The Art of the Commonplace

by Wendell Berry

Start Free Trial

"The Body and the Earth" Summary and Analysis

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Our bodies are inextricably connected to farming, to the earth, and to animals’ bodies. We treat our bodies and the earth, then, in similar ways.

In order to be whole, we must recognize the relatively small place of humanity within Creation. The idea of a search for “the human condition” has preoccupied thinkers for a long time, and the wilderness as a place of knowledge has become especially romanticized since the rise of industry. Modern civilization has forgotten the importance of wilderness, viewing it as scenery, and has forgotten the insignificance of humanity, as the magnitude of human technical achievement grows.

Berry has received a letter about a recent suicide, arguing that suicide “belongs in a book about agriculture.” Berry agrees: he argues that there is a connection between what we eat and what we do and how healthy or whole we are. A healthy body is a whole body, but it is not distinct from the bodies of other people, from those of plants and animals, or from the earth. In order to understand health and to heal each other, we must think of the whole picture to which we belong.

When we isolate the body from everything else, a competition is established between body and soul. The body should not be devalued in this way; this sort of division simply causes the “economy” of the body to work in opposition to that of the soul. When we have contempt for the body, it causes us to exploit other bodies, such as those of slaves, women, animals, and the earth itself. The world ceases to be a thriving economic community and instead exists in a state of detrimental competition.

If we divide body and soul, we condemn ourselves to loneliness and decline. In a society that welcomes exploitation, economic and agricultural policy causes soil to be eroded and land to be destroyed in pursuit of short-term economic gain. A lonely soul hopes for salvation, but this makes us feel that our lives are simply spiritual trials.

Body, soul, and world are a community; a farmer who does not understand health makes his farm unhealthy, which results in unhealthy food entering the community. Healing entails the reunification of all the parts of society, drawing them together. Autonomy is often suggested as a “cure” for mental health issues, but actually this insistence on self-reliance just makes the condition worse.

We teach our young people to be “healthy” by striving after impossible beauty ideals and then encouraging those who do not conform to “accept” themselves. But this just causes us to spend our lives dressing and “making up” to compensate for supposed issues that are the inventions of society.

Another division in society caused by division of body and soul is a gender division. If nurture is the domain of women only, we enter an arena in which “practical” work is thought of as male. As society becomes more urban, these divisions become more extreme as men take more part in urban society. Women do housework, and the industrial economy has changed to ensure that this is work that divides a woman from her husband, rather than simply the pair of them contributing equally but differently to a joint household economy. A good farmer, conversely, must be a nurturer, domestic and bound to the household; “progress” makes this work “inferior.”

When the household ceases to be unified, a marriage is no longer a marriage. Sexual love loses its symbolic or “ritualistic force,” becoming simply frivolous and for recreation. Love has become commercialized, and young people do not experience in marriage what they...

(This entire section contains 1138 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

are promised in songs. This leads to competitiveness, jealousy, and divorce. Sexual “capitalism” makes a loved one another person’s property, which in turn makes sex and marriage exploitative.

What is fidelity? Is it a virtue? People are now faithful only out of “superstition” or because they fear retribution. If sexuality is an energy, fidelity is meant to control energy and preserve devotion against “the distractions of novelty.” If we are faithful, we should be able to channel our energies back into the community of the home.

There is a resemblance between how we behave toward each other and toward the earth. If we exploit our bodies and each other, we will exploit the earth. In the Odyssey, Odysseus’s marriage is sacred, legal, and complex; he is one with his wife as he is with his homeland, and the order of the kingdom is connected to the order of his marriage. Odysseus returns from war to affirm the values of farming and domesticity.

Domestic order is threatened by “wildness,” but we still need wilderness. Farms survive and are healthy because wilderness is preserved within them, just as marriages are healthy because wild sexuality is preserved within them—controlled, but still there.

We must care for the earth, then, as we should care for our marriages. Sexuality should be a nurturing force, not the preserve of clinicians and pornographers. Old methods of restraint, both sexual restraint and restraint from overfarming, have been forgotten. Now people expect clinicians to look after their fertility and “experts” to look after the fertility of the earth. Divisions are being perpetuated by modern technology that does not actually preserve the health of either body or land.

Because our agricultural system is based on economics, it endorses competition and causes disintegration and disrepair. Modern society is full of disconnection, which leads to ill health. People do not want to labor for anything, and therefore they have forgotten that they are part of a cycle with the earth and animals and that labor can be its own reward.

Analysis

Berry alludes to Shakespeare and the works of Homer in discussing the ways in which society has begun to disintegrate. His argument that there is, or should be, a unity between our bodies and the world around us reflects an ideology often found in medieval and pre-medieval literature, in which the body of the king, and the health of this body, is intertwined with the health of the land and the body politic. Berry invites the reader to imagine this on a smaller scale: as society becomes more and more removed from connection with the land, our spiritual and physical health both suffer, and we become more disconnected from each other. As a result, because we no longer care deeply or physically about land, having been taught to pursue economic gain rather than to be nurturers, we exploit not only each other but the land around us. Berry here returns to several popular themes, such as that of exploitation being enabled by overcommercialization of people’s bodies, in multiple senses. In Berry’s view, the breakdown of the traditional family unit has also been caused by the breakdown of the unity of body, spirit, and land.

Previous

"Think Little" Summary and Analysis

Next

"Men and Women in Search of Common Ground" Summary and Analysis

Loading...