biblical stories like those of Moses and Job to modern plays such as Peter Shaffer’s Amadeus (1985) and Tony Kushner’s Angels in America (1993), these narratives often explore the intricate and challenging relationships between humans and the divine forces that may have given them life, energy, and inspiration. Despite the often complex love/hate dynamic depicted in these tales, humans rarely confront their divine adversaries face-to-face, unlike Pentheus’s direct encounter with Dionysus in The Bacchae.
The central conflict involves Dionysus's claim to exist and demand worship from the Greeks, regardless of their willingness. "This city must learn, whether it likes it or not, that it still wants initiation into my Bacchic rites," Dionysus proclaims in the play's prologue. "The cause of my mother Semele I must defend by proving to mortals that I am a god, borne by her to Zeus." Dionysus's jealous nature is reminiscent of the God in the Old Testament, who tests humanity, destroys entire cities, and floods the earth to purify it for his followers.
Pentheus, the mortal opposing Dionysus, is a skeptical realist...
(This entire section contains 404 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
who refuses to believe in the god or his extraordinary powers. He thinks he can imprison Dionysus, suppress his followers, and stop the spread of his worship through sheer force, despite repeated warnings from those around him. Cadmus and Tiresias urge Pentheus to accept Dionysus's worship in the city. The Chorus praises the god. The Herdsman from Mount Cithaeron states, "Ifhe exists not, then neither does Cypris, nor any other joy for men at all." Despite all these warnings, Pentheus continues on his chosen path and only realizes the mystery of Dionysus's powers when the god himself enchants the unsuspecting king and leads him to his downfall.
The outcome of the struggle between humans and gods is often similar, though the lessons learned differ. After centuries of conflict with his creation, the Biblical God is transformed in the New Testament, following the life and sacrifice of his son, Jesus. Humanity is granted free will, along with the freedom to suffer or prosper at the hands of others. In Amadeus, Shaffer’s Salieri is consumed by his envy of God and ultimately destroys himself. The characters in Kushner’s Angels in America reach an impasse with divinity. However, Pentheus learns a critical lesson far too late.
Sex Roles
Euripides stands out among the Greek playwrights for assigning significant roles to women in his plays, although, in line with the theatrical traditions of the time, these roles were performed by men. His plays often convey sympathy for the difficulties women faced in Greek society. For example, Medea, betrayed by Jason, is portrayed with a degree of sympathy, even though she commits the horrific act of killing her own children. In "Hippolytus," Phaedra, the stepmother, is consumed by an overpowering desire. Likewise, Hippolytus is depicted as a fanatical extremist, arguably deserving of his brutal demise. In The Bacchae, although Euripides's criticism of Greek treatment of women might not be immediately obvious, it is revealed through the portrayal of Dionysian rituals, the compassionate Chorus of Bacchae, and Agave's torment at the play's end.
In Euripides's time, women were largely barred from participating in political life, the arts, and many religious ceremonies. The cult of Dionysus offered women a chance for worship equal to or even greater than that available to men. By embracing the spirit of wine and revelry associated with Dionysus, women could become priestesses, or "Bacchae," simply by engaging in drinking, dancing, singing, and releasing their inhibitions. Pentheus, symbolizing the traditional male-dominated Greek culture, disapproved of women's participation in drinking and religious rituals. However, Tiresias contended that a woman's moral character is determined by her nature, not divine influence. "Even in Bacchic revels the good woman, at least, will not be corrupted," he asserts. The Chorus of Bacchae in the play defies Pentheus’s beliefs. They have journeyed with Dionysus from Asia Minor, where his cult originated, and now live solely to honor him and enjoy his bountiful peace. "The ground flows with milk, flows with wine, flows with the nectar of bees," they sing.
Agave's anguish at the play's end demonstrates that women are equally prone to both happiness and sorrow. Initially, Agave denied Dionysus's divinity, accusing her sister, Semele, of fabricating her love affair with Zeus, the king of the gods. Her deceit provoked Dionysus's anger upon the women of Thebes, driving them mad and sending them into the hills. Her son, King Pentheus, worsened her mistake by refusing to permit Dionysus's worship in Thebes, resulting in their tragic fate: Agave was compelled to kill her own son and display his severed head to the horrified citizens of Thebes.