Themes: The Performance of Gender
Throughout the course of the play, Shakespeare examines the extent to which gender is a performance. While many Shakespeare plays feature women who dress as men (Twelfth Night, Merchant of Venice, Two Gentlemen of Verona, Cymbeline) or men who disguise themselves as women (The Merry Wives of Windsor, Taming of the Shrew), the self-referential cross-dressing in Shakespeare’s As You Like offers more of a commentary on gender roles in Shakespeare’s time.
Rosalind becomes the male Ganymede to protect herself in the forest. Once there, Ganymede pretends to be Rosalind in order to teach Orlando how to woo. This act of triple cross-dressing is further complicated by Elizabethan politics: The character Rosalind would have been played by a man on the Elizabethan stage, because women were forbidden from acting. The many layers of crossdressing, and the willingness of all characters to accept each performed gender, suggests that Rosalind was written to blur gender lines and to draw attention to its performative nature.
Because Shakespeare wrote during the time of Queen Elizabeth, the cross-dressing in his plays can be interpreted as commentary on the queen’s reign. Elizabeth distanced herself from her gender, exclaiming in one speech at Tilbury, “I know I have the body but of a weak and feeble woman; but I have the heart and stomach of a king.” Elizabeth’s reign challenged the patriarchal order of Early Modern England. She proved that a woman didn’t need a husband and could rule with the power of a king. Elizabeth remained conservative towards the rights of women throughout her reign and worked to separate her reputation from her gender. Shakespeare’s tendency to play with gender in his plays demonstrates a public fascination with the performative nature of gender, which may have extended to the queen’s performance of those roles.
Expert Q&A
Does Phebe's declaration in Act 3, Scene 5 apply to characters in As You Like It?
Phebe's declaration about love at first sight in Act 3, Scene 5 highlights a key theme in As You Like It, which Shakespeare uses to challenge the romantic ideal. While characters like Rosalind and Orlando experience love at first sight, the play emphasizes rationality over impulsive emotions. Rosalind tests Orlando's love, and Celia initially resists love for Oliver due to his past character. Thus, Shakespeare satirizes the notion of love at first sight to promote thoughtful relationships.
Why is Rosalind considered the strongest woman in As You Like It?
Rosalind is considered the strongest woman in "As You Like It" due to her intelligence, wit, and ability to navigate societal restrictions through her disguise as Ganymede. This allows her to act freely and assertively, educating Orlando and others on love. Shakespeare's portrayal of Rosalind reflects the influence of Queen Elizabeth I, showcasing a powerful, educated woman. Her character challenges Elizabethan norms by being outspoken and commanding attention, embodying qualities of modern feminism.
What does "Shakespeare has no heroes, only heroines in As You Like It" mean?
The statement "Shakespeare has no heroes, only heroines in 'As You Like It'" highlights Rosalind's central role in resolving the play's conflicts. Disguised as Ganymede, she orchestrates the romantic resolutions, notably securing Orlando's love and facilitating Silvius's marriage to Phebe. Rosalind's cleverness and agency drive the plot's happy conclusions, distinguishing her as the play's true heroine, while male characters play secondary roles to her leadership and problem-solving abilities.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.