Analysis
Much like A Midsummer Night’s Dream, William Shakespeare’s As You Like It takes place partly in the “Green World.” The Green World is a Shakespearean trope in which the characters from the civilized world escape to the natural world in order to avoid the problems of civilized life.
Over the course of the play, these characters have experiences and interactions within the Green World that allow them to solve the problems of the court. Thus, the Green World is an idyllic space in which the consequences, pressures, and restrictions of society do not apply. The Forest of Arden is a Green World because it provides a safe haven for many of the characters in As You Like It. Duke Senior is able to maintain a court after being usurped by his brother. In this court, he is both in control and not responsible for reclaiming his throne. Rosalind is able to assume a masculine identity that she uses to transform her lover into an ideal partner. Oliver and Orlando are able to mend their familial relationship when Orlando must save Oliver from a lion attack in the woods. Because the characters manipulate their circumstances in the Green World, they are able to restore order in the courtly world. Indeed, by the end of the play, Frederick steps down and allows his brother to assume his rightful place at the head of the court.
Historical Context
Shakespeare’s source material for As You Like It is Thomas Lodge’s 1590 comedic pastoral novel, Rosalynde: Euphues Golden Legacie. Shakespeare borrows the names Rosalind, Celia, Pheobe, Corin, and Silvius from Lodge’s text. In the introduction to Lodge’s story, a character says, “If you like it, so,” which is the line upon which Shakespeare based his play’s title. While there are many similarities, it is also apparent that Shakespeare meant to change the story in order to achieve a different theme. In setting the story primarily in the Forest of Arden and juxtaposing the courtly love of Rosalind and Orlando with the pastoral love of Silvius and Phoebe (as well as Touchstone and Audrey), Shakespeare mocks the pastoral comedy. It becomes a critique of courtly people who unrealistically idealize country life. As the play is set in France, the Forest of Arden may also be a reference to the real Forest of Ardennes in Belgium.
The Pastoral Mode
The pastoral convention is an Early Modern literary mode that presents the countryside as an idyllic space that lies in contrast to the complexity and corruption of the city and the court. This space, imagined by courtiers and rich noblemen of the city, ignores the reality of a country life full of manual labor and hardship. It imagines peaceful shepherds in mild, sunny, natural spaces. Shepherds will participate in “singing matches” that demonstrate their prowess with words and respect for poetry. The pastoral space is a paradise. To this point, Shakespeare’s Forest of Arden gets its name by combining Arcadia, the earthly paradise of Greek lore, with Eden, the biblical paradise. Duke Senior’s benevolent court in the forest, the singing interludes, and the shepherds who aid and fall in love with city dwellers all point to the pastoral tropes of As You Like It. Songs like “Blow Thy Winter Wind” demonstrate the stark contrast between the idealized countryside and the corrupt court. However, just as much as the play embodies a pastoral comedy, it also calls it into question and satirizes it. Orlando’s terrible love poetry pokes fun of the tradition in which singing shepherds are poets in disguise; Jaques reminds the audience of the miseries of the real world; Corin the shepherd reminds the courtiers that their manners are “poorly suited” to the hard labor of the countryside. In this way, the play mocks the idea of a paradise on Earth. The pastoral paradise is a space invented by the delusions and desires of city dwellers who wish to escape the hardships of their lives.
Historical Background
As You Like It was probably written in 1599 or 1600, at the midway point of Shakespeare's career as a playwright. His principal source for the play was Thomas Lodge's pastoral romance, Rosalynde. Lodge's novel, published in 1590, was in turn adapted from The Tale of Gamelyn, a 14th-century narrative poem. Shakespeare rewrote the story even further; he introduced new themes and created a number of new characters including Jaques, Touchstone, William, and Audrey. He also gave his characters far more depth and dimension than they had in Lodge's novel and added humor to the storyline.
Pastoral romance-a romantic story that takes place in a rural of forest setting-was a popular category of literature and drama in Shakespeare's time. Love stories of innocent shepherds and shepherdesses and tales of woodland adventure were then in vogue. Shakespeare, a practical man of the theatre, created a play that he knew would appeal to his audience. The wrestling scene and the clowning of the rustic shepherds would have captured the attention of the groundlings, while the sophisticated wordplay would have impressed educated playgoers in the galleries. George Bernard Shaw felt that Shakespeare, in calling the play As You Like It; was commenting disparagingly on standards of contemporary theatrical taste. Yet it seems unlikely that Shakespeare had purely commercial considerations in mind when he wrote this play, for As You Like It does not adhere strictly to the conventions of pastoral romance. It satirizes them as well. The Forest of Arden is in many ways an idealized, fairy tale setting for the play, but it is also a place where "winter and rough weather" present hardships and wild beasts lurk as a threat. Shaw may have been correct, however, in his observation that Shakespeare was losing interest in crowdpleasing comedies. Soon after he wrote As You Like It, Shakespeare abandoned comedy and turned to the composition of his major tragedies.
According to theatrical legend, Shakespeare-an actor as well as a playwright-played the old servant, Adam, when the play was presented by the Lord Chamberlain's Men (later the King's Men), the acting company of which he was a member. We have evidence that suggests this play was performed before King James I in 1603. In all likelihood it remained in the repertory of Shakespeare's company for a number of years after it was written.
As You Like It, although neglected in performance for more than a century after Shakespeare's death in 1616, has been a popular play on the stage ever since. It was revived in England for the first time in 1723 in an adaptation called Love In A Forest. This version of the play interpolated passages from other Shakespearean dramas and comedies, notably A Midsummer Night's Dream. Shakespeare's original was restored to the theatre seventeen years later. In the 19th century As you Like It was staged by a number of eminent English actor-managers including Charles Kean and William Charles Macready. In late nineteenth century America, especially, the play became a favorite with audiences. Rosalind found noteworthy interpreters in Helena Modjeska, Mary Anderson, Ada Rehan, and Julia Marlowe.
More recently, the role of Rosalind has attracted a number of leading actresses including Peggy Ashcroft, Katharine Hepburn, and Vanessa Redgrave. In 1967, the National Theatre of Great Britain staged an all-male production of the play, and in 1991 England's experimental Cheek By Jowl company mounted a similar production. Thus, modern audiences were introduced to a theatrical convention of Shakespeare's time, when young men played all the women's roles. Both productions were well received by audiences and critics and subsequently toured the United States. Also noteworthy is the Renaissance Theatre Company's 1988 Edwardian dress production in London with Kenneth Branagh as Touchstone. Today, when there are more than three hundred Shakespeare festivals worldwide, As You Like It remains one of the Bard's most well-loved and frequently produced comedies.
Expert Q&A
What were the gender roles during Shakespeare's era?
During Shakespeare's era, gender roles were strictly patriarchal, with men seen as ambitious leaders and women as passive caregivers. Men dominated decision-making, owned property, and held professional jobs. Women, though restricted, sometimes managed family businesses and worked in trades. Despite societal norms, many women led active lives, and notable exceptions existed, such as Queen Elizabeth I, who ruled England for a long period.
Places Discussed
*Arden Forest
*Arden Forest. Arden, William Shakespeare’s mother’s maiden name, is also an actual forest north of Stratford. Shakespeare’s forest owes more to associations with Arcadia, the legendary home of pastoral poetry, and with the Garden of Eden than to reality. In this setting the banished Duke Senior and his band of followers find a world free from envy and flattery, where a man can weep for a wounded deer and there are “books in the running brooks” and “sermons in stones.” Separated from society, it is a region of freedom where the banished Rosalind can costume herself as a man and “teach” Orlando how to woo her, and the company of courtiers, exiles, shepherds, and even country bumpkins can mingle and interact with little regard for society’s strictures. It is a haven of song and laughter, of wit and wooing, of acceptance and forgiveness, seasoned only by halfhearted criticism, which vanishes with the multiple weddings in the last act.
Orchard of Oliver’s house
Orchard of Oliver’s house. Customarily a fruitful setting, the first scene of the play serves as an ironic background for the hatred of Oliver toward his younger brother Orlando.
Duke’s palace
Duke’s palace. Although not delineated physically by Shakespeare, the scenes in the palace show a dangerous court ruled by the tyrant Duke Frederick, who arbitrarily banishes his niece Rosalind and threatens both Orlando and Oliver. In this setting the palace paranoia contrasts pointedly with the relaxed harmony of the forest.
Expert Q&A
Who is invited into the Forest of Arden in As You Like It?
In "Under the Greenwood Tree," Jaques and Amiens invite those who lack ambition, enjoy simple pleasures, and have joy in their hearts to the Forest of Arden. This idyllic space is for people who are content with a simple, natural life, having left behind wealth and luxury. They celebrate freedom and happiness while acknowledging the challenges of nature, such as harsh winter. The invitation is extended to free spirits seeking liberation.
Why was life in the Forest of Arden preferable to court life in As You Like It?
The adversity the characters face in Arden is preferable to those at court because the troubles at court are the result of treachery and lies, whereas those in Arden are simply the result of nature being what it is.
The Forest of Arden's Role and Reality in As You Like It
In Shakespeare's As You Like It, the Forest of Arden plays a crucial role as a refuge from the oppressive court, embodying the pastoral ideal of simplicity and healing. It contrasts with the corrupt court life, offering a space for self-discovery and transformation, as seen in characters like Duke Senior and Oliver. The forest is depicted as a "green world," symbolizing freedom and truth, though not without its challenges. While it draws on the real Forest of Arden near Stratford, it may also allude to the Ardennes in Belgium.
Duke Senior's attitude toward life in the Forest of Arden in As You Like It
Duke Senior's attitude toward life in the Forest of Arden is one of contentment and appreciation. He views the forest as a place of freedom and simplicity, contrasting it with the corruption of court life. He finds solace and wisdom in nature, embracing the hardships as opportunities for growth and reflection.
The setting of Shakespeare's As You Like It
The setting of Shakespeare's As You Like It primarily takes place in the Forest of Arden. This pastoral setting serves as a contrasting backdrop to the court life, allowing characters to explore themes of love, identity, and transformation away from societal pressures.
The presentation and definition of the court in As You Like It
In As You Like It, the court is depicted as a place of political intrigue, betrayal, and corruption. It contrasts with the Forest of Arden, which symbolizes natural simplicity and freedom. The court represents the complexities and moral ambiguities of civilized society, while the forest offers a refuge where characters can explore their identities and relationships more authentically.
Modern Connections
Much like many contemporary TV sitcoms, the humor in As You Like It relies on the audience's willingness to suspend disbelief. For instance, we are expected to accept that Duke Senior does not recognize his own daughter when she is in disguise. Similarly, although Orlando does not know Rosalind very well, it seems reasonable to think he would eventually recognize some trait in Ganymede that reminds him of Rosalind. Also paralleling modern sitcoms, Shakespeare's comedy resolves all conflicts swiftly and tidily at the end. The transformations of the initial antagonists, Duke Frederick and Oliver, happen so quickly and conveniently that they stretch credibility. Additionally, the marriage pairings—Oliver with Celia, Phebe with Silvius, and Touchstone with Audrey—seem illogical. Outside the play's confines, one might speculate that these marriages could fail due to the characters' shallow acquaintance with each other. For instance, the marriage between Phebe and Silvius, based on coercion and deception, is far from ideal. As Jaques suggests, the union of Audrey and Touchstone is "but for two months victuall'd" (V.iv.192), implying that their emotional journey is poorly equipped to endure. The true purpose of these neat and quick resolutions, as in modern sitcoms, is to suggest and reinforce social values. In the idealized Elizabethan world of As You Like It, marriage is portrayed as a crucial component of social stability.
The idealized Forest of Arden also serves another purpose; it can be viewed as a critique of Duke Frederick's court and Oliver's hierarchical household. As a pastoral drama, As You Like It employs the pastoral mode, which was commonly used in Shakespeare's time to subtly criticize social institutions. Shepherds are depicted as living a simple life in an idyllic "Garden of Eden" setting, far removed from the ambition and deceit of court and city life. The basic values these shepherds, who live close to nature, express implicitly condemn the artificiality of anything unnatural, competitive, coercive, or hierarchical. In this play, Corin embodies such a pastoral figure, and his simple life philosophy contrasts sharply with the complex and often absurd philosophies of Jaques and Touchstone. The pastoral Forest of Arden provides a space where characters can be their true selves, free from the hidden agendas of others. It is akin to what we might call an emotional refuge from the "rat race" of everyday life, a paradisiacal retreat where one's true nature can emerge.
The Forest of Arden functions on an additional level, serving as a mystical place with religious undertones, as some critics have suggested. Oliver recounts a conflict in the Forest of Arden involving a serpent, often symbolizing evil, and a lioness, which might symbolize Christianity. The appearance of such creatures in what is ostensibly the English countryside is surprising and suggests that the encounter could be interpreted allegorically. Likewise, Duke Frederick meets an "old religious man" (V.iv.160) and subsequently renounces both his worldly ambitions and his plans to forcibly subdue the exiles. On this level, the Forest of Arden represents a spiritual realm, while Duke Frederick's court and Oliver's household symbolize an earthly world governed by human frailty.
As You Like It addresses the concept of time in a way that resonates with our modern era. In the Forest of Arden, there is a sense of timelessness where characters can explore possibilities and live free from the constraints of time. In our own technologically driven age, we are familiar with the pressures and constraints of time's fleeting nature. We also occasionally experience moments of freedom from time's constant presence, those rare, unpressured instances when we can relax and be ourselves. Just like the characters in As You Like It, we have the ability to choose which condition we prefer.
Bibliography and Further Reading
Barber, C. L. Shakespeare's Festive Comedy. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1959.
Berry, Edward. Shakespeare's Comic Rites. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1985.
Bloom, Harold, ed. Major Literary Characters: Rosalind. New York: Chelsea House, 1992.
Bloom, Harold, ed. Modern Critical Interpretation: William Shakespeare's As You Like It. New York: Chelsea House, 1988.
Bonazza, Blaze O. Shakespeare's Early Comedies: A Structural Analysis. The Hague: Mouton, 1966.
Brown, John Russell. Discovering Shakespeare: A New Guide to the Plays. New York: Columbia University Press, 1986.
Bush, Geoffrey. Shakespeare and the Natural Condition. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1956.
Campbell, Oscar James, and Edward G. Quinn, eds. The Reader's Encyclopedia of Shakespeare. New York: Crowell, 1966.
Champion, L. S. The Evolution of Shakespeare's Comedy: A Study in Dramatic Perspective. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1970.
Derrick, Patti S. "Rosalind and the Nineteenth-Century Woman: Four Stage Interpretations." Theatre Survey 26 (November 1985): 143-162.
French, Marilyn. Shakespeare's Division of Experience. New York: Summit Books, 1981.
Frye, Northrop. "Characterization in Shakespeare's Comedy." Shakespeare Quarterly 4 (1953): 271-277.
Granville-Barker, Harley. Prefaces to Shakespeare. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1965/1978.
Grebanier, Bernard. Then Came Each Actor. New York: David McKay, 1975.
Halio, Jay L., and Barbara C. Millard. As You Like It. An Annotated Bibliography, 1940-1980. New York: Garland, 1985.
Kott, Jan. Shakespeare Our Contemporary. Trans. Boleslaw Taborski. Rev. ed. Garden City: Anchor Books, 1966.
McFarland, Thomas. Shakespeare's Pastoral Comedy. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1972.
Nevo, Ruth. Comic Transformations in Shakespeare. New York: Routledge, Chapman & Hall, 1981.
Odell, G. C. D. Shakespeare from Betterton to Irving. 2 vols. New York: Scribner's, 1920.
Palmer, John. Comic Characters of Shakespeare. London: Macmillan, 1946.
Parrott, Thomas M. Shakespearean Comedy. New York: Russell & Russell, 1962.
Partridge, Eric. Shakespeare's Bawdy. Rev. ed. New York: Dutton, 1969.
Reynolds, Peter. Penguin Critical Studies: As You Like It. London: Penguin, 1988.
Shakespeare, William. As You Like It. London: Penguin Books, 1981.
Shaw, John. "Fortune and Nature in As You Like It." Shakespeare Quarterly 6 (1955): 45-50.
Speaight, Robert. Shakespeare On the Stage. Boston: Little, Brown, 1973.
Tillyard, E. M. W. Shakespeare's Early Comedies. London: Athlone Press, 1965.
Van Doren, Mark. Shakespeare. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 1939.
Ward, John Powell. As You Like It: Twayne's New Critical Introductions to Shakespeare. New York: Twayne, 1992.
Wells, Stanley, ed. The Cambridge Companion to Shakespeare. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986.
Wilson, Edwin, ed. Shaw on Shakespeare. New York: Dutton, 1961.
Wilson, John Dover. Shakespeare's Happy Comedies. Evanston: Northwestern University Press, 1962.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.