Arna Bontemps

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

Themes and Tone in Arna Bontemps' Poem "God Give to Men"

Summary:

The main themes in Arna Bontemps' poem "God Give to Men" include equality, justice, and the universal desire for peace and prosperity. The tone of the poem is hopeful yet contemplative, as it reflects on the different needs and desires of people across various cultures and regions, ultimately emphasizing a shared humanity and the longing for a better world.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is a theme in Arna Bontemps' poem "God Give to Men"?

In Arna Bontemps' poem, "God Give to Men," the theme (in my opinion) is a prayer that God will give to men what they want—what most brings them pleasure.

The first stanza reads as follows:

God give the yellow man

an easy breeze at blossom time.

Grant his eager, slanting eyes to cover

every land and dream

of afterwhile.

The imagery paints the picture of an Asian man who would gather great joy in smelling the luscious flowers in his homeland, perhaps cherry blossoms as the scent floats gently over the breeze. The author also wishes that this man will have the opportunity to travel and see lands all over the earth, and also have time to reflect upon these things at a later time—perhaps in old age, a blessing to wish on one.

Whereas the mood and imagery of the first stanza support gentle things like breezes, flowers, travel, knowledge and a time for rest and appreciation, the tone of the second stanza suggest power and military-like strength.

Give blue-eyed men their swivel chairs

to whirl in tall buildings.

Allow them many ships at sea,

and on land, soldiers

and policemen.

The elements of this stanza touch on the power a man would have in a fancy chair in a tall building—like a company executive or the president of a business; in the ocean many ships, though one gets the sense that there are more ships than might really be necessary; and on land, that men can exercise their authority as soldiers or policemen. I can't help feeling after the simplistic and beautiful images presented in the first stanza, that this stanza is about having—and having more. I get the feeling that the things that bring blue-eyed [white] men pleasure involves money and power. The poem implies that the author does not begrudge them what they want, but the implied comparison of the first stanza gives one the feeling that what is wanted is "more" or "the most." And then one might ask, does that really make them happy?

The third stanza speaks of the black man, and the comparison between the first two stanzas and this third one may seem bleak at first glance—or perhaps not bleak at all, but simplistic and enough.

For black man, God,

no need to bother more

but only fill afresh his meed

of laughter, 
his cup of tears.

This part of the prayer notes that the black man does not need much to be fulfilled. He will be satisfied with enough to laugh about, even while facing life's tears...but that God does not need to "bother" to provide more than that. (There is a great sense of humility in the word "bother," as if the man wishes not to put God "out.") This simplistic stanza notes that the black man makes do with what he has or has not, but that he does not need to travel or have power to find joy and satisfaction in his life.

The final couplet provides an open prayer for all men. This would indicate that the previous three stanzas are not written with spite, anger or covetousness. There is nothing hidden in the stanzas of a negative nature. How does the reader know? The final couplet wishes every man—regardless of race, eye-color or shape of eye, regardless of his wealth or position, or on what continent he may find himself—God's grace to allow all men the opportunity to experience that which gives them the greatest joy and satisfaction.

God suffer little men

the taste of soul's desire.

In making this wish for all men, the speaker includes himself, wishing for nothing more or less than any other man.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is a major theme in the poem "God Give to Men" by Arna Bontemps?

The poem is about race and religion. It juxtaposes "the yellow man" and "blue-eyed men," and shows the yellow man to be more spiritual and in touch with important things like nature, happiness and spirituality.

While blue-eyed men have material goods like "swivel chairs
to whirl in tall buildings."  "Yellow men" have emotional goods, like laughter and tears.

Posted on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the tone of Arna Bontemps' poem "God Give to Men"?

This poem is written in a very bitter, ironic tone. We can identify the tone by considering the subject matter of the poem and the choice of words that are used to convey that subject matter. Clearly, if we look at this poem carefully, there is massive grim irony in what it says, and in particular in the stereotypical representations of different ethnicities. The second stanza is of course one of the most ironic, as it presents the white man in comparison to other races:

Give blue-eyed men their swivel chairs

to whirl in tall buildings.

Allow them many ships at sea,

and on land,

soldiers

and policemen.

The idea of God being involved in something so trivial as giving white men swivel chairs to use in their "tall buildings" is ironic until we remember that this poem is actually a comment on racial inequality and the way in which certain races have so much and others have so little. The bitterness and anger therefore emerges when the "black man" is refered to, and God is asked only to "fill afresh his meed / with laughter / his cup with tears." The way in which the position of blacks in the world is reflected and how they need nothing else except more laughter and tears, clearly conveys the angry tone.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on